8 ms·
Are PhD Students Irrational?
- loser777 10y agoIn computer science, I feel that this definition of irrational only applies in the same way that doing anything that isn't maximizing my $/hour rate is irrational. Sure, the academic job market is very competitive (though CS arguably has more opportunities than other fields), and landing a solid industry research position is no cakewalk either. But the difficulties in finding a research job don't preclude doing software engineering work to pay the bills. It's not uncommon to decide a few years into a graduate program that you'd rather just be making more money and drop out for a more lucrative industry/industry research position. For CS PhD students, the job market only seems terrible if you have a very narrow definition of a job (which seems irrational).
- danielvf 10y agoYes, CS is way better than most majors in that you can move without too much difficulty from post-graduate studies to a good job. For many other majors, when moving out of acedemia, people end up working at Starbucks, or as a receptionist at a doctor's office. And to top it off, you've got thirty thousand dollars in debt on top of a low paying job.
- altoz 10y agoThe article doesn't really touch on this, but for people embarking on a PhD program, school is what they've been doing 8 or so hours a day for 16+ years and school is what they're good at (or else they wouldn't have gotten into the PhD program). It's the least disruptive path post-college for a certain group of college grads and their choice is to trade potential financial gain for stability and familiarity. That may not be the best choice for each one of them, but it's certainly not irrational.
- eli_gottlieb 10y agoThat rather fails to account for people who "go back to school" for a PhD after finishing their undergrad and working for a while.
- gnarbarian 10y agoThose who can, Do...
- kibibu 10y ago...those who can't, comment on HN
- Noseshine 10y agoHe wrote > for a certain group of college grads Also, even if he hadn't said that, I don't know, do we really have to explain for statements clearly meant to be understood that way what "statistical" means, on HN, and in a thread about Ph.D.s? How many go back to a Ph.D. program once they are in an industry vs. how many get there without having left academia?
- stevenwiles 10y agoIt is absolutely irrational
- nickff 10y agoShould universities not be held accountable for the fraud that they have perpetrated on their students? The tobacco companies were taken to court because their products had long-term consequences which they persistently minimized, while continuing to push product; it seems universities have done the same. If anything, the universities have better, clearer data than the tobacco companies, and the universities have far more people with clear understandings of both statistics and the observable consequences of getting a PhD. Throwing away the last years of your life because of cancer doesn't seem clearly worse than throwing away the best years of your life seeking a PhD.
- nevdka 10y agoThe observable consequences of PhDs are higher salaries and lower unemployment than Masters, Bachelors or lower [0]. PhD students also spend 'the best years of their lives' working deeply on something they care about. Where's the fraud? [0] http://www.bls.gov/emp/ep_chart_001.htm http://www.bls.gov/emp/ep_chart_001.htm
- ikeyany 10y agoI'm guessing the depressing reality that you're spending those years broke, stressed out, and doing unglamorous work compared to your peers who went for greener pastures.
- eli_gottlieb 10y agoYou should read the article more closely. It advocates exactly holding universities accountable, and in particular, holding universities accountable for deliberately casualizing academic (ie: PhD-holding) labor by converting tenured professorships into adjunct positions, even while expanding enrollments and using the tuition money to hire more and more administrators. It would be more accurate to say that universities are exploitative than that the existence of a self-reproducing class of professional scientists is irrational. >But perhaps the best way to get answers is to talk to the parents of college students, the ones footing the bill. Ask whether they’d rather pay that ballooning college tuition for lazy rivers on campus, for fruit baskets and housekeepers for executive staff, and for other rising non-classroom costs; or for more top PhD talent, smaller classrooms, more one-on-one attention from faculty, more independent studies and research opportunities with faculty, and a stable faculty who won’t have to leave halfway through their student’s college career. Then you’ll get a sense of the real, unmet demand for PhDs, and the irrationality of a market that isn’t delivering.
- hprotagonist 10y agoI'd say it entirely depends on the assumption that to get a PhD means that you want to be a professor (and teach in the US at a reasonably decent school and get tenure one day). If that really is your goal, then yes, you should think very hard before you do it. The Adjunct scam is really, truly atrocious. Adjucts and grad students can unionize now, though, and it only takes one strike in the e. coli labs for a research university to cave... However, PhDs do have valuable (and financially rewarding) roles in nonprofit research institutions that are not subject to the same challenges as universities (though I sure hope you like writing grants), In "real" industry positions, a PhD can be a way to bulwark yourself against "the engineer trap", where you get promoted into a project management role and become unable to actually do anything except munge Excel documents. It is a gamble. I have an engineering background, so I can't really speak to what it is like to, e.g., have a PhD in English. But, depending on your degree, there are also really cool gigs at places like microsoft research -- they do everything from cell biology to audio, now, as well as employ "pure theory" CS folks.
