4 ms·
I think the critical insight here is that Stallman’s vision of software freedom dates to a time when software was contained. You could walk away from that PDP-1
by stcredzero 10y ago
I think the critical insight here is that Stallman’s vision of software freedom dates to a time when software was contained. You could walk away from that PDP-11 and the choices you made there didn’t follow you home in your pocket or give a world full of bored assholes an attack surface for your entire life.
How practical could it be to have laws against trolling? There are online groups who have rules against doxxing, who seem to be able to enforce them. I don't think it would unduly contravene free speech, if public spaces on the internet assumed consent to communication between individuals, with the option of individuals revoking consent. This would be analogous to what people do in public spaces. Then the act of creating a throwaway account on Twitter to continue harassment would be analogous to continue to harass someone in real life. There would be exceptions, but generally, this would be definable and enforceable. (And I would also say, it would be more constructive than picking a figurehead like Milo Yiannopoulos and banning him as a scapegoat. Even if enforcement could only catch a few people.)
- vonmoltke 10y ago> This would be analogous to what people do in public spaces. How do I "revoke consent" to one-way communication in public spaces? All I can do is avoid known people (if possible) or ignore them.
- stcredzero 10y agoHow do I "revoke consent" to one-way communication in public spaces? "Okay, I'm done with this, and with you. I no longer consent to this interaction. If you continue, it's harassment." Then you walk away. In a virtual space, like Twitter, you block them. Then it's incumbent on them to not create a throwaway and continue the behavior. (And in the case of most middle schoolers and other internet willful idiots and trollers, they're probably not competent enough to hide their identity from a knowledgeable enemy.)
- vonmoltke 10y ago> "Okay, I'm done with this, and with you. I no longer consent to this interaction. If you continue, it's harassment." Then you walk away. One-way communications are not an interaction. You cannot silence someone just by saying "shut up or it's harassment". Harassment, from a legal perspective, rightfully has a high bar that your example does not meet.
- AnimalMuppet 10y agoI'm not a lawyer, but: >> Then you walk away. If the person continues the interaction, they have to follow you to do it. Is that (legally) harassment? If not, isn't it something? Or can I just legally follow you down the street, loudly verbally abusing you, and you have no legal recourse?
- dragonwriter 10y ago> If the person continues the interaction, they have to follow you to do it. Is that (legally) harassment? Without violence or threats of violence, or stalking (which requires more than just following), not in California, AFAICT. Other jurisdictions may differ. > If not, isn't it something? Like, some crime? Not for just continuing an unwanted verbal interaction generally. Legally, that's generally called, "Exercising one's First Amendment rights." > Or can I just legally follow you down the street, loudly verbally abusing you, and you have no legal recourse? If it is loud and unreasonable noise, it might be actionable as disturbing the peace.
- stcredzero 10y agoSo in the case of the infamous video about being a single female in New York, from the POV of California law, all of the male "transgressors" in that video were simply exercising their 1st amendment rights. (Had the events happened in downtown San Francisco.)
- dragonwriter 10y ago> So in the case of the infamous video about being a single female in New York, from the POV of California law, all of the male "transgressors" in that video were simply exercising their 1st amendment rights. IIRC, the video doesn't actually follow the fact pattern of the hypothetical upthread (its not limited to examples of a conversation being initiated, declined, and pursued), and does include things which might reasonably be included within some aspects of California's laws on criminal threats and/or disturbing the peace. But, generally, yes, lots of rude and offensive behavior is neither criminal nor even civilly actionable, just rude.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- wyager 10y agoThere are no public spaces on the Internet, except perhaps government websites. Everything else is a private space, maybe with public access. Regulating "trolling" (however some legislator chooses to define that) would be regulating what people say and allow to be said in their own private websites.
- paavokoya 10y agoThe government currently tells businesses how to build their buildings, how to run their safety code, their hygiene policies etc. I'm not endorsing this level of micro-management, but it certainly allows recourse for negligence and malpractice.
- wyager 10y agoAre you really saying that regulating hygiene is comparable to regulating speech? In what way is allowing open discourse negligent or "malpractice"?
- jasonkostempski 10y agoName 1 technology law that actually fixed a problem.
- fusiongyro 10y agoIf you read the post, he argues that we have boatloads of legislation about vehicle and road safety. Cars were once the cool new technology. And he implies that this legislation has actually resulted in safer cars.
- Frondo 10y agoSeatbelts?
- jasonkostempski 10y agoTouché, I should have been more specific, I meant digital technology.
- Frondo 10y agoOh, I thought of another. Section 508 rules on accessibility mean that government websites can be used by the visually impaired.