11 ms·
Graduate Students, the Laborers of Academia
- rubidium 10y agoI'd never heard of the 2-week grade strike at Yale. That's bold. My experience at a state-school, tier 1 research university was that the grad student TA workload varied greatly by department. I calculated I was making just under $25/hr while there with the time I put into TA responsibilities. It wasn't too bad. Some friends in humanities were swamped though. Most because they cared a lot and spent a ton of time grading carefully.
- beachstartup 10y ago> Some friends in humanities were swamped though. Most because they cared a lot and spent a ton of time grading carefully. huh, strange. for undergrad i went to a "good" UC and this is the opposite of what i saw in my humanities TAs. they either didn't give a shit and handed out A's like candy or graded on a rubric (i.e. did student posit counter-argument in paragraph N and support with primary sources in p. N+1) while paying little attention to content. either way they certainly didn't seem stressed... unlike the STEM ta's... who were literally going gray in their mid 20s and clearly drank a lot.
- karmajunkie 10y agoAt least these days, most grad students and adjuncts depend heavily on student feedback for their continued jobs. It creates a perverse incentive for sure.
- jseliger 10y agoA very perverse incentive: https://jakeseliger.com/2015/01/13/what-incentivizes-professors-to-grade-honestly-nothing/ https://jakeseliger.com/2015/01/13/what-incentivizes-profess.... It also creates an incentive to avoid anything that could be considered remotely controversial, as I discovered the hard way a while ago. I was fine, but I didn't have to be.
- analog31 10y agoI think the same incentive is present in the "real world." As a manager, it was in my short term self interest to inflate performance reviews. The company was aware of this, and imposed quotas, which only amplified the incentive but made the reviews less effective and more political.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- slavik81 10y agoIf you catch a student cheating, they may also give you a terrible evaluation as payback. If the response rate is low enough, that can actually have an impact on whether you get to TA again. Those jobs are how many students fund their post-grad, which makes rocking the boat dangerous.
- jccalhoun 10y agoThe schools I'm at might be different but in my experience the student evals aren't the deciding factor in employment. They are important and I was once talked to because of a poor student eval (although in that same meeting she said she wanted me to help out in course instructor meetings since I had taught the class several times and wanted me to mentor the new grads. It was a confusing meeting...) and I saw a fellow grad student come under a lot of scrutiny for some odd teaching (I really think the guy was bipolar) but there was never any fear that you wouldn't be able to teach next year. I'm currently an adjunct at another school and luckily my evals have been quite positive overall so I haven't had to worry about it here.
- vthallam 10y agoGlad the NLRB gave decision in favor of the student unions. Though it is true that unionization in universities "would threaten to undermine the primary relationship, that of student to professor, advisee to mentor" , the grad students wouldn't have had to do this if the private universities with billions of dollars in endowments refused to provide basic and reasonable incentives. NYU, for example only recently increased min pay to $15 per hour up from $10 after the union fought for like 2 years. It's a double edged sword to allow unions in universities, but given the state now, perhaps it's wise that they allowed them.
- trhway 10y ago>but given the state now exactly. With number and salaries of administrators (and various non-education positions like sport coaches, etc.) swelling, i don't see why the grads performing the actual labor of education, serving direct business purpose of universities/colleges, shouldn't be let in on their share of the pie.
- pnathan 10y agoA barely-adequate salary for a BS in CS in some rather awful location is 50K. The _top end_ salaries for grad students are about 30K nationally. Most are in the 15-20K range. Many times, grad students can qualify for food stamps and other forms of welfare. I would suggest that "professional median salary for holder of degree with 0-3 years experience" is the rubric that should be applied for compensation. More for relevant experience. Of course, that would entirely shatter the entire US academic system, since it is, today, built on the backs of grad students working in penury (often having a blast, it must be said). The entire current system is built around VERY cheap willing labor. a remark: grad students working for nil and startup employees working for nil have a facially similar appearance. The difference is the startup employees should have some fat options to compensate. The grad students don't have any upside...
