3 ms·
So in the case of the infamous video about being a single female in New York, from the POV of California law, all of the male "transgressors" in that video were
by stcredzero 10y ago
So in the case of the infamous video about being a single female in New York, from the POV of California law, all of the male "transgressors" in that video were simply exercising their 1st amendment rights. (Had the events happened in downtown San Francisco.)
- dragonwriter 10y ago> So in the case of the infamous video about being a single female in New York, from the POV of California law, all of the male "transgressors" in that video were simply exercising their 1st amendment rights. IIRC, the video doesn't actually follow the fact pattern of the hypothetical upthread (its not limited to examples of a conversation being initiated, declined, and pursued), and does include things which might reasonably be included within some aspects of California's laws on criminal threats and/or disturbing the peace. But, generally, yes, lots of rude and offensive behavior is neither criminal nor even civilly actionable, just rude.
- stcredzero 10y agoIIRC, the video doesn't actually follow the fact pattern of the hypothetical upthread (its not limited to examples of a conversation being initiated, declined, and pursued), and does include things which might reasonably be included within some aspects of California's laws on criminal threats and/or disturbing the peace. IIRC, "examples of a conversation being initiated, declined, and pursued" were the worst examples shown. Everything else could possibly be argued as "disturbing the peace" but could also have been seen as one person saying something to a passer-by.