4 ms·
The "Somalia is a comparable form of anarchy" argument is even worse than the "roads would not have been built" argument the OP was dismissing. This hardly need
by dmix 10y ago
The "Somalia is a comparable form of anarchy" argument is even worse than the "roads would not have been built" argument the OP was dismissing. This hardly needs a rebuttal because it's based on a false pretense that the goal is some form of stateless 'anarchy' without rule of law/courts rather than a minimalist government, particularly in the economic sense.
- mikeash 10y agoThe original comment literally presented "without government, the world would be in complete anarchy" as a false belief. If "without government" is a false pretense and the actual case being explored is "minimalist government" then maybe they should have said so, but it hardly seems fair to blame the responder for replying to what was written.
- aminok 10y agoThose places have governments, just ones that, relative to the governments of advanced economies, are extremely small and barbaric. If we define a government as a party with a localized monopoly on force, even an armed robber is a government. And if one doesn't define government this broadly, that still doesn't invalidate the libertarian argument, since it hinges on opposition to the initiation of force (aggression), as opposed to initiation of strictly government force.
- rayiner 10y agoAnarchy is at least morally defensible. "Minimal government" yokes people under government, while taking away their self-determination. It replaces democracy with rule by a self-selected intellectual elite that decides what is and is not a proper function of "minimal government."
- likeclockwork 10y agoWhich always seems to come down to "police to keep the poors in line" because they expect to be able to buy everything else.