- ryuker16 10y agounionize? Too many scabs waiting to take their spots while rich foreign kids and local trustfarians don't need the money.
- ryuker16 10y agounionize? Too many scabs waiting to take their spots while rich foreign kids and local trustfarians don't need the money.
- gozur88 10y ago>The Adjunct scam is really, truly atrocious. Adjucts and grad students can unionize now, though, and it only takes one strike in the e. coli labs for a research university to cave... Grad students have been forming unions since the '70s, and it hasn't had any impact. There are so few tenure track positions you can't afford to even slightly irritate the people you need to get one, and everyone views their stint as a TA or an adjunct as temporary.
- jdoliner 10y agoFrom my reading it seems like the crux of the argument is this: > We’ve presupposed a scenario in which there really is a massive oversupply of PhDs, and thus PhD students must be irrational for treading into an oversupplied labor market. But that’s simply not true. PhD “oversupply” is just a euphemistic way of talking about the fact that colleges and universities haven’t met student-generated demand with a commensurate supply of full-time, tenure-track faculty. PhDs aren't irrational for wasting 5 years on something that won't net them a job... universities are shirking their responsibility to provide a job to those who demand them.
- back_beyond 10y agoYou seem to be framing PhDs as terrorists. Why is the university obligated to provide jobs when students come regardless of the extent its faculty is exploited?
- versteegen 10y agoSee the next sentences in the article (which I quoted above).
- rahimnathwani 10y ago"universities haven’t met student-generated demand with a commensurate supply of full-time, tenure-track faculty" This reverses the normal definitions of 'supply' and 'demand' to make a weak point. Universities are the buyers, i.e. they have demand for faculty. The PhD graduates are the suppliers (of their labour), i.e. they can compete to fulfill that demand. So to say universities have a responsibility to hire people, just because those people want/need jobs, goes against how we normally think about the way the world works. No one owes me a job. EDIT: zasz is correct. I read that quotation out of context, and as a result my comment doesn't address the point. I still disagree with the assertion, but for a different reason. Undergraduate students don't demand 'full-time' or 'tenure-track' faculty. Those aspects don't directly affect how well they are taught, or the value of the credentials they gain.
- 10y ago
- sn41 10y agoI don't see why being irrational is bad. A "labour of love" is precisely something that does not obey the law of diminishing returns. Passion and interest are much more sustaining and fulfilling than a job in the finance sector just because it is highly paid. I think "rationality" is a stupid assumption, often wrong. Of course, people need more money, but a lot of people are also willing to make sacrifices for something else - spouses, children, parents, religion or country. Money is important, but not the overriding concern for everyone. I often feels that the correct word for a "rational" individual in the sense of economics is "sociopath". Ralph Nader once said about his organization, that "you can bring your conscience to work" every day. This actually counts for a lot. However the basic point of the article, that the Universities are conning students is perfectly valid (source: ex-PhD student, can relate to the frustration). This point needs to be better made, avoiding slinging mud on the intellect of the hapless students. This article is an example of how you can write a dubious article, even in the presence of good data.
- catskul2 10y agoIt's not necessarily bad if you can afford to be irrational. If you can't, the it's bad for obvious reasons.
- groovy2shoes 10y agoEveryone on this thread seems to be focusing entirely on money when determining whether or not something is rational. The Economics 101 definition of rational that I recall from university is only tangentially related to strictly monetary value -- things usually provide non-monetary value as well ("opportunity cost", etc.). If every trade were always based solely on monetary value, trade would be a zero-sum game, but it's not: fair trade is a win-win situation. Seller wins because the product is worth more to the buyer than it cost to produce; buyer wins because the product is worth more to them than it cost to buy. If this weren't the case, one or both parties would decline the trade (assuming, of course, as economists are wont to do, that both parties are rational). As you point out, there are plenty of non-monetary benefits to academia: passion, interest, fulfillment, pride, etc. These things have different value to different people depending on their own interests and goals. If the total benefit (tangible and intangible) is worth more to someone than the opportunity cost, then, according to economics, that person is still acting rationally in such pursuits. I'm not an economist, but this is seriously undergraduate-level Introductory Economics material.
- throw_away_777 10y agoIn my experience people don't enter into PhDs expecting to make a lot of money. And STEM PhDs get paid, so it isn't as if we accumulate debt. Often times a PhD is the only route to doing what you love. It isn't possible to do academic research in industry. Personally when I entered into my PhD I really liked that the research I was doing had a noble purpose. On the other hand, a PhD is way too long. And if you stop at year 4 or so you have basically wasted 4 years. I did not appreciate how much my values would change over time and sort of got locked into trying to finish my PhD. Trying to finish a PhD when you don't have passion for the subject anymore is very stressful. This experience is disturbingly common. Finally, the author early on implies that the job market for STEM PhDs is not good. At least in physics, this is only true in academia. I know many people who have transitioned successfully to data science, or who have gotten a post doc. Overall, the unemployment rate of physics PhDs is low.
