3 ms·
I would agree this is generally true. There isn't anything that is easier to do in "space" than it is on the planet. But I think that might not be as true for o
by ChuckMcM 10y ago
I would agree this is generally true. There isn't anything that is easier to do in "space" than it is on the planet. But I think that might not be as true for other planets.
You could, for example, put radioactive waste in an open pit on the moon. Nobody is going to "accidentally walk by it unprotected" as the radiation levels on the surface of the moon are "naturally" higher than anything we've got in our waste pile due to a lack of atmosphere between the Sun and the Moon.
Now the first thought would be "Gee Chuck, sending a Kg to the moon is pretty freakin' expensive." But if you pause and consider the money already spent on Yucca mountain and other projects, and the fact that it still isn't operational, and the on-site nuclear waste storage issue continues to make nuclear plants riskier rather than safer, then is is too freakin' expensive? Remember you don't have to "land it gently on the moon" you could literally drop it from orbit if the impact plume was pointed away from the earth.
Solves a real problem perhaps? Perhaps not. Hard to say definitively.
- chris_va 10y agoIf you can get it to he moon, may as well put it in the sun :). There is a slight problem with the x% chance the rocket will blow up at max-Q while still in the atmosphere. Plus, all nuclear waste ever generated would fit in 1 football stadium. The rest of the spending is just due to political infighting that looks good to voters.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoYes, there are risks. Just saying its a defensible "permanent" solution to disposing waste with a very long half life. As far as using the Sun as an alternate, it takes less delta-v to get to the moon than it does to get to the Sun. Further, the overall effect of adding nuclear waste to the Moon is completely predictable in its impact, but that is less true of adding it to the Sun.
- AlgorithmicTime 10y agoPretty sure the impact of adding nuclear waste to the sun is more or less zilch.
- kiliantics 10y agoI think this isn't a viable option because you would need 100% certainty that your flight will not fail. An explosion in the atmosphere with nuclear waste involved sounds pretty devastating. This is the same reason that nuclear power should be avoided right now. Even if the chance of disaster is tiny, the consequences are far too large.