- rahulnair23 10y agoGrad students are absolutely that. During my grad student days in a STEM program at a large state university, professors were occasionally able to "buy-out" of their regular course load and forfeit a percentage of their salary. The department head would then hunt for the next best thing - usually an unsuspecting grad research assistant to cover the offering.
- pgbovine 10y agoThat's not exactly how it works. Professors can use grant money to buy out of teaching; they are not forfeiting their base salary. That money will be (indirectly) used to fund other instructors, which may be grad students. It's not like the department head forces an unsuspecting grad student to teach; if they choose to teach, they will be paid for their teaching (tuition + stipend) so that they do not need to be funded by their advisor's grants. The money has to come from somewhere.
- mountaineer22 10y agoSo, the student gets the class at a discount?
- Kephael 10y agoTypically the student gets their classes for free, plus a stipend on top of that.
- microDude 10y agoI think they meant, "Does the 'undergraduate' student get a discount for a class that is being taught by a Graduate Student rather then the original faculty staff". As everyone here knows, NO.
- mattkrause 10y agoYou don't always get paid--a lot of programs require 2-3 semesters of TA duty, even if you don't need the funding. That said, I found teaching to be pretty fun and helpful in solidifying my own understanding so it was helpful (but I'm sure the school also likes the free labor).
- ben_jones 10y agoAt the University of Oregon it seems almost a yearly occurrence that grad students strike, usually a week or two before finals need to be graded. I'm apathetic to the ordeal because whether its administrators, professors, or grad students, getting payed, I'm still stuck paying an egregious tuition. That said in every department except for the Math department both professors and GTFs (graduate-teaching-fellows) have been top notch and gone above and beyond their duties to educate.
- nickfrostatx 10y agoYou can always drop out if you feel the tuition is too high. We can talk all day about how much it ought to cost, but clearly you feel it's worth it to stay enrolled.
- ben_jones 10y agoYou can always avoid hospitals if you feel the cost is too high. We can talk all day about how much it ought to cost, but clearly you feel your health is worth it for continued check-ups.
- argonaut 10y agoYour analogy doesn't work, because of the existence of Medicaid. And the fact that emergency rooms must treat you no matter what.
- mac01021 10y agoEgregious? http://financialaid.oregonstate.edu/review_costofattendance http://financialaid.oregonstate.edu/review_costofattendance
- ben_jones 10y agoEgregious. http://www.collegedata.com/cs/data/college/college_pg03_tmpl.jhtml?schoolId=755 http://www.collegedata.com/cs/data/college/college_pg03_tmpl...
- pm90 10y agoFrom various anecdotal evidence and talking to other graduate students (and going to Graduate School myself), it seems like the experiences vary a lot, and they seem to depend a lot on the amount of funding a field or a professor can attract. For me personally, I had to teach one semester as a TA, but the Prof. I worked with was extremely helpful, and would pitch in to help when the workload was too much. After that, all my semesters were spent as an RA, which is a pretty awesome job if you work in the lab of a good professor and on an interesting project, which I did. And many of my friends pursuing graduate degrees in engineering seem to be in a similar position.
- danielmorozoff 10y agoAs you said 'good professor'. It seems prestigious != good these days, even though prestigious does bring in money and can simplify a number of problems. From what I have seen in STEM at 'top' research institutions the true delineating factor is the professor/group you work in, money/grants is a second and project is 3rd.
- _delirium 10y agoI agree, although I think that's always been true to some extent, so I don't know if I'd add "these days". There are stories going back centuries of famous professors who were also famously jerks and horrible mentors. Some people are great at advancing math or chemistry (or [insert subject]) but really bad at mentoring new students. Other people are great at teaching the current knowledge and mentoring but not particularly amazing at advancing it. Others are great at one-on-one mentoring and research but kind of meh at teaching in a big lecture-hall setting. Still others can give great, engaging lectures to large audiences but are not so good at one-on-one mentorship. Top universities of course want to claim they're full of the unicorns, professors who are top-5% in all of: disciplinary research and interpersonal kindness and large-classroom teaching and 1-on-1 mentorship. But the odds are any individual will not be equally good at all of those tasks.
