6 ms·
I'm not really clear on why anyone should care. I recognize that my first reaction is an elitist "who cares what losers who 'follow' celebrities get sold on".
by rconti 10y ago
I'm not really clear on why anyone should care.
I recognize that my first reaction is an elitist "who cares what losers who 'follow' celebrities get sold on".
But even when I get past that, I can't figure out why I'd care. It doesn't sound like the FTC is in the business of determining what's a legitimate from-the-heart endorsement versus what's a paid endorsement anyway.
In the end, all that really seems to matter is truth in advertising. If she's making undocumented medical claims about something, and being paid to do so, doesn't the FTC already have a right to clamp down on it? Follow the dollars.
I imagine making undocumented medical claims for free fall under 'free speech'. So all they have to do is see if she's getting paid or not.
- Broken_Hippo 10y agoIt probably isn't a big issue if you are looking for something to drink. But say you are wanting to buy a larger investment item or one you don't know much about. Kitchen appliances are a good example. Let's say a coffee grinder. Perhaps you've bought a couple, and they haven't lasted long or been sup-par in quality, or maybe you had one you liked, but they no longer make it. You bought the same brand, but behold, it quit sooner or it doesn't do nearly as well. And you'd really like to have one that is decent, even if you spend a bit more money. If you can't sort out which reviews are paid endorsements and which ones are heartfelt reviews, you are none the wiser. Something that is basically an ad isn't nearly as trustworthy in this case. The ads might not have been false, per se, but they aren't exactly going to give the bad with the good.
- tbihl 10y agoIt seems that Amazon, for example, has already seen the huge problem that causes, and has been working to reduce that problem. At the other end of the spectrum, you'd be assigning the FTC to be like the small subset of redditors who feel compelled to reply "Hail Corporate!" any time you mention a product you like.
- Broken_Hippo 10y agoI do understand that it is a broad spectrum to regulate, and a lot of times, it'll go without being caught. But there are ways of undermining these sorts of things. For example, regulate the more visible folks fairly stringently. This is more because a 'known' individual, a public person, has more pull and status and visibility than the unknown person on reddit. I'd always punish the offending company much more (noticable fines, dependent on company financials) - they can require the person states the paid portion of their endorsement. In cases like Amazon, it might be hard to catch, but when it is, you can fine the companies involved in the paid support - an ad company, the parent company, etc. (Amazon itself seems to be against this and likely willing to cooperate, so they'd not have much issue).