4 ms·

I think it's worse than that -- for me it all reads, "young person with zero responsibilities chooses unsustainable lifestyle and has an awesome time". What hap

I think it's worse than that -- for me it all reads, "young person with zero responsibilities chooses unsustainable lifestyle and has an awesome time". What happens to the designers when their boat needs serious maintenance, something that boats need _constantly_? We already know that one of the van guys basically only was able to function because a friend helped him sell his (broken down) van and move his crap home for him. Game development is also a terrible platform to build a life on. What happens when you burn out? What happens if (when) no-one likes your game?

Impossible 10y ago
Although HN loves to hate game development, and I understand where you're coming from, at least in Rami's case he's in the top 0.1% of indie game developers and has multiple $1M+ grossing games on the market (http://steamspy.com/dev/Vlambeer http://steamspy.com/dev/Vlambeer). He is in every way the exception, but I think its ok for him to live and exceptional lifestyle if he wants to without fear of burn out or "no one liking his game". The HN view of game development tends to apply more to salaried AAA developers in mid or bottom tier studios, and new, inexperienced or unsuccessful indie game developers, which might be the majority, but are certainly not Rami.
- stevenwiles 10y ago
  > but I think its ok for him to live and exceptional lifestyle if he wants to without fear of burn out or "no one liking his game". So you are ok with him living his life how he chooses? Why do you think that is something that needed to be said? That should be everyone's default disposition, so I'm not sure if you're expecting a cookie for this or what? Also, I don't think you have a strong enough grasp of this community to begin making assertions about its opinions towards certain professionals. As it is, your comment reads like "Silly HN readers, you guys aren't as smart as me, let me explain why you should share my opinion."
  - justinlardinois 10y ago
    > As it is, your comment reads like "Silly HN readers, you guys aren't as smart as me, let me explain why you should share my opinion." So ~50% of the comments on this site?
  - Impossible 10y ago
    I have 4153 karma and have been an active Hackernews member for over 5 years, so I feel like I have a decent amount of insight into general patterns I see in the community. I'm aware that HN is super diverse and people have different backgrounds and viewpoints, which is one reason why I like HN over other technical communities. That said if I was to treat HN comments as a hivemind and generalize I'd say overall HN leans negative on the game industry. There is a lot of truth in these views but people tend to generalize towards "all game programmers are underpaid and over worked and should work on business CRUD apps" and not look at individual cases of motivations, success or failure. This is both stereotyping and anecdotal but I see it in game industry related threads time and time again. I wasn't trying to sound smarter than the community, I'm sorry if I came off that way.
- Tloewald 10y ago
  When the article says something like "at first their families were concerned" I initially thought they meant their wife and kids, but no, it's their _parents_ -- which gives you a clue as to where these guys are coming from.
  - lj3 10y ago
    That's because they're game developers. Game developers are young. They haven't burnt out yet. :) Seriously though, there are lots of people who decided to take their act on the road in a similar fashion as these kids. One of whom is a 40 something composer[0]. He doesn't have kids, but if you search around you'll find families on liveaboards and in larger RVs. [0]: tosimplify.net

Impossible 10y ago

Although HN loves to hate game development, and I understand where you're coming from, at least in Rami's case he's in the top 0.1% of indie game developers and has multiple $1M+ grossing games on the market (http://steamspy.com/dev/Vlambeer http://steamspy.com/dev/Vlambeer). He is in every way the exception, but I think its ok for him to live and exceptional lifestyle if he wants to without fear of burn out or "no one liking his game". The HN view of game development tends to apply more to salaried AAA developers in mid or bottom tier studios, and new, inexperienced or unsuccessful indie game developers, which might be the majority, but are certainly not Rami.

stevenwiles 10y ago
> but I think its ok for him to live and exceptional lifestyle if he wants to without fear of burn out or "no one liking his game". So you are ok with him living his life how he chooses? Why do you think that is something that needed to be said? That should be everyone's default disposition, so I'm not sure if you're expecting a cookie for this or what? Also, I don't think you have a strong enough grasp of this community to begin making assertions about its opinions towards certain professionals. As it is, your comment reads like "Silly HN readers, you guys aren't as smart as me, let me explain why you should share my opinion."
- justinlardinois 10y ago
  > As it is, your comment reads like "Silly HN readers, you guys aren't as smart as me, let me explain why you should share my opinion." So ~50% of the comments on this site?
- Impossible 10y ago
  I have 4153 karma and have been an active Hackernews member for over 5 years, so I feel like I have a decent amount of insight into general patterns I see in the community. I'm aware that HN is super diverse and people have different backgrounds and viewpoints, which is one reason why I like HN over other technical communities. That said if I was to treat HN comments as a hivemind and generalize I'd say overall HN leans negative on the game industry. There is a lot of truth in these views but people tend to generalize towards "all game programmers are underpaid and over worked and should work on business CRUD apps" and not look at individual cases of motivations, success or failure. This is both stereotyping and anecdotal but I see it in game industry related threads time and time again. I wasn't trying to sound smarter than the community, I'm sorry if I came off that way.
Tloewald 10y ago
When the article says something like "at first their families were concerned" I initially thought they meant their wife and kids, but no, it's their _parents_ -- which gives you a clue as to where these guys are coming from.
- lj3 10y ago
  That's because they're game developers. Game developers are young. They haven't burnt out yet. :) Seriously though, there are lots of people who decided to take their act on the road in a similar fashion as these kids. One of whom is a 40 something composer[0]. He doesn't have kids, but if you search around you'll find families on liveaboards and in larger RVs. [0]: tosimplify.net