- danielmorozoff 10y ago
- cup 10y agoI've always thought that PhD students should band together and refuse to run experiments for one week. The shock that might have on the current academic system, when administrators, managers, supervisors and project leaders start to realise that their careers depend on a constant supply of dependent serfs might shake things up.
- hga 10y agoThere's always more willing serfs where they came from, especially after the NSF started overfilling the pipeline in the mid-late '80s insisting there was a terrible shortage of them. Of course, they just wanted to spend less money on scientific labor, and things like bringing in many foreigners helped that, while making the job even less attractive to natives.
- twblalock 10y agoThere is no shortage of delusional people eager to sign up for this kind of serfdom.
- flowereaterz 10y agoProbably not too dissimilar to the delusional early employees who sign up for a startup hoping to make millions from their shares...
- twblalock 10y agoThat depends. Are the grad students making six-figure incomes while they suffer through the experience, as the startup employees do?
- flowereaterz 10y agoThey are not. But are startup employees doing something meaningful, or building their own reputations and expertise? And since you're talking about software startup employees, probably the closest comparison is CS phd students, who are nowhere near suffering. The vast majority of graduate students are at least as satisfied as a developer, otherwise whole programs would have disappeared decades ago from inability to recruit. New admits always ask current graduate students what it's like. There seems to be this dissonance between people here on Hacker News believing that everything is like the horror stories of grad students being abused by psychopathic advisors and at best will get poorly paid adjunct positions before burning out, and what's really happening.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- howandwhy 10y agoit should be written as "Cheap Labor". I can vouch this as I went to graduate school where I worked for 5 years at 8-10 hours/day including Saturday and Sunday for $12,000/year to get a PhD in Biological Science. And it was in one of the most expensive state in US. So could not afford to start a family because of perpetual state of sharing apartment and not enough money and time to go out and find a partner. And at the end I was very delighted to get a post-doc position for $40,000 year at a small town. After working for few years I was burn out due to constant pressure/stress of writing grant to bring money instead of doing real research so ended of quitting science. Now working in a completely different field with much better work-life balance and great salary. Now a days every time I meet an aspirant scientist ready to jump for PhD, I have just one suggestion to them. If you can get into top 2-3 school then go. Else do not waste your time and energy.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- howandwhy 10y agoThe fundamental principle about doing science has changed. It has come from becoming a true scientist(born with natural curiosity towards natures, physics, understanding and exploring fundamentals principles of physics, life and matter) to bread butter scientist where you are pigeon holed into a cubicle writing grants all day and tinkering a very narrow part of a huge field to collect as much data possible so that you can put it in your next grant proposal. Oh by the way, do not forget to teach undergrad, grade their papers and sprinkle some tenure pressure, department politics into it and your life as a scientist is complete.
- auxym 10y agoI don't know if you were downvoted because of the cynical tone, but that sounds pretty accurate in my experience. It's why I quit after a master's.
- btdiehr 10y agoAcademics spend a lot of time on the internet defending their poor decision of going into academia, as well as anyone who points out how obviously fruitless academia is. For most people it's nearly impossible to admit something they just dedicated a large portion of their life too was completely worthless. (standard disclaimer statement that of course there are exceptions to the trend.)
- makecheck 10y agoA couple of anecdotes that really drive me crazy. One, the amount of money universities can shovel at athletics is insane. It cannot be justified, I don’t care how many reasons you come up with. They pay millions to build stadiums, pay coaches, etc. while throwing chump change at people doing academic work. I have also seen hundreds of thousands of dollars thrown at things like ugly artwork and statues. Two, the “chump change” I spoke of doesn’t even come close to scaling with cost of living. I don’t even know how there can be students in cities where housing costs are out of control, unless they are the children of millionaires.
