7 ms·
France: Open Access Law Adopted
- julien_c 10y agoI worked on this law!
- semi-extrinsic 10y agoSo, if I'm reading this correctly, the law gives any government/EU funded author the right to publish a preprint for any scientific article they produce, even when a journal has a license forbidding such publication? But it does not require an author to do so, right?
- pikzen 10y agoIf a scientific article has been funded by at least 50% by the state, public establishments, local collectivities or the european union and is published in a review coming out at least once a year, the author (or authors, provided they all agree) have a right to put up, for free and in an open format, the final version of this article on the Internet. So, not just a preprint, and yes, journal licenses forbidding such publication have now no legal value. It does not require the author to do so. EDIT: see answer below for a few more precisions.
- p4bl0 10y agoWell, that's not exactly right. It's a bit less cool. The author's right to put their articles in open access is not immediate, it happens at the soonest of: — when the publisher make the article freely available itself, or — 6 months after initial publication in sciences, or 12 months in humanities.
- mlinksva 10y agoOh, the humanities
- igravious 10y agoWhy, the difference? I'd like that legally challenged.
- p4bl0 10y agoThe difference exists because in the humanities the situation is very different from science. Publishers are a lot smaller and more locals, they often have a real added value (the vast majority of humanities academics do not produce camera ready PDFs themselves), and are thus a lot less predatory.
- jnicholasp 10y agoTurning an article into a clean PDF is a sufficient value addition to deserve an extra six months of exclusive license? As a humanities type who nevertheless despises the academic uselessness of the realm, let me suggest that the extra six months is given to humanities papers because nothing that happens in them matters, and any value that anyone can contrive to get from them, they deserve to keep. But maybe that's a little too harsh. Is anything valuable coming out of the humanities these days?
- igravious 10y agoNo, it's because of the narrative that nothing that happens in the humanities matters. > Is anything valuable coming out of the humanities these days? You know, back in the late 19th century things were the other way around. The sciences had to argue for their value while the humanities held sway over the mind-share in academia. Google the debates of Huxley and Arnold -- many people think the culture clash only goes back to the C.P.Snow era, as if. A part of the problem with the humanities is its amnesia. The humanities sprang from humanism. The humanities is academic humanism. Secular humanism is what has given us the idea of the separation of Church and State, among many other society-altering changes. Academic humanism has been a great moderating influence on the world, and continues to be. The smartest people I meet in academia are in the humanities, not the sciences. It is only relatively recently the the notion that the sciences are pre-eminent came to be. Since the time of their birth in the Renaissance the humanities grew in the shadow of the theological scholastics, and then brought about the Enlightenment. Which was nice. You've bought into a narrative. The humanities teaches us about how narratives and ideologies shape our minds, so your comment dismays me. edit: I don't blame you though. I was in the humanities for nearly 10 years before I bothered to look into the history and philosophy of humanism and the humanities.
- untilHellbanned 10y agoWait in the US this already happens, so is this law just France catching up to the US?
- Loic 10y agoYes, but you know, France is within the EU, this means you have a precedent in the EU which is very good to have other countries within the EU joining the party. Once you have 3 big countries doing so, because papers have usually authors from many institutions around the EU, nearly all the papers will have a way to get freed. And this is good.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ced 10y agoWhat did you do?
- nmc 10y agoHe is an advisor to Axelle Lemaire, French Deputy Minister of Digital Affairs.
- scoot 10y agoWhere's the downvote button when you need it?
- grive 10y agowhy?
- hk__2 10y ago> and it still needs to be voted on by the Sénat on September 27 So technically it hasn’t been adopted yet.
- pygy_ 10y agoThe French Senate can at most delay the adoption of a new law. The Assemblée Nationale has the final say and can overrule any modification made by the Senate. While the lower chamber could have a change of mind, it is very unlikely to happen.
- readams 10y agoWhat would stop journals from blacklisting scientists who publish their articles under open access laws? Would anyone publish their article if they knew it meant never being able to publish in Nature again?
- dragonwriter 10y ago> What would stop journals from blacklisting scientists who publish their articles under open access laws? Nothing; of course, that just hastens the death of the journal system.
- ZenoArrow 10y agoWhat difference would that make? Getting into journals like Nature is about getting research shared amongst fellow researchers. The value that journals add is in curating interesting research so a busy scientist can still keep up to date with the key developments in the field. With open access it'll be easier than ever for new curators to emerge.
- hackuser 10y agoThe value that journals provide is identifying high-value research for other scientists to read, and also for the researchers' employers and funders who use it as a basis to decide whether to hire the researchers, give them tenure, or fund them.
- ZenoArrow 10y ago> "The value that journals provide is identifying high-value research for other scientists to read" As I said before, curation. > "and also for the researchers' employers and funders who use it as a basis to decide whether to hire the researchers, give them tenure, or fund them." If that's true, sounds like it's time for the processes around hiring of science staff to get an overhaul.
