3 ms·
There isn't a simple answer here - like in most non-trivial data science/ML questions. The only think I think worth pointing out is that in the mortgage exampl
by nl 10y ago
There isn't a simple answer here - like in most non-trivial data science/ML questions.
The only think I think worth pointing out is that in the mortgage example the current location of a person isn't as major an influence as income. The fairness test here seems somewhat reasonable: a person on $10K/y who lives in Oakland should probably have the same outcome as someone on $10K/y from some very white area - all other things being equal.
The flip-side is that under a human-biased system, the first white person might get the mortgage based on being white, and the second black person might be denied. That would be reversed under an algorithmic system only considering legitimate factors, and surely that's progress?
Yes, I think so? Or at least it can be audited (in theory at least - although see sentencing guideline systems for the problems with this).