5 ms·
The most specific and IMHO damming allegation was how they avoided paying tax. From the EU press release: [Ireland] endorsed a split of the profits for ta
by madeofpalk 10y ago
The most specific and IMHO damming allegation was how they avoided paying tax.
From the EU press release:
[Ireland] endorsed a split of the profits for tax purposes in Ireland: Under
the agreed method, most profits were internally allocated away from Ireland
to a "head office" within Apple Sales International. This "head office" was
not based in any country and did not have any employees or own premises.
[...]
The remaining vast majority of profits were allocated to the "head office",
where they remained untaxed [...] an effective tax rate of about 0.05% on
its overall annual profits.
So, at the advice of Ireland, Apple was able to attribute sales to 'Apple Sales International', which was not based in any country and thus was not subject to tax.
- threeseed 10y agoThis is known as the "Double Irish, Dutch Sandwich" tax strategy. And has been used by many multinationals e.g. Google, Facebook, Ikea, Coke for many years.
- draw_down 10y agoThen shouldn't all of them be in trouble right now too?
- MollyR 10y agoThey probably will be next.
- draw_down 10y agoAh, "next". I gather that European tax law prosecution must differ from other kinds, because if me and five of my buddies did a crime we'd all be in trouble simultaneously.
- MollyR 10y agoprecedent has to be set somewhere.
- saynsedit 10y agoJust a note, precedent has little impact on law outside of countries that don't practice common law. Common law originates from the UK and Germany and France don't practice it, therefore precedence has little to no impact.
- germanier 10y agoThis is not entirely true. Precedence works different, sure. But saying precedence has no impact is (at least in the German legal system I know) absolutely false. For example, the German criminal code is sparse on detail and enforcement in courts is largely based on earlier decisions by higher courts. The important difference is that judges are not legally bound by those decisions and they usually don't directly refer to those (except for high-profile decisions) but just re-use the same arguments. But if they don't follow earlier decisions and have no good reason their verdict is going to be thrown out (again, by re-using old arguments instead of directly referring to precedence.) To bring this back to topic: Litigation one example to establish a known interpretation of the law and then going after similiar cases (which are then decided on a low level based on the work in another case already done) is absolutely common in Germany. Courts don't want to flip-flop on very similiar cases with no reason - in fact they are not allowed to by the constitution.
- raattgift 10y agoThat's not entirely accurate when talking about the French and German forms of private law, which are the most popular non-common-law private law systems in the European Union (there are others, such as the Swedish system). In both systems, periodic codification of the body of private law is made by the judiciary, executive and legislative branches working together at regular intervals with a goal of producing a nearly complete set of relevant rules for dealing with lawsuits between private persons. The contrast is most keenly seen in landlord-tenant law, which in France is fully codified in a single document, while there are many Acts of Parliament and case law that apply in England and Wales. In the French and German systems, matters that cannot be fully decided by reference to the relevant codified law are dealt with by the court of first instance writing down a decision with logic similar to that done in county courts in the UK. The parties generally have an automatic right of appeal from the court of first instance to a court that behaves very similarly to either the High Court in England or the Court of Appeal for England and Wales when it hears evidence sua sponte. The rulings of these appellate courts will almost always form the basis for a revision of the relevant code, and in the interim the appellate courts will generally reverse any ruling by a court of first instance that conflicts. Codification also happens in public law, both administrative law and criminal law. Many common-law countries other than England and Wales -- most notably Canada and the United States (federally, and in several of the states) have a criminal code that is amended and revised from time to time. The German system of codification in criminal law also incorporates points of what in the U.S. would be doctrinal (i.e., wholly maintained by the judiciary) directly into the code, so that most criminal cases do not have to make reference to any other document even where there are controversies over the behaviour of the police or other authorities. Precedent -- not precedence -- therefore differs mainly in the use of extra-statutory material in courts of first instance. Note that in this particular case, European Administrative and Procedural Law (and particularly with respect to member-states' compliance with the Treaty of the European Union) is the relevant system, and while it strives to codify after the fact, typically a Directorate-General of the European Commission holds quasi-judicial hearings and writes down a detailed analysis and order in a process that in English Law would be considered secondary or delegated legislation, or something very very roughly similar to an Executive Order of a form explicitly allowed by an Act of Congress (one might compare decisions of e.g. the FCC). These orders are reviewable by the Commission as a whole, and in principle references may be made to the Council on an ad hoc basis. Parties subjected to adverse orders have a right to go to the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) on various grounds, and there is an appeals process within the CJEU. This system stems from (among others) Articles 41 and 47 of the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union and Article 298 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union. With respect to precedent under this system, in general if an administrative decision by the Commission is not appealed or is not overturned on appeal, it remains part of secondary law until and unless the CJEU or the legislature (both parts, the European Parliament and the European Council) changes it. That means that Commission decisions that elucidate a general principle is binding on future Commission decisions. I can't imagine what to call that other than binding precedent.
