2 ms·
The problem, as the commenters to that question note, is that no one is really sure what it means to be "well read" anymore. Louis Menand talks about how the en
by jseliger 17y ago
The problem, as the commenters to that question note, is that no one is really sure what it means to be "well read" anymore. Louis Menand talks about how the end of the consensus on the "canon" or lack thereof has played in universities (and their requirements) in The Marketplace of Ideas: where he notes that only a few schools, including Columbia, still have "great books" courses grandfathered in. (See my post here: http://jseliger.com/2010/01/21/problems-in-the-academy-louis-menands-the-marketplace-of-ideas-reform-and-resistance-in-the-american-university/ http://jseliger.com/2010/01/21/problems-in-the-academy-louis... for more on the book).
Anyway, as a consequence most people, with the exception of Harold Bloom and some other literary conservatives, don't know what should be in the canon, or would rather fight about what it means to have a canon than to read it. This is in part related to the larger question of how English and humanities types think; there's a decent book on that subject called How Professors Think, which deals with the legitimacy crisis in English.
That's from an academic angle. As for what I think, I'm not all that impressed by the idea of reading things merely because they have been read, and therefore going from Plato to Don Quixote to Austen to Dickens to James to Joyce to Roth; to my mind, being well-read means reading books that are interesting, unusual, show something new about the world, and so forth, whether they're canonical or not. To me, very little fiction is of real interest before 1900—yet a lot of it is part of the "canon," that I have to put scare quotes around. Do you want to read that, or excellent modern novels that have, in my view, improved on what has been, like Ian McEwan's Atonement, or most of Robertson Davies' work, or Ursula K. Le Guin's better novels (like Earthsea), or Carlos Ruiz Zafon's recent novels (which are very highly plotted and very fascinating), or Umberto Eco's The Name of the Rose, or, or, or...
As you can tell from the way I've structured my response, I'd prefer the latter. To my mind, being well read means reading a lot and reading meaningfully—not reading a particular set of books.