12 ms·
Aurora massacre survivors sued, and four ended up owing the theater $700k
- Broken_Hippo 10y agoI find so much of this article simply appalling. I'm not sure how the movie theater is actually responsible for the shooting. The shooting was a horrible and tragic event, yes. Could safety be improved? In general terms, probably. Would these general safety things helped this incident? Almost certainly not. Is expecting a movie theater to provide this level of security reasonable? Probably not - and the truth is that most reasonable folks wouldn't want this level of security at a movie theater. It is probably best left to law enforcement. I understand these folks' lives have changed for the worst. I truly think they are entitled to have their medical bills and therapy and things covered. If they cannot work, I do think they are entitled to having income at their previous levels. But not by the theater. And all along, this lawsuit had many failings. I find it amazing that a lawyer would take the case. I find it amazing that said lawyer, if he was not paid upfront, is not partially responsible for the other side's fees. (being paid upfront changes things, as he'd not really profit from the winnings). I find it weird that the case was allowed through and not thrown out earlier. I find it appalling that these folks aren't taken care of as I mentioned before - because I truly believe this stuff would lessen such lawsuits. Such an odd world we live in.
- lintiness 10y agoyou find it odd that a lawyer would take this case? you must not know many lawyers. here in colorado, we've allowed them to advertise their services. almost all of daytime tv is inundated with ads for ambulance chasing shit slingers.
- Broken_Hippo 10y agoYeah, in a way. At some point, doesn't a reasonable person stop to say, "This is quite ridiculous, isn't it?" I forget about those commercials, honestly. I remember a few from Indiana some years back, but disconnected from TV and switched countries since then (and that could affect my viewpoint). I don't view those folks well - but at least occasionally they wind up actually taking justifiable cases. Again, though, the safety net thing would render them unnecessary in many cases.
- meddlepal 10y agoA good lawyer will generally advise you not to take on near unbeatable odds or politely decline to take a case like this.
- jessaustin 10y agoThe "good" lawyers should start taking some responsibility for the shit lawyers like "Marc Bern" mentioned in TFA. Law is still considered a profession, by some people anyway. Physicians don't let other physicians sell snake oil; why are lawyers and judges comfortable doing that? However the "good" lawyers in this case are also scumbags. On an open-and-shut case like this, in which the plaintiffs spent $22k on expert testimony, how is it reasonable for the defense to spend $500k? It isn't clear from TFA that defense expenses will have to be paid for the state-level suit, but if so most of that should be thrown out. If in fact the federal judge doesn't throw out most of the apparently >$700k federal expenses, the two explanations for that would be corruption (of course) and a fit of pique against the intransigent four for not respecting his authoritay. Incidentally TFA is a mess. Why does it use the defense expenses for the state trial to calculate what the federal plaintiffs will have to pay?
- dogma1138 10y ago>Physicians don't let other physicians sell snake oil; Eh? do you know how many BS "Doctor" (MD, Ph.D. And Wannabe) sites, tv and radio shows, segments and infomercials that sell snaken oil (and in many cases simple snake poison) are out there?
- jessaustin 10y agoNo I don't know. Regardless, one wouldn't hold physicians responsible for the actions of PhDs and other charlatans. If a snake oil salesperson claims to be an MD (or DO?) on the internet, one could believe that or not. When I am treated by physicians, they are held to the standards of their profession. If I consulted an attorney, that wouldn't be the case.
- tzs 10y agoThere are a couple of different theoretical justifications for holding someone liable for some bad event that is somehow connected to them, such as when a bad event happens on their property, or a bad event happens using a product they built or sold. The most well known one, and the only one that most people know of, is that of negligence. If you do something negligence and that leads to harm, you should be held liable for the harm and have to pay to correct it or compensate the victims. If you were not negligent, then you should not have to pay. In a liability system based on that justification, it would make little sense to hold a theater liable for a mass shooting unless they actually did something negligent that made them more likely than other places crowds gather to be chosen by the shooter, or if they did something negligent that made the shooting worse than it would have otherwise been (e.g., jammed cell phones which delayed getting help, or did not have enough emergency exits so people were exposed to the shooter longer than they should have been). The negligence approach can work reasonably well. It does have a couple of problems, though. First is that it may be hard to decide who, if anyone, was actually negligent in a given case. Another approach is to have a liability system based on the idea that parties should purchase insurance to compensate them from the damages from bad events. For a given type of bad event, the law under this approach would put liability on the entities that are in the best position to estimate the risk and determine the appropriate level of insurance coverage they need. For consumer products, that would often be the manufacturer. So for instance you might make lawn mower makers liable for injuries from their lawn mowers, even if it is the consumer's stupidity that causes a particular injury (such as not stopping the mower before reaching under to clear a blockage). The mower company would then keep track of how often these injuries occur (something they would be doing anyway so that they can design safety feature to make it harder for people to do stupid things like that), and could buy the necessary insurance, passing the insurance costs on to its customers. If it was left up to consumers to insure against sticking their hands under lawn mowers, you'd either have almost no one buying that insurance (who plans to stick their hand under a running lawn mower?), or it would have to be covered under their general medical insurance, and so would be slightly driving the cost up for everybody else. When it is the lawn mover company that has to buy the insurance, the people who hurt themselves with lawn mowers are only driving up the cost for other lawn mower users. The net effect is that you are somewhat narrowing the pool to the people who are actually more at risk. Note that in this "liability based on who can best insure" approach, liability does not imply fault. For mass shootings, the question then is whether it makes more sense for each individual to purchase insurance to cover injuries they receive in mass shootings, or for venues to purchase insurance that pays their patrons for injuries when those patrons are shot in a mass shooting at that venue. If the latter, then you make venues liable for shootings that occur there, regardless of whether or not they were negligent. For any given type of venue or any given type of product, where liability should be placed in this kind of system depends on the details of the relevant industry and market. You probably want liability placed at some entity that will have the data and/or expert knowledge to figure out reasonably accurately how much insurance to carry. Note that negligence based liability systems and best insurer based liability systems are not mutually exclusive. There is no reason you cannot do both. You can have a negligence based system applicable to everything, and also have a best insurer system applicable to things where this is some party who has the data and expertise to deal with the insurance.
