2 ms·
s/Intelligence/Civilization/ And yet: I've been surprised how many successful people barely (or crudely) read or write. One such recurring type is the dyslexic
by gojomo 17y ago
s/Intelligence/Civilization/
And yet: I've been surprised how many successful people barely (or crudely) read or write. One such recurring type is the dyslexic entrepreneur. They are very intelligent -- but also very verbal/kinesthetic and not at all text-oriented. (I also suspect, without ready examples, that other great artists/performers/craftsmen are awful readers/writers.)
These types of intelligence will be underrepresented in a forum like this -- where 98%+ of our projected presence is writing.
So even while our giant enterprises (sprawling corporations, large governments) and engineering projects (bridges, computers) are dependent on the written word and text-based intelligence for coordination, we shouldn't forget the widely-dispersed and valuable non-textual intelligence we also rely upon.
- nopassrecover 17y agoIs that intelligence valuable if it had to be reinvented every generation because it is lost though?
- gojomo 17y agoAccepting your premise: maybe that need-for-reinvention makes it more valuable -- it can't be mass-produced by the printing press. Contesting your premise: these intelligences are passed down in other ways -- including ways that we hyperlexics barely perceive well enough to properly value.
- nooneelse 17y agoI've often wondered if enabling the capture and transmission of this type of knowledge would be one of the killer applications for ubiquitous-ish wearable computers (or to put it more fancifully, one of the advantages of the Borg). Someone who is good at something but isn't good at explaining how they do it could wear the rig and the task could be recorded a few times through from their perspective (they could say how they think of the task's steps or whatever if they felt like it, but it wouldn't be needed). Other people, better able to describe things, could annotate the replays, break them into steps, explain motivations, put in branches for various cases, etc. A kind of first-person wikihow. That seems to be along the line of translating the non-verbal into video and text formats, making the non-textual wisdom more like text so we hyperlexics can sift it our way. Various trials using wearable computers to aid inspection and maintenance tasks have been done, but I guess we are still waiting on the tech and interfaces (or maybe more the social acceptance or right marketing) to catch up to the idea.
- hassy 17y agoTim Bray exhibits the error of rationalism in this piece. Knowledge can be split into two types. The first one is what's usually called knowledge: what you can learn from a book, get graded on, formalize, prove, explain etc. This is academic knowledge, the know what, the episteme. The second type is more ambiguous. It's more of a way of doing things -- easier to show than to explain in words, something that one can do well without being able to put it on paper. This type of knowledge is implicit, it's the know how, it comes from practice and experience, it's the techne. The error of rationalism is overestimating the importance of the first type of knowledge. To someone unaware of the distinction - someone who reads too much - it will seem that all knowledge is of the first type, because it is all they see in their books.