3 ms·

Here are a few more principles of Western Law for you. Statute of Limitations. Ex Post Facto. If this tax activity was illegal, why wasn't it stopped 25 years

• _Codemonkeyism 10y ago
  "Ex Post Facto" It was illegal all the way, only Apple wants to make it legal. "why wasn't it stopped 25 years ago, when it started?" If murdering is illegal, why wasn't it stopped 5000 years ago? Don't know. People do illegal things all the time, most people doing illegal things do not get prosecuted for various reasons, fashion, society, not enough prosecutors. The argument "I was not prosecuted some years, so it was not illegal" doesn't work with any court. "Statutes of limitations" I don't know the time frames and for what time frame Apple needs to pay fines. Could you share the time frames where you think Apple got illegally fined? I'm no expert in tax law but would assume, here in Germany, there is no "Statutes of limitations" for taxes. Countries lose all their humor when it's about taxes.
  • maratd 10y ago
    > The argument "I was not prosecuted some years, so it was not illegal" doesn't work with any court. That's exactly how it works. Look up statute of limitations. Most civil violations have stringent limits. > I'm no expert in tax law but would assume, here in Germany, there is no "Statutes of limitations" for taxes. Countries lose all their humor when it's about taxes. I didn't know German law applied in Ireland. Perhaps that's the entire point of the EU, I don't know. Anyway, Ireland explicitly says that nothing is owed. Maybe you should read a bit more about this issue before commenting?