- lintiness 10y agotldr: most plaintiffs settled for peanuts (the judge didn't believe the theater was to blame or could have reasonably prevented the massacre), the others went against judicial advice and ate cinemark's attorney's fees.
- celticninja 10y agoThat TL:DR is inaccurate. All plaintiffs agreed to settle for a share of $150k rather than face the prospect of paying the legal costs of the theatre. One plaintiff (who was one of the plaintiffs getting a larger share) refused the deal at the final minute which meant there was no settlement for anyone. The next day the judge found for the theater and costs were assigned to the plaintiffs. At which stage there were only 4 left on the case as the others had withdrawn so im not sure if the 700k was between all original defendants or the 4 remaining ones.
- kahnpro 10y agoI don't understand how they can just withdraw after an attempt at settlement but before the decision was made. Seems to me like all 41 should be on the hook for those legal fees.
- celticninja 10y agoBut 40 of the 41 would have accepted the settlement so why should they be on the hook for the fees when only one refused the settlement.
- kahnpro 10y agoBecause they're a part of the lawsuit? Refusing the settlement doesn't mean the lawsuit is lost.
- celticninja 10y agodid you read the article? All this is explained. The lawsuit was lost, the judge had pretty much told them he would be giving a decision in favour of the defendants the next day hence the need to agree a settlement.
- 300bps 10y agotl;dr There were 41 survivors suing the movie theater for failing to secure the theater from an armed attacker. 40 voted to settle for a small amount of money. One rejected the settlement which caused it to fail. 37 then removed themselves as plaintiffs fearing they would lose the case and be responsible for the movie theater's legal costs. The four remaining lost the case and were held responsible for the movie theaters bills. And that's how 4 of the survivors ended up owing the movie theater $700,000 in legal costs.
- gambiting 10y agoThe article seems to paint the theatre in bad light, as if they are responsible for the shooting, or at least for not preventing it - do we really want to live in reality where you have to go through metal detector to see a movie? While I feel very sorry for the survivors, I feel like they are a bunch of exploitative arseholes for trying to sue the theater for any damages - it's beyond ridiculous.
- simbalion 10y agoWhy is this even an acceptable hypothetical? "if they are responsible for the shooting"... Seriously? Unless someone employed by the theater hired the shooter, I would love to know what other scenario could possibly have made them responsible for it. Adults since ancient man have been expected to be responsible for their own self-defense. But for some reason in modern day America, people think someone else is responsible for protecting them. Well they're not.
- lintiness 10y agoit's mostly predatory whore lawyers causing problems like this. we're a ridiculously litigious country, and the expense is visible in everything from the cost of healthcare to insurance to buying carrots at the store.
- simbalion 10y agoThe experts who gave testimony might be to blame too, it sounds like they charged a years salary for their 30 minutes of testimony.
- rmchugh 10y agoIt seems like a really bizarre case from a European perspective. If one concluded that the theatre was liable for the actions of a gun carrying lunatic wouldn't the same apply for all service providers acting in public space? Concerts, bars, cafés etc would all be expected to prepare for terrorist-style shooting incidents. Whatever about the excessive cost of such preparations (which would be passed on to the consumer), the effect on public consciousness by constantly rubbing up against militarised zones would be horrible.
- sneak 10y agoTry going to a concert or sporting event in that country sometime. It's totally ridiculous.
- lostlogin 10y agoIt would be a problem that was largely solved if gun manufacturers held any liability - a far better target than the cinema. The protection of lawful commerce in arms act protects them.
- LyndsySimon 10y agoGun manufacturers do hold liability - for defects in their products, for negligence, for breaking the law in the course of selling their products, etc.
