3 ms·
>Long before that is the case, there'd be no incentive for the manufacturer to sell the car at all; they'd make more money just pushing the button themselves th
by Clubber 10y ago
>Long before that is the case, there'd be no incentive for the manufacturer to sell the car at all; they'd make more money just pushing the button themselves the minute the car rolled off the assembly line.
If they sold a car, they get profit immediately. If they kept the car for their own fleet, it would take longer to earn the same profit and then add additional overhead of maintaining the fleet, the reservation system, refunds, additional litigation, etc. Also, if the market is super saturated, they can sell cars to companies unable to make a profit. The manufacturer still gets the sale even thought the car doesn't realize a profit through a fleet.
The smart move would be to sell cars and also keep a fleet. It really depends on how well they could manage the fleet being a car manufacturer. They are quite different businesses and you don't get much overlap, other than the vehicle at cost and perhaps maintenance parts.
The even smarter move would be to franchise the fleet so you push off the management and operating costs but increase your sales and take part of the profit for branding, advertising, etc. The fleet would of course cross brand the vehicles.
- stdbrouw 10y ago> If they sold a car, they get profit immediately. If they kept the car for their own fleet, it would take longer to earn the same profit Well, no, it would take longer but the profits would be higher, too, so it would still be the smart move to make.
- Clubber 10y agoMaybe, depends on what the overhead is and if you sell that car to yourself at cost or not. Fleets could be an ultra low margin business. You also have to take into account inflation. Also, when companies don't "stick to the knitting," they often don't as well as their core business because an SVP of Tesla marketing has different skills than an SVP of Hertz marketing. Certainly a higher risk than just selling a car and taking the profits immediately.
- rhino369 10y ago>If they sold a car, they get profit immediately. If they kept the car for their own fleet, it would take longer to earn the same profit and then add additional overhead of maintaining the fleet, the reservation system, refunds, additional litigation, etc. A car company can raise capital and manage fleets much better than individuals can.
- Clubber 10y agoA car rental company could do that even better than a car manufacturer.
- rhino369 10y agoI imagine if a car company really did invent an autonomous car that works almost 100% of the time, they'd do a joint venture with a car rental place. But the car company has a competitive advantage in that it could choose not to sell to anyone while they build out a fleet maintenance operation. But if multiple companies solve the problem at the same time, maybe Hertz has the advantage.
- paulddraper 10y agoSo car rental places would buy up the supply (and charge less in fares) until the prices work themselves out.
- fossuser 10y agoI don't know if you've seen Elon's last announcement, but that is basically exactly what Tesla is planning to do with the Model 3. Sell the car and let people loan it out to an autonomous fleet with the app. Tesla would also have its own fleet for cities without enough Tesla owners. This would allow people who could otherwise not afford a 35k electric car (before incentives) to buy one and is the reason he doesn't think it'll be necessary to build another cheaper version.
- jonknee 10y ago> If they sold a car, they get profit immediately. If they kept the car for their own fleet, it would take longer to earn the same profit and then add additional overhead of maintaining the fleet, the reservation system, refunds, additional litigation, etc. Also, if the market is super saturated, they can sell cars to companies unable to make a profit. The manufacturer still gets the sale even thought the car doesn't realize a profit through a fleet. Car companies already run their own financing companies so they are used to this model of technically buying their own product.