3 ms·
It's not just going to be about straight miles driven, it's about the technology being focused on and what's possible with it. Both Tesla and comma.ai are focus
by ocdtrekkie 10y ago
It's not just going to be about straight miles driven, it's about the technology being focused on and what's possible with it. Both Tesla and comma.ai are focusing primarily on what the car can see and do with it's own sensors... Google's cars are only functional on roads excessively mapped far above the normal Google Maps level. Google's existing strategy for self-driving cars isn't practical at a national level because of that extensive mapping requirement, and it possibly never will be. (Google's cars may have driven x number of million miles, but it's all the same very small number of roads.) And while prices drop as technology develops, bear in mind that in addition to all of that, Google's sensor platform is the most expensive out there.
Additionally, I've read some really interesting articles about research other car manufacturers have done. For instance, Google has never tested in bad weather, but Ford has been working on self-driving cars that work in snow. And while Google just assumes the humans are meant to be 'along for the ride', Volkswagon did some really good UI work, in terms of figuring out how to make the car's actions predictable, and hence, less scary. (Essentially, the car indicated to the driver what it was about to do before it executed a maneuver.)
Google is really good at capitalizing on their self-driving car project for marketing purposes, but it's extremely unlikely it'll ever be a market leader.
- jfoster 10y agoTesla is either already mapping roads through the sensors on their cars, or is only one software update away from doing so. Their mapping data will be a lot fresher than Google's.
- obmelvin 10y agoTesla cars don't have enough sensors to capture great data. It will require a lot more than a software update for then to record data on par with googles quality
- jfoster 10y agoThey claim autopilot uses "cameras, radar, ultrasonic sensors and data." I think even just the cameras alone would be valuable. It seems a Tesla has a better idea of what's going on around it than a human would, so these sensors should be at least close to sufficient for training an autonomous driving agent.
- ocdtrekkie 10y agoThis is true but mostly irrelevant, because mapping data is the least valuable self-driving data. Google focuses on it because Google has it already. Google Maps is one of the things Google has that few else have, so it's obvious for them to build their technology on it... nobody else can copy them. But if you have the most cars collecting the freshest data, you still have to bear in mind, the car collecting that data, is currently relying on the old data. Which means your cars can't trust the map data. And the reality is, with how much things in the real world change, your map data will never be trustworthy. You can have it, but you can't rely on it. Which is a better self-driving car? The car that can look at a cloud-based 3D map of every object in the entire town, assuming it's current, and decide on a route? Or the car that can ping Google Maps, get told "turn left on Main, right on Washington" then entirely from it's live surroundings, decide how to drive?
- petra 10y ago>> Google's existing strategy for self-driving cars isn't practical at a national level because of that extensive mapping requirement, and it possibly never will be. >> Google's sensor platform is the most expensive out there. >> Google has never tested in bad weather What about a self-driving cars as a service ? they can be the first to start a very profitable service that is limited in area and in weather even thought the sensors are more expensive(and they can claim "we aren't cutting corners like everybody else!") And that could be a great place to be in, strategically.
- ocdtrekkie 10y agoSure, they could definitely do similarly to what Uber just announced, in a small scope area like the Bay Area suburbs. But that's not likely to be a high margin product, certainly not something Google would want to hang onto long term. It's far smarter to be selling software licenses or cloud access to millions of units built by other car manufacturers and operated by individuals or other companies at scale, that's where the money is. But you also have to realize that you'll also highlight the weaknesses of the technology. People may not be able to easily specify to the car where they'd like to disembark. What if people want to be taken just outside the service area? Uber is including a human with their self-driving project for now, which doesn't save them (or you) any money. Google learned from Glass that a small number of users and a lot of public attention and hype about a product can quickly eviscerate it. The technology was good, but people without hands-on experience misunderstood it, and a couple small incidents became national news. A small rollout can just as easily kill your project as kick it off.
- petra 10y agoEven if Google decides to sell access to other companies, at scale, they can still say: "our service only works in summer , in that list of expanding areas". And of course if they sell access on a per-trip-basis, it's almost as if they own the service themselves. >> What if people want to be taken just outside the service area? Google is currently trying to be the comparison search engine for people who want to order rides - via their Google Maps. If they sucsseed, they'll just fit you with the right service according the limitations of the self-driving car ,etc. And regarding Google Glass - IDK. Even Uber is marketed on a city-by-city basis,
- kllrnohj 10y ago> Google's cars are only functional on roads excessively mapped far above the normal Google Maps level. Since this is a core part of your argument, I'm gonna go ahead and [citation needed] I've not heard anything of the sort and I've seen Google's cars on all sorts of roads. Plenty of their talks have been about the cars detecting anomalous situations and reacting appropriately, as well.
- ocdtrekkie 10y agoThere's no reason to believe they've exceeded this limitation: http://www.slate.com/articles/technology/technology/2014/10/google_self_driving_car_it_may_never_actually_happen.html http://www.slate.com/articles/technology/technology/2014/10/...