5 ms·
Does embedded mean micro-controllers only? I've worked on i7 boxes with 16GB of RAM as "embedded systems". Various customers bought them as such. I guess we've
by rdtsc 10y ago
Does embedded mean micro-controllers only? I've worked on i7 boxes with 16GB of RAM as "embedded systems". Various customers bought them as such. I guess we've been fooling ourselves and our customers for 10+ years.
- fumplethumb 10y agoNot well defined, but to me embedded just means the device is not a PC or a server. Could be a microcontroller running bare-metal code or an RTOS with application code. Could be a device like you describe above which, in some cases, resemble a PC with custom I/O requirements.
- dom0 10y agoThere's a whole industry built around embedded Linux. Just FYI.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 10y agoI think there's a lot of room in the embedded system space beyond just a microcontroller, but I would not be comfortable calling something that beefy "embedded."
- AnimalMuppet 10y agoIt's not the size that makes it embedded. It's that it's something that isn't supposed to be a computer - it's supposed to be a nuclear power plant, or a railroad locomotive, or a microwave oven. Size has nothing to do with it.
- RobertDeNiro 10y agoDepends who you're talking to I guess. I wouldn't call that an embedded system, although it could technically be described as such.
- Matthias247 10y agoEmbedded systems mostly means that the OEM delivers a complete device (hardware and software) where the endcustomer doesn't install anything else. These systems can contain anything from 8bit microcontrollers to i7 processors. But of course, when many people talk about embedded systems (especially in the context of development) they mean the more constrained devices (microcontrollers without OS or with realtime OS, ...). That's because the others are more PC-like and therefore don't have these special requirements during (software) development.
- vonmoltke 10y ago> That's because the others are more PC-like and therefore don't have these special requirements during (software) development. Requirements are based on the task, not the hardware. I have written firm real-time software for multi-processor, multi-node Xeon and POWER7 systems.
- JoachimSchipper 10y agoJust out of interest - what were you doing?
- vonmoltke 10y agoAn airborne radar signal processor. We were using telecom-ruggedized IBM blades to run a large-scale (for an airplane) clustered signal processing application. The processing was divided spatially, but needed to be implemented as a grid because the workers had to move in lockstep through the stages of the pipeline.
- chocolatebunny 10y agoIs there any custom hardware, built in house, in it? like is it a custom motherboard or do you put in custom PCIe cards that you can't find anywhere else? If it's a standard Dell server with just some custom software and nothing else special about it, then I have a tough time comprehending why it would be called an embedded system. If it has like a PCIe card that you can't get anywhere else. that you can only interact with the embedded software you provide. Then maybe I can see it being called an embedded system.
- rdtsc 10y agoIt was about a 2U server size but with additional external packaging, cooling improvements. Some specific hardware cards in in it, wouldn't say "can't get anywhere else" but it was very specific for application domain. The difference I saw was that a customer was not supposed to interact with it as a general server. They didn't install stuff on it, interacted mainly via external devices and via a web-based config interface. It was also configured for a specific purpose and had tweaks to kernel scheduling algorithms to provide low latency data processing.
- kbumsik 10y agoYes you are right. So just saying "embedded system" is very misleading. He did not mention any of specific field. So I still think he does not know embedded system.