- Oletros 10y agoWell, 35 EU companies were subjected to the same ruling in Belgium earlier this year and Belgian government has to recover 700 million euro. Apple is not the first case, it is just more mediatic and has a bigger sum
- simonswords82 10y agoIndeed, I suspect the companies you've listed and many more are watching this case keenly.
- ksrm 10y agoIsn't this just simple tax evasion? How can a head office not be based in any country or have any employees?
- pjc50 10y agohttp://www.bloomberg.com/research/stocks/private/snapshot.asp?privcapid=26016763 http://www.bloomberg.com/research/stocks/private/snapshot.as... "Apple Sales International supplies and distributes Apple products. Apple Sales International was formerly known as Apple Computer International. The company is based in Hollyhill, Ireland. Apple Sales International operates as a subsidiary of Apple Inc."
- madeofpalk 10y agoAhh right. And thus the 'Double Irish': It relies on the fact that Irish tax law does not include transfer pricing rules. Specifically, Ireland has territorial taxation, and does not levy taxes on income booked in subsidiaries of Irish companies that are outside the state. Funny - when it's phrased like this it seems a whole less clear about what Ireland (and Apple) has done wrong. It's also worth noting that Ireland has passed tax reform to render this not possible any more.
- throwawayReply 10y agoFalling to 0.005% [...] In subsequent years, Apple Sales International's recorded profits continued to increase but the profits considered taxable in Ireland under the terms of the tax ruling did not. Thus this effective tax rate decreased further to only 0.005% in 2014.
- pmontra 10y agoAnd to use Cook's words "A company’s profits should be taxed in the country where the value is created." By this logic maybe the EU should get only VAT, which is paid by Apple's customers and not by Apple, but the US is left without a huge amount of tax money.
- ivan_gammel 10y agoI'd agree with you, but this probably requires some advanced tax evasion deal between US and EU.
- socket0 10y agoThat statement itself means very little. I would argue the value is created where thousands of workers turn designs into millions of individual devices; Tim Cook might argue value is created where slapping an Apple logo on the device transforms it from a regular gadget into a luxury status symbol. Either way the issue here isn't where Apple should pay tax, but that they should be taxed fairly. There are many international tax treaties to prevent double taxation, Apple simply need to pay tax like (most) everyone else.
- mcphage 10y agoYou see, if there's no clear answer to where the value is created, then there's no clear answer to where the profits are taxed! So it kinda clips through the cracks. Whoops!
- maxmax 10y agoThe value is "created" where the sale is made. Until money changes hands, there is no concrete value.
- webXL 10y agoSeems simple enough, but money is changing hands throughout the production process. Apple and its suppliers' wages are taxed. What's left over is taxed when spent or invested for a return. Given the leviathan tax systems out there, it's no wonder tax havens exist in the first place. Before judging this activity as unethical and shifting the tax avoidance to some other place though, governments really need to perform a cost-benefit analysis of their tax laws and make it clear to companies what's expected from them in return for access to their market.
- chiph 10y agoThe firm had to be incorporated somewhere.
- Oletros 10y agoFrom the rulingÑ > ASI, formerly Apple Computer International and originally Apple Computer Accessories Ltd., is a 100% subsidiary of AOE. ASI is an Irish-incorporated non-resident company that is carrying on a trade through a branch in Ireland
- JohnStrange 10y agoIt's amazing that this scheme is even legal. In fact, I'm pretty sure it wouldn't be legal if Kim Dotcom did it.
- josho 10y agoThose with money and/or power get to make the rules. Dotcom certainly has neither compared to the corporations that he pissed off. I'm starting to understand how vital unions were for being a lobbyist to the gov. That spoke from the people's perspective. There is a lot that I dislike about unions but their voice representing the people is missed.
- andrepd 10y agoUnions are a necessary lesser evil. The alternative, unchecked power to the corporations, is much much worse.
- akerro 10y ago>'Apple Sales International', which was not based in any country and thus was not subject to tax. How can I do it?