- xapata 10y agoThere was a time when a failed postdoc was in a very depressing financial situation. Corporations didn't want to hire a PhD, because they were overqualified and likely had some anti-authoritarian streak that led them to attempt academia. STEM PhDs are more in demand these days, but some still don't know it and need encouragement (and sometimes a little help) transitioning to industry.
- throw_away_777 10y agoI agree with your sentiment, and think that postdocs are the real problem with academia currently. Besides the low pay, being a graduate student is not a bad job - you get good job security, interesting problems, good mission, and can somewhat choose your boss. A postdoc is a terrible, soul-crushing, low-pay job. At least for the physics postdocs I have seen - I have heard that in the humanities a postdoc is actually a highly sought after position.
- xapata 10y agoOne of the saddest conversations I've ever had was with a two-time assistant professor who had just been denied tenure (second chance is the last). A mutual friend had referred him to me for advice on how to transition to industry. I gave him a pep-talk and explained how to build a portfolio to show skills that matter in the workplace. I think he turned things around, but for a little while he couldn't stop thinking about the "wasted" years. PhD, postdoc(s), 3-5 years of assistantship, repeated once, ... it's a tragedy for such a smart, capable person to succeed so much and yet feel like they failed.
- sjg007 10y agoA PhD is a great way to immigrate and this drives down PhD stipends. A PhD is a great way to continue learning.. And good for the overall economy because companies rely on math, science and engineering to produce products.
- hardtke 10y agoTo further this point, it is much faster to get a green card if you possess a Ph.D. rather than a Master's degree. Not only can you apply for the outstanding researcher category, but I believe you also get priority for the regular process. For Master's holders, the process in 5+ years now.
- cperciva 10y agoA PhD at a good institution is also a great way to open doors which would otherwise remain closed. I found that opening emails with "I'm a DPhil student at the Oxford University Computing Lab and" resulted in a dramatic increase in how helpful people would be.
- gohrt 10y agoCompanies need very few PhDs in math, science and engineering -- bachelors and masters do fine.
- sjg007 10y agoMy company hires tons of PhDs.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- thr0waway1239 10y agoWhen talking only about software and CS, I think there is one more way to look at this issue (and has been mentioned multiple times in this comment thread). Let us say the typical software engineer's day is filled up with the following types of tasks: 1. What patio11 describes, although in a different context: "Don't try to make a career out of optimizing the SQL queries to display a preference page on a line of business app at a company that no one has ever heard of." [1] 2. Some kind of algorithmic work (e.g. writing a compiler) 3. Big data, machine learning etc. (consuming the results of algorithms, hence different from 2) 4. Software architecting My view is that after a while, most people want to move from group 1 to one of the other groups. This gives a good way to explain the pursuit of Ph.D. even when it is not economically rational (both in time and money cost) - it is a pursuit of something which is not mundane as long as you make the effort. A teacher of mine said: "You are going to be spending about 40 years in your career. If you take 5 out of that to do a Ph.D. you are not going to reflect on it with regret. And at the end of it you have a Ph.D. too." When you combine this with the possibility that you will be mostly hanging out with elastic minded students as PG once put it and you might actually have the time of your (intellectual) life, the decision doesn't look all that irrational. [1] https://training.kalzumeus.com/newsletters/archive/do-not-end-the-week-with-nothing https://training.kalzumeus.com/newsletters/archive/do-not-en...
- nnain 10y agoNo. Reason: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge%27s_law_of_headlines https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge%27s_law_of_headline...
- nnain 10y agoHah, downvotes. I thought people would get that I was 'trying' to joke.
