3 ms·
The big issue with a photo finish on this for me is I bet the starts weren't accurate to 2cm. I'd also wonder if the camera was fixed to avoid that margin of pa
by notahacker 10y ago
The big issue with a photo finish on this for me is I bet the starts weren't accurate to 2cm. I'd also wonder if the camera was fixed to avoid that margin of parallax error, which is much easier on a small running track than a wide expanse of water.
Still, that photo-finish is a paragon of fairness and clarity compared with the Olympic marathon swimming, in which after swimming in the sea for 10k, it all came down to who could "strongly" touch one of a few small pads on a beam suspended above their heads on a raft floating on the choppy seas: in a finish where ability to obstruct an opponent without being penalised for it could count for as much as swimming speed and timing on touching the pad.
Remarkably the men's Olympic race produced (i) a gold medal photo-finish after nearly two hours that was so close that it took 15 minutes to figure out they'd initially named the wrong man as the winner and (ii) 2.2 seconds behind them, a three way photofinish for bronze
(the third person to post that time was subsequently for disqualified for what he described as fighting off somebody that was holding onto his leg in the final sprint...)
The women's race saw the a silver medal photo-finish before one of the swimmers was disqualified for reaching over the top of her opponent to touch the pad first in a manner which looked a little bit too much like dunking
So if losing a rowing sprint by a couple of centimetres sounds tough, spare a thought for the person that is two centimetres away from touching a moving finish line whilst their competitor elbows them, after swimming for two hours to get there
- Someone 10y ago"gold medal photo-finish after nearly two hours that was so close that it took 15 minutes to figure out they'd initially named the wrong man as the winner" For me, that was more a matter of the jury figuring out what the rules are. The GPS tracker of swimmer A passed the finish line .7 seconds before B did, but swimmer B hit the board half a second or so before A did. Both differences are easy to spot, even without the benefit of slow-motion (https://youtu.be/iQY6EoYVRxs https://youtu.be/iQY6EoYVRxs). So, if you know what determines the winner, it should be easy to figure out who won. This race probably has taught them not to connect the GPS measurements directly to numbers shown on screen to a worldwide audience.
- jrudolph 10y agoThe olympic marathon swimming was indeed mean. In any case, it's up to the sports organisations to determine what the rules are and what the rules should be. I don't say it's wrong what we're doing in rowing. In fact, using a photofinish with a minimum resolution of 1/100th of a second is an easy and pragmatic solution. But it's not necessarily the way things have to be forever. My main concern is that it pretends to offer a precise measurement of relative performance when in fact it cannot because we can't guarantee a similarly precise alignment at the start. Or at least the rules don't ask for it (accuracy of alignment + precision of its measurement is not prescribed in the in the FISA rules of racing).