5 ms·
> The tax break is equivalent to a matching program coming from public funds. No, not even remotely. It's a mechanism to reduce public funds and leave more mo
by JoshTriplett 10y ago
> The tax break is equivalent to a matching program coming from public funds.
No, not even remotely. It's a mechanism to reduce public funds and leave more money in people's hands. In accounting terms, a tax deduction doesn't belong in the "expenses" column; it decreases the "revenue" column.
> Thought experiment: if you were setting up a matching program that used public money (i.e. tax income), what would your criteria be? Is that an appropriate use of public funds at all?
Almost never, no. The only case I can think of that would ever be appropriate might be as a means of allowing people to direct spending in a particular area already considered within the purview of government, allowing people to select from a variety of competing services while amplifying their spending power to allow them to afford something considered a necessity. As a means of re-introducing competition to improve quality, it might make sense. (But only after carefully determining that the expenditure in question should actually fall within in the scope of government.)
- Retric 10y agoMoney is fungible. There is no difference from me handing you a dollar and then you handing it back to me and me not handing you a dollar.