4 ms·
I'll stick my head above the parapet and say that I partially support Apple in this. They negotiated particularly sweet deal with the Irish government and got i
by Angostura 10y ago
I'll stick my head above the parapet and say that I partially support Apple in this. They negotiated particularly sweet deal with the Irish government and got it. The EU has now said tha the deal is incompatible with EU law. I don't particularly blame Apple for the attempt, if anything I rather think it is the Irish Government who were a bit naughty.
I'm conflicted on whether Apple should pay back the sum - it would seem fairer to me to simply agree that 'This Stops Now'.
- jbmorgado 10y agoLook, if I negotiate with the state of Texas that I will not pay taxes in the state of New York for doing business there and then get fined by the state of New York for not paying my due taxes there, you will say I was stupid and it suits me right. It's exactly the same with what Apple did.
- sudhirj 10y agoMore like the federal government telling you ten years later that you and Texas shouldn't have made that concession to you and asking you to retroactively pay back taxes for the last ten years.
- yardie 10y agoThat is exactly what the IRS does. Do you think businesses want to keep 7 years of transactions? No, they do not. And if they fail an audit it increases to 10 years.
- ascorbic 10y agoIt's not quite the same. The tax isn't owed to the EU, it is owed to Ireland. As far as I'm aware this sort of deal is not only legal, but common in the U.S. The rules broken here are the ones against excessive "state aid". These are defined as selective advantages given to companies. The treaties forbid these as anti-competitive. This mainly applies to subsidies to individual companies, but also covers sweetheart tax deals like these that aren't open to all companies. They're welcome to set low corporate tax rates, but not to approve convoluted structures like these. Stuff like Tesla's deal with Nevada would be illegal in the EU.
- boudin 10y agoAs everybody, when you didn't pay your due taxes, you're asked to pay for what's due. And basically every law applies to past actions... I don't get why Apple would have a special treatment. Apple deal with Irish government was illegal regarding access to EU free market. If Apple is not happy with that, they can open a business in every EU country, pay local taxes in each of those and keep their deal with Ireland only for the Irish narket. I don't even get how anybody could defend Apple on this. You're get caught trying to cheat, you pay what's due, that's as simple as that. The fact that the Irish governemt took part in this illegal deal is another problem that should also be pursued by EU.
- charlesdm 10y agoIt would indeed be much more reasonable to say, "this stops now" + giving Apple, say, 12 months to restructure their affairs. Second, if that poorly Irish designed piece of tax law wouldn't have existed, they might have structured things differently. Even if Apple is to pay the €13bn, you can assume they will sue the Irish state for the exact same amount in damages. If the EU wants to harmonise tax law, they should focus on that. But I'd be curious to see if it will ever happen, given member states don't want that. The state aid mechanic is the only thing they have to perhaps combat avoidance a bit. But if you only have a hammer... Well, just look at Vestager - that's exactly what happens. I wonder, has she challenged Danish tax mechanics?
- Erwin 10y agoCases like that often appear when EU country does something that's consider a subsidy. A criteria is selective enforcement/favoritising of one company. If Ireland said: come to Ireland and pay 0.005% corporate tax, that would be fine by EU competition law. Last year the big Danish energy company DONG (recently privatized and entered the stock market) was investigated but found not in violation. Here's an exciting article about it: http://europa.eu/rapid/press-release_IP-16-1885_en.htm http://europa.eu/rapid/press-release_IP-16-1885_en.htm These cases take years to investigate. So no, Vestager is not selectively helping Denmark; you are looking at the wrong country for corruption.
- charlesdm 10y agoDon't get me wrong, I think it's good to use the state aid mechanic as a way to combat unfair competition. But I think retroactively applying it for 15 years is wrong, and displays incompetence. These breaks have existed for years, and it's not like the EU didn't know about them. Most countries don't even have national laws that allow recovering of taxes after 5-7 years. I recently read in the newspapers she's also investigating Belgian harbours, because for some reason, they're exempt from paying corporate tax. HOWEVER, if she'd rule against it, she would be unable to force the Belgian government to recoup that money, because that tax break existed even from before the EU was founded..
- sharemywin 10y agoI would feel more sympathetic if they weren't sitting on 200B not doing anything. Waiting for the US to allow them to bring it back into the US for very little in taxes.