7 ms·
The CIA’s Venture-Capital Firm, Like Its Sponsor, Operates in the Shadows
- nickpsecurity 10y agoWhether I like CIA or not, In-Q-Tel is one of their best achievements. The VC model in private sector had long been making better tech more cheaply and with faster improvements. There was also lots of overlap between enterprise and CIA needs. Funding dual-use tech through private sector is already win/win at this point. That revenue from sales to private sector could reduce taxpayer burden on any given tech is another win. Even if there was corruption, it's still better than most US Govt actions because they produced useful stuff that actually benefited Americans in some way.
- Zach_the_Lizard 10y agoThe title is misspelled; it's In-Q-Tel, not Q-Tel.
- sciguy77 10y agoIt's In-Q-Tel, not Q-Tel. I actually interviewed there a few years back. Very cool company.
- hansjorg 10y agoDo you know if they invest in torture technology? Or is that the domain of more surreptitious ventures of theirs?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- nickstinemates 10y agoAgree. Very smart guys. Passion for open source. Contribute to a ton of projects.
- nickpsecurity 10y agoI didn't know that about them. Is there a list of what they contribute to anywhere?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- mindslight 10y agoThis article makes it sound secretive and corrupt, but really this is a surprising amount of transparency compared to other drug cartels.
- advisedwang 10y agoMost VCs put their own people on the boards of companies they invest in, and then continue to invest in those companies. Doesn't this imply that the "shares a board member" conflict of interest described is either rampant in the industry or not actually a conflict of interest?
- cloudjacker 10y agoOf course they are rampant, and of course they are conflicts of interest. Industry and government standards state they simply have to be disclosed. You disclose it and either all the investors moan, sigh and walk away or they don't, if you have obtained a certain place in society, the investors don't walk away and you still get the lucrative outcome.
- vonnik 10y agoWe're missing the "In" on "In" Q Tel in the title. And I have to add, IQT serves a ton of govt agencies, not just the CIA.
- s_q_b 10y agoIn-Q-Tel is pretty explicit about their mission: to support the development of private sector technologies that are of immediate use (within 36 months) to their IC customers. Their investments are sometimes public and they invest in pretty much what you'd expect: D-Wave, Facebook, Keyhole. Even their name is taken straight out of the James Bond tech supplier branch/agent Q. Nor do they have even particularly critical national security technology. In-Q-Tel probably has less dark tech knowledge than your average building at NBP. One of my startups was contacted by one of their employees (it's almost always an employee, not the org directly), and they really just facilitated our data analysis processes, and made some connections. It never got to the stage where we accepted any money, and it was a lot less creepy than some of the government contractors cough Mitre cough. Disclaimer: I have not, do not, and will not work on mass surveillance technology.
- NumberCruncher 10y agoEverybody has his on price....
- T0T0R0 10y ago...than your average building at NBP. ...building at NBP. ...NBP. Name Binding Protocol National Biosolids Partnership National Braille Press National Broadband Plan Neighborhood Broadcast Problem Neutral Body Posture NetBIOS Protocol Network Binding Protocol Network Bootstrap Program Network Bridge Processor New Black Panthers Non-invasive Blood Pressure Normal Blood Pressure Normal Boiling Point Northern Business Products Namco Bandai Partners Hmmm...
- s_q_b 10y agoNational Business Park
- hansjorg 10y agoFor a minute I thought that was some kind of general name, say for a business park of a certain size or standing within its state, but according to Google (first hit) it's this place: http://cryptome.org/eyeball/nsa-nbp/nsa-nbp.htm http://cryptome.org/eyeball/nsa-nbp/nsa-nbp.htm
- ChuckMcM 10y agoI suppose it would be a scandal if they tried to hide who they were.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- unethical_ban 10y agoSearch for " we are all intelligence officers now" transcript by Dan Geer, CISO of the company, who refuses to get a clearance. Fascinating insights.
- dmix 10y agoIt only takes a moment to link to them... Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hxLJExWk9GE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hxLJExWk9GE Text: https://www.theinternetpatrol.com/security-expert-dan-geer-we-are-all-intelligence-officers-now-full-text-here/ https://www.theinternetpatrol.com/security-expert-dan-geer-w...
- mi100hael 10y agoHoly shit those side burns.
- srtjstjsj 10y agoHe unironically asks people to spy less, while working for the most famous spy org in the world? Wow
- unethical_ban 10y agoNot when mobile. Thanks for the backup.
- robterrin 10y agoWow. I started my career in Identity Management and this is brilliant. Thank you for sharing.
- tcoppi 10y agoDan Geer's refusal to get a clearance is more an experiment than a principled refusal, in case anyone was curious.
- binarray2000 10y agoI hope someone knowledgable will help me here. Do I get this right: US taxpayers are giving their hard earned dollars so that a government agency CIA can take it and, throu their venture capital firm (!), invest it into something that might, but also might not, work? Is this actually fiscally responsible? Is it in the job description of an intelligence agency to be a VC fund, not with private money, but with the money of the shrinking US middle class?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- caseymarquis 10y agoMeh. The whole system's a sham in my opinion; might as well get some decent technology out of it.
- bbctol 10y agoThe fact that it may or may not work is hardly a reason to not spend tax dollars on it... the government sends lots of money towards academic research and other scientific projects that individually have a low chance of amounting to much.
- drawkbox 10y agoMongoDB and Apigee are on their list of investments that are known.
- nickpsecurity 10y agoOracle's first customer was CIA. In-Q-Tel also has MemSQL, Tenable Network Security, Cloudera, VeraCode, and BBN before acquisition. Also, they give HN readers continued entertainment in form of Palantir and D-Wave.
- ryporter 10y agoThe author seems to want to unearth some scandal about conflicts of interest, but there's not much here. The final quote of the article pretty much nails it. “On the one hand, if you wanted really pristine independence, it means you are going to need people who don’t have commercial ties to the industry,” Mr. Gilson said. “On the other hand, if you have people without any commercial ties to the industry, they are not much use.” If there were no conflicts of interest at all, then we'd be discussing an article about how horribly In-Q-Tel's investments performed, because they were made by bureaucrats in D.C. who had no idea how startups worked.
- mmaunder 10y agoAgreed. The list of companies is good data and if you're in the security space, the kinds of capability CIA is trying to foster is interesting too.
- kirubakaran 10y agoIn John Doerr's words, "no conflict, no interest."
- slim 10y ago> how horribly In-Q-Tel's investments performed Not accounting for the value of the assets. Pun intended
- xxcode 10y agoDatabricks is one the companies that raised money from In-Q-Tel. Given that there are likely to be multiple Turing award winners from that company, I'd say its money well spent.
- adrianratnapala 10y agoSome on this thread are saying it's very common for VC trustees to be closely involved in the businesses they fund. But normal VCs must sink or swim as private businesses. In-Q-Tel is a non-profit, kept afloat by the taxpayers. This setup can easly be a nice channel for powerful people to funnel public money their own way. For one thing, if In-Q-Tel has close links with the CIA, they can steer contracts towards favoured companies. Even without that, trustees can funnel VC money into businesses and then funnel it out to their own selves. When the business fails, they shrug. Failures happen. That couldh appen in the private sector too. But even if In-Q-Tel keeps losing money in total, the trustees (who just made nice personal profits) can also shrug and say "this was never a for-profit thing anyway".
- leroy_masochist 10y agoI'm quite surprised the article went into that much detail without mentioning Palantir.