4 ms·
So Zika, a devastating illness that is likely to cripple thousands, will go on being undetected because Theranos may have not quite followed the rules in collec
by JoeAltmaier 10y ago
So Zika, a devastating illness that is likely to cripple thousands, will go on being undetected because Theranos may have not quite followed the rules in collecting finger sticks? This is a public health emergency. Appalling.
- rayiner 10y agoFirst, do no harm.
- hprotagonist 10y agoNot quite. 1. Their tech is _deeply_ unproven. Theranos doesn't even use it internally, and the sanctions against them in the past year have been very instructive about that. They have exactly zero publically disclosed, peer-reviewed pieces of evidence that detail the clinical use and efficacy of their primary technology. 2. Thou Shalt have an IRB [0]. No exceptions. The tuskegee experiment[1] and other utter failures of medical ethics in this country is why. [0]: http://www.hhs.gov/ohrp/regulations-and-policy/regulations/45-cfr-46/ http://www.hhs.gov/ohrp/regulations-and-policy/regulations/4... [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tuskegee_syphilis_experiment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tuskegee_syphilis_experiment
- _asummers 10y agoIRB, for those like me who didn't know, stands for institutional review board.
- rblatz 10y agoIt's such a basic mistake that I can't imagine any legitimate researcher making it. I helped out with a project that anonymously surveyed registered dietitians about their knowledge of listeria. It had to go to through the IRB before we started, and then any change to it required an IRB amendment. It is unbelievable how big and how basic of a mistake they made, it makes me question what other corners they cut.
- hprotagonist 10y agoexactly. I've had to be aware of IRB needs since high school, and deal with them since I was an undergraduate. This is like trying to run a business but "not knowing" that you have to issue your employees W-2s.
- firebones 10y agoOr, another way to think of it is that a company that has already harmed people with false claims about the suitability of nanotainer technology in medical screening is prevented from doing further damage because they still can't manage to clear even the lower bar the FDA the has set for approval in such public health emergencies--a lower bar that other vendors have managed to clear for their already-approved Zika tests.
- ebbv 10y agoWhat? Are you kidding me? The law is the law. The regulations are there for a reason. The people you should be mad at here are Theranos if you really think they were going to do something good, they are the ones who screwed up. I'm not comfortable with companies skirting the law "because it's an emergency."
- sseveran 10y agoI spent 10 years in the medical research world. Not having IRB approval is such a basic error. IRBs are set up to ensure that all research conducted on humans is safe and ethical. If this was not Theranos and someone was say giving high level of radiation as part of an experiment I doubt you would be as forgiving. Or maybe PII gets published as part of a study on STDs and people are publicly identified. IRBs exist to protect patients and prevent researchers from harming them, either intentionally or unintentionally.
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoWe're talking a finger stick here.
- apathy 10y agoThink about that for a moment. If you can test for the virus with a finger prick, you can potentially transmit this and other viruses as well. That needs to be addressed in the protocol, along with any other relevant details. It should be mundane. That's why it's shocking to hear that they did not do it! IRBs exist to ensure that these sorts of things are not overlooked. Too many times in the past, they have been. So now the burden of proof lies with the investigator. Like it or not, a few fast-and-loose protocols ensured that this situation will not be changing any time soon.
- enzamatic 10y agoYou're also talking about telling someone they either do or do not have a disease. The finger stick alone is not all the damage that you can do. Is that person pregnant? Is their spouse? Are they going to act on what you told them?
- pkaye 10y agoLooks like Theranos just needs to just more knowledgable people... "The FDA has cleared Zika tests from several other companies since invoking a rule allowing the agency to lower hurdles for new medical products during emergencies."
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoAnd all of the responses and negativity skate around the positive results and the tragic loss of an effective diagnostic procedure. Because 'rules'. The oversight (potentially risking folks safety by not doing a finger stick with the right paperwork?) has nothing to do with the actual medical test nor does it compromise the results. Yet everybody is fine with punishing an unpopular company because of yes technicalities. While public safety and the lives of unborn children are at serious risk. I don't get the nerd mentality sometimes. Common sense flies right out the window.
- seesomesense 10y ago"tragic loss of an effective diagnostic procedure" Theranos' last attempt at an effective diagnostic test for the effects of warfarin caused at least one stroke in a patient due to inaccurate results. Both false positive and false negative Zika virus tests would have equally undesirable ramifications. How many women would you like to have Theranos harm with their implementations that have been well documented to be appalling ?
- apathy 10y agoThalidomide was also banned in the US "because rules". Common sense in medicine prioritizes doing no harm. I can provide other notable examples if need be. The bottom line is that all parties need to be confident that the expected benefit of a test or procedure outweighs any expected potential harms. Having multiple layers or peer review is one way to ensure this. I work on clinical trials of "black label" (potentially lethal) agents in patients that typically have no other options. Our pages can be 70-100 pages and we are doing this in our "spare" time (Ha! Ha!). I don't think it's unreasonable for a massively capitalized private company to produce documentation at least up to this standard. It really isn't much to ask, especially for an existential venture like this (something -- anything! -- trustworthy to recover the tremendous amount of credibility they've lost.) Other companies had no problem writing a suitable protocol. Why should peoples' safety be compromised just so that an untrustworthy company can enter the market?
- JoeAltmaier 10y ago