- harryh 10y agoAt least for schools with successful football or men's basketball teams athletics are generally run as basically break even programs. The money brought in by those two sports funds everything else. And that doesn't even take into account the large alumni donations that big time sports programs can bring to a school. Here, for example, is the University of Michigan 2015 budget (the first one I found googling): https://record.umich.edu/articles/michigan-athletics-presents-fiscal-year-2015-budget https://record.umich.edu/articles/michigan-athletics-present... Revenues: $151 million Expenses: $145.9 million
- ikeyany 10y agoSchools like Michigan are the exception. Try Oregon State, or UNLV, or a school not known for resounding success in several sports.
- dalke 10y agoOregon State - 24% subsidized sports program - http://projects.huffingtonpost.com/projects/ncaa/subsidy-scorecards/oregon-state-university http://projects.huffingtonpost.com/projects/ncaa/subsidy-sco... . UNLV - 55% subsidized - http://projects.huffingtonpost.com/projects/ncaa/subsidy-scorecards/university-of-nevada-las-vegas http://projects.huffingtonpost.com/projects/ncaa/subsidy-sco... . Then there's Eastern Michigan University, 83% subsidized (at $24M/year) - http://projects.huffingtonpost.com/projects/ncaa/subsidy-scorecards/eastern-michigan-university http://projects.huffingtonpost.com/projects/ncaa/subsidy-sco... . With 13K undergrads, that's $2,000/student/year. That report points out that some 3/4ths of school have a 25% or more subsidy on their programs.
- finid 10y agoHere's where I stand on this: Without the opportunity I was given to serve as one of those "Laborer of Academia" during my time, I'd still be paying student loans. Three years of grad school and I didn't owe a dime at the end.
- jrkelly 10y agoGetting a PhD was one of the best decisions I ever made. You have your whole life to go optimize for making $ if you want afterwards. At a top research school in the right lab you get a 1:1 apprenticeship with a world-class expert in an area of science you are passionate about. They take 1 or 2 new apprentices a year. It's a unique experience and changed me dramatically for the better. Postdocs are a different story (only do that if you are sure you want to be a professor) but I recommend getting a PhD to anyone passionate about an area of bleeding edge hard science or engineering.
- dluan 10y agoYour view is a bit rare these days. Nearly all my friends who started PhD's who've dropped out or quit early with a master's wasn't because they didn't get this experience. They all loved doing the science, that's the fun part. It's just that as a young scientist it's so clear looking down at the end of the tunnel that the light keeps stretching further away. Grants, tenure, and politics are the new extracurriculars needed to show you're capable of being a scientist. Being at a top research school probably helped, but the majority of grad students in this country are not at those types of homes.
- jrkelly 10y agoAgree the professor track is tough but a PhD is a great idea even if you don't want to be a professor. It's just a unique experience that both gets you deep in a specific area of science and teaches you how to conduct open-ended research in general.
- _lpa_ 10y agoI haven't regretted doing my PhD in the slightest. I've learned a huge amount, in a wide variety of areas. However, the system in the UK is a bit more favourable regarding funding. Having said that, the funding doesn't scale with location. I live in one of the most expensive cities in the UK (outside London), and am funded to the same level as everyone else outside of London. The bigger problem I have is in deciding to leave academia. There are still questions I would like to know the answer to (and I expect there always would be). It just doesn't seem to make sense to take that path. Low pay, high competition, and the likelihood of being on a series of 18month contracts for the majority of your career. Indeed, in my specific field (Bioinformatics) the career path isn't even that well defined, and you can more easily get a job at a software company who will pay several multiple of what you could expect as a postdoc. It just doesn't make sense to do it.
- chrisbennet 10y agoQuestion: How can it possibly be illegal to get together with others to bargain? What is the rationale? If I and my fellow students/etc want to boycott something, compare notes on pay, share legal actions, or protest shouldn't that be protected by law? I'm not a fan of unions or political parties but it blows my mind that the legality of organizing with others is even a question.
- bo1024 10y agoI think unions involve a lot more than that. (Correct me if I'm wrong.) For instance, the decisions a union makes or negotiates for may affect all other workers even if they aren't part of the union.
- chrisbennet 10y agoOK, that make sense.