- geebee 10y agoHard to say. The RAND institute did a study concluding that there is no meaningful shortage of STEM graduate degrees, that the aversion to these degrees, to the extent it exists, is a rational response to completion times, attrition rates, job prospects, and salaries when compared to other professional degree programs such as MBA, law, or medicine. However, this wasn't quite the same as concluding that it is irrational to pursue these degrees, just that we should stop scratching our heads and wondering why more people don't pursue them. Payscale has an interesting ranking of graduate degrees by program, which is more useful than raking all holders of a particular graduate degree together. http://www.payscale.com/college-salary-report/grad?page=49 http://www.payscale.com/college-salary-report/grad?page=49 Unfortunately, it doesn't break out MS and PhD holders by subject studied. So while you do get to see a specific ranking for an MBA or JD holder from UCLA or MIT, you only get overall salary info for PhDs from MIT, not PhD in Computer Science from MIT vs Electrical Engineering from Berkeley. That would be far more useful. As it stands, a PhD doesn't show up until spot 29 on this list, but then again, a PhD in CS might, so hard to say. To me, the attrition rate from PhD programs is an under appreciated aspect of this discussion. A lot of people from elite Law, MBA, and MD programs are floored when they hear the attrition rate from PhD programs. Seriously, the attrition rate form an elite law or med school tends to be well below one half of one percent. Attrition rates form elite engineering and science PhD programs range from 35%-50%. In any case, I'm always glad to see this discussed. The only people who seem to think there is a "shortage" or STEM graduate students are people who have a financial interest in hiring STEM graduate students. Almost every other analysis concludes that people with the freedom to choose their career in the US (free of visa restrictions that limit their career choices) are largely acting rationally by pursuing other graduate degree programs (or no graduate degree program).
- chestervonwinch 10y ago> ... the attrition rate form an elite law or med school tends to be well below one half of one percent. Attrition rates form elite engineering and science PhD programs range from 35%-50%. Many PhD programs offer full tuition, health care, and a yearly stipend with teaching duties. OTOH, there may be less incentive to give someone the boot if they're bringing in large sums of money by paying their way through, which is how most master's and professional degrees work (as I understand).
- Futurebot 10y agoIf you enjoyed this piece, you should read "Planet Loser": "If you actually want to know why people persist in going to grad school, or trying to be screenwriters or musicians or professional athletes or actors — or, if we’re getting really real about it, journalists and writers, the kind that write for The Atlantic — it’s because our culture insists relentlessly that certain kinds of work have intellectual and aesthetic value, that they are a way to be a Somebody, and also that you never, ever give up on your dreams. There is no message that we deliver to children and adolescents more relentlessly than that they should pursue their dreams with manic focus and unflagging persistence, no matter how hard and often they fail, and that they will be assured of eventual victory. Never, never, never give up. Whether you think you can, or you think you can’t, you’re right! If you believe it, you can achieve it. Go to a middle school sometime. Look at the posters on the wall. It’s like a one-party state, propaganda of the most ubiquitous and intense variety. When I was a long-term sub at my local junior high I was amazed; it was like some sort of totalitarian reeducation camp, with the purpose being to indoctrinate in all who passed through the doors that failure stems always and only from a lack of nerve." http://fredrikdeboer.com/2016/04/24/planet-loser/ http://fredrikdeboer.com/2016/04/24/planet-loser/
- Chinjut 10y agoYes! This is the best, most on-the-mark account of the matter I've ever read. (Granted, I've read it before, but I'll say it again). Amazing how few people writing about the issue see, or at least note, this basic insight.
- alpineidyll3 10y agoSo do you think that a 20 year old deterministically absorbs the values of their culture? Don't be so paternalistic. College students are not children; they are not your students. The value of a PhD is not high because the life of a PhD is desirable. Academia provides a (flawed) society with a permanence and thoughtfulness that competes with non academic america. Leisure and camaraderie is everywhere. It provides a sense of identity which is hard to find, so supply is high and price is low. Within the cult there are bad actors who misrepresent their value, and selfishly collect rewards. Nothings perfect.
- j7ake 10y agoSince we are on HN, how does this irrationally differ from the hordes of people going into start ups hoping they will be the next AirBnB? I would be interested in comparing the chances of a graduate student becoming a tenured professor versus a fresh grad starting a start up that becomes a unicorn.
- cossatot 10y agoIf we stick to PhDs as opposed to the excellent but undervalued MS degree: Far better chance of becoming a tenured professor (I'd say roughly 1 in 10-20 in my field, geoscience). Plus, like has been said elsewhere in this thread, after 4-7+ years of being underpaid and overworked, you've got a PhD. However, a freshly-tenured professor at a major research school might make 100k, and might make 150k by full professor. Very few outside of business/medicine/maybe some engineering make more than 200k by full professor. If you found a unicorn, you probably do a bit better than that, financially.
- j7ake 10y agoThose seem to be pretty good odds. Thanks for the rough estimate. You can also hit 'unicorns' as a scientist, for example a major discovery (nobel prize) or innovation (millennium technology prize), which should be taken into account somehow if we want to compare the two. In start ups there are lots of discussions and analysis of long tails and capturing unicorns (implying lots of failures along the way) but analysis of careers in science never gets the same treatment, although I find many connections between the two (many small failures but big wins). It is always statistics of what an average scientist would achieve rather than what a top scientist would achieve. It would be nice to apply some of the same analyses we do on careers in start ups to careers on science.