3 ms·
Almost all universities public and private in the US are 501(3)(c) nonprofit organizations. (Some public ones are more or less an extension of the government an
by colechristensen 10y ago
Almost all universities public and private in the US are 501(3)(c) nonprofit organizations. (Some public ones are more or less an extension of the government and don't count)
For-profit universities ... aren't. They're owned and operated by for-profit companies, the accreditation is usually terrible and in no way comparable to other universities, and they deceive students into thinking they'll be getting something similar to a university degree.
For example, ITT is run by ITT Educational Services Inc
https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/ESI https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/ESI
---
What really needs to happen, is the US needs to restrict federal student loans to programs on a whitelist of accreditors (whitelisting the accreditation organization not the program, like ABET for example) as well as restricting organizations calling themselves "institute", "university", etc. as well as giving out "degrees" without matching the whitelist.
I have _no_ problem with the concept of a for-profit university, but they're being allowed to exist with very low standards and it needs to stop.
In fact I think the whole university system needs to tighten it's belt and be made smaller and more elite. Too many people think that ticking a university box is necessary to get a job / to hire a person, especially when so many people get such low quality degrees.
I'm not even railing against soft degrees, but their contents instead. "Liberal Arts" ... if you deconstruct that you can get to the original meaning which might be rephrased something like "the skills necessary to live a free life" which a whole lot of university degrees these days do not do at all.
- duncan_bayne 10y agoSo, this seems to me like a problem that is almost perfectly amenable to market solutions. University has poor standards? Don't hire their graduates, or at least, don't weight their qualifications as heavily. I don't understand why you think Government action - that is, force - is necessary here. Or is it that you think they are defrauding their students by calling themselves Universities?
- douche 10y agoThe main reason is that the government is the one holding the pursestrings that enables the whole system to operate. If federally-guaranteed student loans cannot be used by these places, their business model collapses entirely. And a big chunk of these terrible for-profit universities are also preying on veterans using their GI Bill benefits.
- colechristensen 10y agoAccreditation organizations are private. Vetted by the Department of Education, but still private organizations. It's just an external audit, and there's nothing at all wrong with that. These for-profit organizations are defrauding students by providing very low quality and very expensive educations, all the while passing the low quality standards set by a broken accreditor. Market solutions don't work when the target audience are young people investing a huge chunk of their lives in education. If a new brand of coffee and it's horrible, you can just try a different brand. A college student doesn't have the same luxury.
- TheCoelacanth 10y ago> they are defrauding their students by calling themselves Universities Yes, that is what I think
- duncan_bayne 10y agoOkay, if that's the case, then taking them to court for fraud and stripping them of their accreditation would indeed be reasonable.
- ryuker16 10y agoThey usually form a fake accredation system owned by a private entity recognized by no one but themselves in the same corporate umbrella. As to why theyre ellegible for student loans (unlike most code bootcamps)....excessive lobbying. Hence why their credits rarely transfer to other schools.
- ryuker16 10y agoMost companies and hilariously the owners have a policy to not hire these graduates. These schools have high pressure sale teams who target the bottom of the barrel or the clueless leaving the tax payer on the hook for defaulted loans. Its no different than scammers who target the elderly or children with false claims.