4 ms·
Forced smiles making you more happy? Talk to anyone in in-person customer service. Talk to a model or "sales associate". Talk to a waitress, or even a stripp
by sandworm101 10y ago
Forced smiles making you more happy? Talk to anyone in in-person customer service. Talk to a model or "sales associate". Talk to a waitress, or even a stripper. There are plenty of people who force smiles all day. It isn't fun. They don't feel better about themselves afterwards.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smile_mask_syndrome https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smile_mask_syndrome
"According to Natsume, this atmosphere sometimes causes women to smile unnaturally for so long that they start to suppress their real emotions and become depressed."
- duaneb 10y agoI don't think this is quite the same as forcing yourself to smile for yourself.
- AstralStorm 10y agoThe forced part is. If you actually choose to smile, then it is not forced, right? I'd like to meet a person who actually can "smile for themselves" most of the time.
- Retra 10y agoAs soon as you've decided to do something about being unhappy - even if it's just smiling - it's reasonable to think you'll be at least a slight bit happier.
- kristofferR 10y agoYeah - most people probably doesn't just think "I'm not feeling great, so I'll force my facial muscles to create a smile". Instead they are likely thinking "Hey, what am I bitching about, things aren't so bad. I have lots of things in my life to smile about, so let's do it.".
- jwdunne 10y agoThere is a difference between a forced smile and a genuine smile. There are a different muscles at play. If you force a laugh, you'll see muscle movements similar to a genuine smile. A forced smile tends to just use the muscles below the nose. When you test the difference, observe your emotions. Mindfulness is helpful here but I observe a genuine, immediate difference. Perhaps this can be explained by forces other than "fake it til you make it" but it works for me so I can reuse it when I need to. Now I know that a potential placebo effect means it's as good sugar water but sometimes sugar water is all you need to lift your spirits - a little better than rum and cola.
- vidarh 10y agoAnd this is a big problem with reading too much into the original result or the replication: They're not measuring forcing yourself to smile for yourself, or even forcing yourself to smile for someone else. They're measuring being tricked into shaping your mouth like a smile without being aware that you're doing it. That may be interesting and and of itself, but whether or not intentionally forcing a smile has an effect is an entirely separate question.
- SubiculumCode 10y agoThe smiling oppressed sex slave may indeed be happier than the frowning oppressed sex slave, but the frowning self empowered wealthy woman is likely happer than either the smiling or frowning opressed sex slave...on average.
- SubiculumCode 10y agoDown vote is interesting. I was using an example to illustrate the fallacy of the grandparent's argument, and apparently the choice of 'sex slave' as an example of a bad situation someone might find themselves in left a bad taste. Maybe, however the point was that just because someone might be miserable in a bad job that requires forced smiles doesnt mean that the forced smile doesnt have a positive effect, just a smaller effect than the o e associated with having a bad job.
- thaumasiotes 10y agoThe choice of "sex slave" as an example of a bad situation isn't why you're getting downvoted. You're getting downvoted because, in context, you seem to be labeling customer service representatives, models, sales associates, waitresses, and strippers as "sex slaves". You should blame yourself for that, not your audience; the inference is conventional, and is plausible in large part specifically because those are jobs that call for smiling. (Though even more so for models and strippers.)
- SubiculumCode 10y agoah. That was quite unintentional. I was using extremes to make a point, not to associate the two separate examples. However I can see how some might arrive to that inadverent conclusion.