4 ms·
Backstory: outsourcing our election administration to corporations. With the business model switching from bulk rates to per voter (whether they voted or not).
by specialist 10y ago
Backstory: outsourcing our election administration to corporations. With the business model switching from bulk rates to per voter (whether they voted or not). That's the driver for all these disruptive changes.
With paper based precinct voting, perhaps 20% of the work is done outside. Mostly printing, ballots, pamphlets, poll books. But also buying some simple gear, like the optical (scanotronic style) scanners or punchcards (whatever is used).
Adding touchscreens to the mix outsourced more stuff.
With postal balloting, I'd estimate 50-60% is outsourced. For more printing. Signature matching. Ballot image scanners. A lot of bookkeeping software.
With internet voting, closer to 100% of the elections will be outsourced. What jurisdiction is sophisticated enough to build, run, maintain voting systems? None. So every jurisdiction will be like the state of Georgia, where all of election administration is conducted by a corporation.
--
Buddy of mine is trying to sell me on blockchain voting. Claims it'll protect privacy via some kinda tor like onion routing whatever.
I don't even care.
If we adopt some magical crypto voting system that actually work for our form of elections (unlikely), we'll completely forfeit the primary function of our governments, which is administrating elections.
Private voting and public counting will be gone.
- Mtinie 10y ago> Private voting and public counting will be gone. I may be missing your point or misunderstanding your comment, but what you describe there is a by-product of a successfully developed blockchain-based voting solution. Everyone's votes are verifiably recorded, but publicly anonymous. You can still conduct public counts and everyone with access to the blockchain's ledger (or a trusted method of viewing the ledger) can confirm that the only votes that count towards the contest are those actually recorded. The additional benefit is that at any point in time, you can revisit your own vote to confirm it is still contributing to the outcome as it should. I don't see how this in any way undermines or "forfeits the primary function of our government, which is administrating elections." This may be due to our differing opinions on what the role of government is. Generally my reasoning falls closer in line with Milton Friedman's (paraphrased) view: > Government has three primary functions. It should provide for military defense of the nation. It should enforce contracts between individuals. It should protect citizens from crimes against themselves or their property.[...][1] --- [1] http://www.goodreads.com/quotes/578626-government-has-three-primary-functions-it-should-provide-for-military http://www.goodreads.com/quotes/578626-government-has-three-...
- dev1n 10y agoHUMINT is much more resource intensive than SIGINT. Paper voting is much more secure for persons than e-voting / polling. Blockchains are more easily conducive to side-channel attacks at revealing who a person voted for than paper voting is.
- Mtinie 10y agoI don't disagree you. I'm not aware of a production-grade blockchain voting protocol that yet exists that is resilient against one or more of the currently known de-anonymization attacks. I'm not even sure it's possible to build one, given that humans are a portion of the workflow. On the other hand, I'd love to be proven wrong.
- maxerickson 10y agoAny good suggestions about how blockchain systems propose to securely and anonymously distribute voting power? In the paper system Michigan uses, ballots are not distributed anonymously, but the identifying information is torn off the ballot before it is counted and secured. (I think it's pointless to propose a voting system that depends on individuals securely managing a cryptographic wallet; it's pretty clear we don't yet live in a world where that's a good idea. But it'd be interesting to see how they propose to solve the above problem.) edit: logfromblammo answered my question below: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12382298 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12382298
- specialist 10y ago"You can still conduct public counts..." Do you have any examples of corporations submitting to FOIA (public record) requests? My point is that our elections are being privatized. Internet voting is just the excuse. "...my reasoning falls closer in line with Milton Friedman's..." Mine's closer to Abraham Lincoln's: of the people, by the people, for the people Elections are what give a democracy its legitimacy. The right to vote precedes all other rights. Like the Zeroth law of Robotics. It's unstated because it's assumed because we voted ourselves (nation) into existence.
- 10y ago
- Taek 10y agoBlockchain voting has yet to solve the biggest issue with voting: membership. How do we know that every vote came from a person who is supposed to be registered and that each person cast exactly one vote? Hard problem.