3 ms·
> Smiling as such does not make us feel happier. That is trivially proven, just as pretending to cry does nit make us sadder. It may be trivially proven, but t
by vidarh 10y ago
> Smiling as such does not make us feel happier. That is trivially proven, just as pretending to cry does nit make us sadder.
It may be trivially proven, but there's been decades of research hinting that the opposite was true, and took a major replication project to give the first published indication it isn't.
In the end, we probably know that it's not as simple as the original research indicated (indicating smiles can change your mood), but the replication setup differed from the original research in many ways, and we don't know why it failed to replicate. Maybe the effect does't exist, or maybe the changes affected the outcome. Or maybe the fact that this is a very famous experiment may have affected the outcome (though in that case one might have expected the effect to get stronger?)
I wouldn't be surprised if the effect isn't real, but I won't be surprised if people get other results with different tweaks to the method either - they are trying to measure emotional effects from small physical changes. If they truly do exist, then it's not that odd if they are fickle in terms of experimentation setup when psychologists have to invent all kinds of elaborate schemes to "trick" subjects to try to exclude effects caused by experimentation stup.
E.g. in this case they were trying to prevent people from knowing that they were trying to get them to smile, to measure whether just the physical act of putting your mouth in that shape will make you happier.
It's important to consider that both the original paper and the attempted reproduction is explicitly not measuring whether you deciding to force a smile makes you happier or not, or if you putting your mouth into a smile for unknown reasons and recognising that you are smiling will make you happier or not.
Whether or not the original paper or the replication attempt are right, it's a very narrow finding, that does not address your statement.