4 ms·
If that were true—which it's not—I'm still not sure if it's relevant; kitchen knives have a separate use besides stabbing people. IKEA could argue using it aga
by mcphage 10y ago
If that were true—which it's not—I'm still not sure if it's relevant; kitchen knives have a separate use besides stabbing people. IKEA could argue using it against a person is using it wrong. Whereas most guns don't have a use besides shooting people (hunting rifles do, obviously). If you shoot a person with a handgun or assault rifle, you're using the gun as intended.
- undersuit 10y agoI have friends that use their guns every weekend. I don't think they are killing people.
- dogma1138 10y agoAnd if I write on the side of the gun "for hunting and range use only" does that mean the gun manufacturer isn't liable anymore? Also last time I've checked automatic weapons are illegal for civilians to own or carry in the US so no one is buying an Assault Rifle in the US unless they spend north of 30,000$ on a pre-ban firearm or have a license to make or sell firearms to law enforcement and military customers. But that's aside you cannot shift the liability of an action to anyone but the perpetrator. This infantile idea that some how some one can be liable for you own actions is not only morally bankrupt but is completely the wrong fight if you want to implement sane gun control in the US. I am not American, I have no particular support for gun "rights" as I do not have them. Any objection I might have to gun control activists in the US is due to their ideology tactics and methods rather than the goal at large.
- mcphage 10y ago> And if I write on the side of the gun "for hunting and range use only" does that mean the gun manufacturer isn't liable anymore? I guess—if you could convince a judge that that's true. For most guns, I don't think they'd buy the hunting angle. The range angle, maybe, if only their messaging and advertising didn't imply something totally different. Remember, laws are evaluated by human judges, and they can see through totally transparent ploys.
- dogma1138 10y agoWhat law, you can't hold some one else responsible for your actions the fact that you even proposing this and then say that a judge would defend it, is laughable. Not a single judge would accept this argument, and there is no way any law like this would ever pass it would shatter the current framework of legal responsibility and accountability.
- mcphage 10y ago> What law Under no law, obviously. But you claimed that if it were, it would be comparable to holding IKEA responsible for someone using a knife in an attack, and I don't think that's an accurate comparison.
- dogma1138 10y agoNo, I claimed that the principal is equivalent of holding IKEA responsible for some one using their knives to kill some one and it is 100% accurate, which is why this would never will be a legal argument.
- lostlogin 10y agoI'm trying to think of other legislation where manufacturers hold a liability when a product is used as intended. Tobacco comes to mind, but other examples are hard to find. Where I live alcohol sold as pre mixed drinks and targeted at young people/ under age drinkers has caused the manufacturers some grief. Are there other examples?
- dogma1138 10y agoI'm pretty sure the legal basis for the fight against Tobacco is that they have committed fraud by intentionally hiding the medical research on the effects of Tobacco, you can't really say the same thing about weapon companies they usually advertise exactly what their products are going to do :)