5 ms·
Adding to the supply will always lower prices. That is basic Economics. If the program is "designed" to do that or not doesn't matter. > they are simply being
by BurningFrog 10y ago
Adding to the supply will always lower prices. That is basic Economics. If the program is "designed" to do that or not doesn't matter.
> they are simply being used by corporations to lower wages
That's bit conspiratorial. I think of it more as they need more engineers to get more work done. This lowers the wages of the native engineer population, but raises them for the imported workers. The net result is a bigger population of highly productive high income earners, that is quite good for the overall American economy.
- wcummings 10y ago>That's bit conspiratorial. No, believing otherwise is naive. Zuckerberg isn't lobbying for more H1Bs out of the goodness of his heart and a profound belief that labor arbitrage will make the world a better place. Labor is Silicon Valley's biggest expense, you had better bet they're trying to reduce that cost. If we're going to allow foreign workers, they shouldn't be shackled to employers like H1B workers are.
- BurningFrog 10y ago> No, believing otherwise is naive. Zuckerberg isn't lobbying for more H1Bs out of the goodness of his heart and a profound belief that labor arbitrage will make the world a better place That's a silly caricature of what I said. > If we're going to allow foreign workers, they shouldn't be shackled to employers like H1B workers are. Agreed.
- nullcipher 10y agoThe H1B workers are still less shackled than those L1s. If that makes any H1Bs feel better.
- pps43 10y ago> I think of it more as they need more engineers to get more work done. They can easily get more engineers by simply increasing salaries. Let's say I'm a bright student deciding whether to study software engineering or plumbing. When I graduate, my salary will be driven by supply and demand. As a software engineer, I will be competing for jobs with other software engineers, many on H1B visas coming from countries where education is less expensive than in the US. So those software engineers can comfortably accept a lower salary. No such problem with plumbing, so it is rational for me to chose plumbing. Now Zuckerberg and co can justifiably say "look, there is a shortage of software engineers, let's lift H1B cap".
- yummyfajitas 10y agoIn the short run, increasing salaries will only get you a greater share of the existing engineers. Importing workers solves the labor scarcity issue today. I love how imply that foreign engineers have some sort of advantage over you because schools are cheaper where they come from, ignoring how much poorer those folks are. But actually that's nonsense - if you really wanted to pay low prices for foreign schools (out of yours/your parent's American income), you would have. Plenty of foreigners do attend Indian colleges, it's pretty straightforward to do. It's quite popular among Africans. From what I'm told, African colleges are terrible, UK/US colleges are expensive, so India is a great middle ground.
- pps43 10y agoI'm not implying anything, but speaking from first-hand experience. As a foreign engineer who got decent education outside of US for free and then came over on H1B, I did have clear advantage over my US counterparts. I had no student loans to service, so could afford to accept a lower salary and get the same disposable income. There is no labor scarcity issue. I switched fields away from software engineering but if you pay me enough, can switch back just as easily. It's not rocket science.
- yummyfajitas 10y agoOf course there is scarcity - not everyone has as many software engineers as they want. That's true even if people who left software come back. Again, you ignore the fact that if an Americans wants a cheap foreign education, they can buy one. The difference between $0 in loans and $5000 in loans is negligible.
- ryandrake 10y agoScarcity only exists at a price. When the prices is higher, the scarcity goes away. If I only want to pay $10,000 for a new car, and I can't find any, then is it fair to say that I am facing a shortage of Mercedes?