3 ms·
Nobody ever suggested that the Gnome desktop should be built on Java. Miguel was a very vocal advocate of C# as a solution to the language interop problems the
by cageface 17y ago
Nobody ever suggested that the Gnome desktop should be built on Java. Miguel was a very vocal advocate of C# as a solution to the language interop problems the early Gnome tech suffered from. The rest of your argument is an unpersuasive slippery slope argument. The software patent system is broken and you can never really be safe but there's still a difference between building something that might use some of the same methods as other patented software and implementing a full-stack clone of a core MS technology that they've alternately promoted and protected.
A big part of the reason that Mono hasn't made further inroads in the Gnome desktop beyond some disposable userland apps is because the rest of the free software movement sees it as the trojan horse it is, despite Miguel's urging over the years to make it the base of Gnome.
- kprobst 17y agoThe argument du jour is that every software patent is dangerous and useless, and every patent holder a potential troll. Surely it cannot be "safer" to infringe on Oracle's patents than on Microsoft's, yet at least Microsoft has gone to the trouble of specifying what exactly is exempt from patent claims and what isn't with that Community Promise of theirs - which by the way is legally binding under estoppel. I don't remember ever seeing anything like that from Oracle, Sun or IBM vis-a-vis Java, and it was interesting that Java was released under the GPLv2 and not v3, which would actually eliminate the threat of a patent claim on it. /This/ argument that Java and PostgreSQL and MQ implementations (check out the patents in that niche) and everything else is "more safe" than Mono is unpersuasive at best to me - in fact I'd buy it only in the case of Samba, which does have an official get out of jail free card from Microsoft.
- cageface 17y agoYou may be unpersuaded, but, as Miguel acknowledged in a recent article linked here, most OSS developers have (wisely, IMO) kept their distance and relegated Mono to a sideshow. While MS was constantly making veiled threats about patent issues with free software in general and Linux in particular Sun and Oracle were making important contributions and treating Linux as a first-class deployment platform. Maybe you can't see a difference here but it couldn't be plainer to many of us.