3 ms·
This seems to be an extremely glass-half-full view. The other view is that what would have otherwise been "non-people's" OS contributions now belong to the peo
by epistasis 10y ago
This seems to be an extremely glass-half-full view.
The other view is that what would have otherwise been "non-people's" OS contributions now belong to the people. All these "corporate" coders are putting code out in the open. Isn't this better than everybody working on closed-source kernels?
Those that are violating the GPL would have done what instead? License a closed-source kernel? Use a BSD and not contribute back?
Even though corporate Linux may not always co-align with my interests as a user, it seems to align at least as much as any non-corporate dev who's contributing to Linux. I'm only one person, but the GPL projects that don't have full-time or at least paid maintainers seem to align with my interests as a user with the same or less frequency as the ones with a corporate maintainer.
So I'm not sure that corporate/non-corporate is a useful distinction for this.
>They are keenly aware that if Linux takes a hardline GPL approach it will gain the reputation of being unfriendly to corporations. That perception will kill Linux in the long run.
I'm not sure I agree with either of these statements, to be honest. Those corporations that are violating the license aren't contributing back to Linux anyway; so losing them won't kill Linux. And Google or other corporate Linux sponsors are not going to be scared away by having to conform to the GPL.
- khedoros 10y ago> Those corporations that are violating the license aren't contributing back to Linux anyway; so losing them won't kill Linux. I don't think that's what the grandparent was worried about. If the kernel developers defend the GPL too ardently, some companies that currently contribute, or that are considering contribution, may be worried about violating the license and decide that it's in their best interests to avoid Linux altogether. I agree that it wouldn't actually kill Linux, but it could potentially do more harm than good by scaring away potential contributors that are a little more on the fence.