- lostlogin 10y agoYes, but a fully functional assault rifle killing dozens when sold to someone whom is badly mentally ill - no liability? For example, liability could extend to the sales process rather than be held by the individual store. http://everytown.org/press/new-fbi-data-shows-mental-health-records-in-background-check-system-tripled-since-release-of-fatal-gaps-report-pressed-states-to-submit-records-of-prohibited-gun-purchasers/ http://everytown.org/press/new-fbi-data-shows-mental-health-...
- MrMember 10y ago
- kbart 10y ago"Weaver had been pushing for, an acknowledgment that the theater chain would take new measures to protect patrons." Another TSA at the cinema? No, thanks. We can't secure every step from mass shooting and/or terrorists attacks without making cities into the huge prisons. While our society functions normally and mass killings are very rare, there's no need to take additional security measurements. A much better way is to invest these money into mental health programs. So no, despite the alarmist tone on this article, the court ruling was sane and probably the best one in this case.
- lostlogin 10y agoWhat about dealing with mental health and guns? Both of these are hard but the guns one is pretty much untouchable unfortunately.
- LyndsySimon 10y agoIn the US, depriving someone of a right is a legal process. If someone has been adjudicated mentally incompetent, they cannot legally own a gun.
- lostlogin 10y agoExcept when the correct process isn't followed and they just buy one, which unfortunately occurs. http://everytown.org/press/new-fbi-data-shows-mental-health-records-in-background-check-system-tripled-since-release-of-fatal-gaps-report-pressed-states-to-submit-records-of-prohibited-gun-purchasers/ http://everytown.org/press/new-fbi-data-shows-mental-health-...
- LyndsySimon 10y agoYour response is a complete non sequitur. If someone has been adjudicated incompetent, they may not legally own a gun.
- lostlogin 10y ago
- aaron695 10y agoGood. Why do we assume people who were just sitting in a theater where good people? Why should they get to sue? Do we realise what would have happened if they won. TSA at theaters being needed to keep their insurance. Theaters going broke. The judge even gave them warning. Bad things happen every day. A car accident is an awful thing. Why do people get special preference the more media coverage they get.
- mcphage 10y ago> Then one plaintiff rejected the deal. Her suffering had been profound: Her child was killed in the shooting, she was left paralyzed and the baby she was carrying had been lost. I'm curious if she rejected the settlement—and (presumably) stayed on the case—because she thought they would win? Or because she thought shooting victims owing the theater $700k would be a bigger black mark against Cinemark, than it settling for $150k? A $150k settlement makes it sound like Cinemark wasn't at fault and they settled for a pittance to make it go away (which is true); having the shooting victims owe it $700k sounds like an injustice. I certainly doubt Cinemark wants the results of this case to be widely publicized. It's not like they're ever going to receive even a fraction of that $700k anyway.
- rhapsodic 10y ago> I'm curious if she rejected the settlement—and (presumably) stayed on the case—because she thought they would win? Or because she thought shooting victims owing the theater $700k would be a bigger black mark against Cinemark, than it settling for $150k? I don't think there was any logic involved in her decision at all. I'm guessing that the unimaginable horrors that had been inflicted upon her and her family clouded her judgement. I feel really sorry for her, but I agree with the decision, and the law that led the judge to make it.
- mcphage 10y ago> I don't think there was any logic involved in her decision at all. Yeah, probably. I guess I'd prefer to think that she knew what she was doing, but who knows. I can't imagine Cinemark is very happy with the results, since rather than the case going away quietly they got a $700k judgement they can't do anything with. But then insurance gets involved, and I'm not going to pretend I know that will work out.
- simbalion 10y agoSuing the theater for something so obviously out of their control is crooked. Suing the victims to re-pay the exhorbitant fees for your "expert testimony" is also crooked. Everyone involved are crooks. That is interesting.
- unclenoriega 10y agoI wonder if it makes sense to limit fees for expert testimony.
- simbalion 10y agoPeople summoned to give testimony should not be allowed to get paid for it at all. It's enough to cover their expenses. It should be a duty.
- icebraining 10y agoThat's both counterproductive and unfair. Counterproductive because unless you'd start arresting and forcing people to testify, you'd just mass evasion, just like there already is for jury duty. The only "experts" willing to come would be self-promoters trying to get their name on the newspaper. Unfair, because that "duty" would be almost exclusively levied on the most capable and productive members of society. If you think expert testimony is a social duty, then it should be imposed on the whole of society, by getting the State to finance it.
- rhapsodic 10y ago> On a conference call, the federal judge overseeing the case told the plaintiffs’ attorneys that he was prepared to rule in the theater chain’s favor. He urged the plaintiffs to settle with Cinemark, owner of the Century Aurora 16 multiplex where the July 20, 2012, shooting occurred. They had 24 hours. Is it common for a judge to tell one party in a dispute which way he intends to rule, in advance of the actual ruling? That would seem to give that party an unfair advantage in settlement negotiations. The article doesn't say that Cinemark was given the same information in advance. Had they had that information, they wouldn't feel compelled to offer much of anything to settle the lawsuit, except perhaps for the sake of PR.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]