3 ms·
It entirely depends on the measure. Low-level gang members get their raw deal from being systematically trapped in their situation. Go to jail, get out of jail
by mindslight 10y ago
It entirely depends on the measure.
Low-level gang members get their raw deal from being systematically trapped in their situation. Go to jail, get out of jail, find no other opportunities, repeat.
Punishment divided by harm-caused obviously goes to drug users, being infinite.
Hacking has stiff criminal penalties for many things that should be civil matters at best, precisely because it makes powerful people realize how tenuous their control actually is.
Let's not succumb to identity pity politics about who has it the "worst". Each codified injustice is ultimately the result of a ruling class slowly eroding the rule of law for its own benefit.
(Also, I'm pretty sure the definition of "hacker" does not imply "white dude")
- AnimalMuppet 10y ago> Punishment divided by harm-caused obviously goes to drug users, being infinite. That defines the harm as being zero. I'm not sure that's the case. Some drugs (angel dust, at a minimum) greatly increase the user's propensity for violence. And the argument for saying "they haven't done anything yet, so arrest them for the violence when they do it" is similar to saying "drunk drivers haven't caused any harm yet, so wait until they cause a crash before you arrest them". The harm to others is (for drunk driving and some drugs) too likely to follow to simply wait for it to occur.
- mindslight 10y agoDriving while under the influence creates a condition where one can cause harm with no further intent. General being under the influence does not, to the limit of philosophical zombies. Furthermore, any drug user's increased propensity towards $whatever is going to correspond to the dosage they've taken. Criminalization of the substance itself is still not implied, just as driving with a trunk full of beer is fine. And there still exists the correlated crime-by-association [0] of public intoxication. [0] Observe how the legal cancer spreads based not on true misdeeds, but on ancillary behaviors that are simply correlated to misdeeds. But if correlation were sufficient justification, then profiling based on skin color and lack of political connection would also be perfectly acceptable! Since the entire point of the rule of law is to protect the long tail of individual outliers, creating avenues to arbitrarily persecute people by association is its destruction.