3 ms·
Except that children can jump in front of you at arbitrary close distances so it's not possible to satisfy that. This purported solution seems to be a special
by SilasX 10y ago
Except that children can jump in front of you at arbitrary close distances so it's not possible to satisfy that.
This purported solution seems to be a special case of "assume I will never encounter a moral dilemma that forces me to make a hard choice". It's not solving the dilemma, but refusing to recognize that one exists. [1] Even if you think it can't happen this way, there are a hundred other ways it can manifest while driving.
[1] LessWrongers advocate the practice of choosing the "least convenient possible world" to avoid such side-stepping: https://wiki.lesswrong.com/wiki/Least_convenient_possible_world https://wiki.lesswrong.com/wiki/Least_convenient_possible_wo...
- honkhonkpants 10y agoThe trolley problem obtains its ethical considerations from the lethal outcomes. When you are driving you can easily prevent a lethal outcome by slowing down. Even a child is unlikely to die when struck by a car going 20 MPH or less. So yes, slowing down does fix this problem. If you are driving down a street where it is possible that a child will suddenly leap out, completely unseen by you, then you should be driving 20 MPH at most.
- joncrocks 10y agoSo you should always drive at less than 20mph? For every "but that'll never happen" there's a contrived scenario where it could. Yes, it could be a vanishingly small chance, but it's not going to go away.
- honkhonkpants 10y agoEverywhere? No but in neighborhoods with limited sight lines I do. You ever heard of the 20's Plenty campaign?
- joncrocks 10y agoIndeed (we've something similar here in the UK). The point I was trying to make is that the trolley problem is always going to exist, saying "no, just slow down" doesn't make the problem of making decisions go away. There are always going to be scenarios where an automated system is going to have to decide what to do in a life or death situation. And someone's going to have to decide how such systems will respond.
- honkhonkpants 10y agoI don't see how they could do a worse job than the humans do. Most human drivers aren't aware of the life-or-death situation until a loud noise interrupts their snapchatting.
- bryanlarsen 10y agoTrolley situations require approximately equal chances of death for passengers and pedestrians. Nobody or nothing can predict such probabilities with any degree of accuracy. Some people die when they trip and fall, others survive 80mph collisions. So either the situation has obvious probabilities and subsequently obvious solutions or there are such huge error bars that there's no right answer.
- bryanlarsen 10y agoSo you divide into two categories: - stuff that is relatively common, like children playing on streets. So if you get into that situation you were driving too fast, or there's something you should have done in the first place to avoid it. - stuff that isn't common, like children playing on freeways. In which case it's rare enough that the answer is a nice philosophical exercise but isn't practical. The real world is never as clean as such philosophical exercises. Defaulting to 'slam on the brakes' may perhaps be improved upon, but the difference will be very marginal.