3 ms·
The fact that several teams of very highly qualified physicists bothered to look at it makes me believe the physics involved is non-obvious and can't be written
by onion2k 10y ago
The fact that several teams of very highly qualified physicists bothered to look at it makes me believe the physics involved is non-obvious and can't be written off with a simple "the theory is simply wrong". Dismissing it out of hand does a disservice to all those people.
That's not to say it'll prove to be true, I doubt it will, but this is something that has so much potential it's worth investigating the tiny possibility that it's real, and "all currently used theories of electrodynamics are wrong", just in case.
- csirac2 10y agoWorryingly, the 2015 paper didn't seem to have anything about measuring the mass of the device before and after the experiment. An old radar technician asked me to take a look... apparently "boiling" waveguides are a thing when it comes to high-power RF.
- jschwartzi 10y agoIf the waveguide boils at a certain rate at certain power levels, then it should be possible to estimate how much force this would produce. If that force is on the same order, then it's likely the reason for what we're seeing.
- megalodon 10y ago> Dismissing it out of hand does a disservice to all those people. Or maybe they all know its impossible, but continue because they are perfectly happy with the amount of funding thrown at them. Not saying it's true, but it's the other side of the coin.
- estefan 10y ago> Or maybe they all know its impossible How could they know? That's the point of the scientific method isn't it, experimentation and valuing observation over preconceptions?