- Aaargh20318 10y ago> The value that journals provide is identifying high-value research for other scientists to read No, it's other scientists who do that for the journals, for free. They can just as well do it for any other publication. The only value journals add is printing it on a piece of paper. So basically they provide the same value as a €30 Deskjet.
- ramblenode 10y agoThis is excellent news. The people of a country should absolutely have access to the research they have funded. France has taken an important step in standing up to the anachronistic publishing cartels who siphon public money in order to lock down rather than disseminate knowledge. Here's to hoping the rest of the world follows this example.
- mighty_atomic_c 10y agoAgreed! Although it may take a long time to get there...
- paul_f 10y agoWithout taking a side in the discussion, we should make a distinction between the research and the subsequent paper. The government funding is for the research. Scholarly papers are created for publication, not to meet the requirements of the research funding.
- lago 10y agoi think the purpose of government funding is both for research and a public communication of its effects. is it not the effects (a carefully designed text / 'publication') we should share with the stakeholders? a public mandate is a reasonable strategy for sustaining quality research, in contrast to a money wall filter system.
- aargh_aargh 10y agoThat would be unpractical. You already cannot copyright the ideas (the research). You can patent it, but the issue addressed here is specifically copyright. The thing is, for the last hundred years or so, publications have been the communication channel about research, so the two are often conflated (for the most part) - most importantly in science evaluation, which is where the money comes from, so research without publishing is not incentivized at all.
- ramblenode 10y agoThis isn't an important distinction to the research process up until a paper is accepted for publication, so perhaps asserting ownership of any eventual publications in the grant's terms is a minimally disruptive way to bring publications into the public domain. Already it's the case that researchers conduct research and agencies award grants with the intent that any useful or interesting results will be published, so I don't see any material changes happening in research itself if this "loophole" were closed.
- Grazester 10y agoPhew! With just reading the title of this I thought the article would have been something stating France just made encryption illegal without a way for law enforcement to circumvent it
- tzakrajs 10y agoHow about the right to free speech? It may be a useful step in making information accessible.
- igravious 10y agoThe legal right or the human right? If you're referring to the legal right, to which jurisdiction are you referring? If to the human right, that's a social justice issue not a legal one.
- analognoise 10y agoHuman rights have become "social justice" issues and not legal ones? Are you trying to draw a distinction between the implementation and the theory of the thing, because I'm failing to see law not being both, with the unfortunate secondary label of "social justice" being entirely useless.
- igravious 10y agoIs it too corny to say, "vive la liberté!" ? Well done France. It's little moments like these that give one faith in humanity. I think I'm going to start calling them Snowden moments. :)
- imadfy 10y agoWhat do they mean by "...cannot be commercially exploited?" Would a for-profit corporation be violating copyright just by viewing it? What are the punishments for "commercial exploit[ation]"?
- aargh_aargh 10y agoDespite the unclear wording, the intention here is clearly to protect the commercial publisher who is otherwise being harmed by this law (the author usually gives some exclusive distribution rights to the publisher and this law changes that by declaring this exclusivity void and mandating open access, perhaps via a parallel publishing channel).
- Loic 10y agoThe translation is not good, so a "shorter" version: 1. If you publish your research work in a journal and the research work has been financed for at least 50% by public institutions, you can provide on the web for free your paper too (if the coauthors agree). You are allowed to put it online directly if the journal is a free/open access journal or after 6 to 12 months. 2. A publisher cannot prevent you to do that. 3. You cannot use these available papers to make money out of them with a service similar to a publisher "une activité d'édition à caractère commercial". Basically, to prevent competition with the original publisher. So, you cannot create a big website with both the papers and advertising. If you are a company getting access to the paper through the university website or the website of the author, this is fine. Wikipedia could start collecting and make the papers available too. Punishments will be set by a judge according to the French civil law on copyrights I suppose.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- d3ckard 10y agoThat's great news. Hopefully it will set an example. Everything that is state founded should be available to everybody (sans few exceptions like defense systems etc.). Hopefully more countries will follow and policy will be adopted in more areas than just scientific writing.
- brador 10y agoThe right but not the obligation?
- johncolanduoni 10y agoI don't think the primary barrier to open access is the willingness of the researchers to self-publish, as long as they can still publish in any journal that they want. Seems like a very sensible trade-off to make the law easier to pass. I'm somewhat worried about what publishers might try to do to dissuade them, but everything I can think of would involve messing heavily with the peer review process which is fairly dangerous.
- jernfrost 10y agoCongratulations France!!! I hope we follow you in Norway, although I don't quite know what our current law on the matter is :-D It is of big importance that large rich countries like France does this. It should have a strong influence on other countries. The ultimate goal is of course for the US to implement such a law as the US is the worlds most influential and important country, especially within research.
- husamia 10y agogreat news!
- junipergreen 10y agoI'm curious. Does this apply to just French journals? Or just French scientists? How would that work with journals based in other countries? Or multi-national research collaborations?