5 ms·
Growth of Unpaid Internships May Be Illegal, Officials Say
- kjhnbnfghj 17y agoNo problem, register the internships as training courses and charge the little idiots/candidates for working there
- fexl 17y agoIn our town someone made a business of that, starting a technical and vocational training school many years ago. They're doing quite well trading knowledge and experience for money.
- codexon 17y agoThis is an interesting turn of events. Just 2 weeks ago when this story popped up on HN recommending unpaid interns (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1202168 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1202168) I thought it may have been legal, but now we know where the lawmakers stand.
- kjhnbnfghj 17y agoWhen I was a student the first year of a UK law graduate's work in a practice (articles) was unpaid. This was necessary to keep the wrong sort of people out of the legal profession after they started letting anybody go to university in the 60s and 70s.
- _delirium 17y agoYeah, this allegedly happens in some areas in the U.S. too, especially business and law--- unpaid internships as a way to filter out the poor, who can't afford to work unpaid internships.
- garply 17y agoIt's not just business and law in the US. When I was a CS student in college (not very long ago), during the summer students had to make a choice to go do low-paying internships for brand-name companies like MS, Google, and Amazon or take real summer jobs that would pay better but not look as good on a resume. Poorer students with more debt would take the short-term better paying jobs while students whose parents were footing the bills would take the internships that would give them better future prospects.
- joshhart 17y agoWhat are you talking about? I interned at Microsoft for a summer 3 years ago and was compensated almost 20k... Low paying my ass.
- _delirium 17y agoYeah, in my experience it's always been the opposite: internships from companies like Google, Microsoft, and Intel are about the highest-paying summer jobs (~$30-50/hr) any college student is likely to find, versus "normal" summer jobs that pay more like ~$15/hr at best. When I decided to do a $5k-stipend research internship instead of working somewhere like that, it was turning down a good deal of money.
- Locke1689 17y agoMy upcoming Microsoft internship is more than $5k a month. My summer NSF REU last year was $3k total.
- kobs 17y agoMy experience has been completely different. I'm a CS student from a low income household, yet it was the brand-name (and well-known startup) internship opportunities that were not only incredibly educational and provided with me with invaluable experience, but also paid pretty darn well. I made more than half of our annual household income in a single summer. I know this is just a single anecdote, but I don't think my story is that unusual for people in the tech/engineering/finance industry.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- luminary 17y agoI was in the job market for the past few months and stumbled across postings where even certain well-known tech companies (startups can be considered as exceptions) were looking for unpaid interns. You could see smell their BS from a mile.
- vv 17y agoDoesn't "Growth of Unpaid Internships May Be Illegal" mean it's legal not to pay interns, but illegal for them to grow up?
- jackowayed 17y agoIf anything, I'd say it technically means "it was legal when they were rarer, but now that they're becoming more common, it's illegal" as it's the growth of unpaid internships, not of unpaid interns, that may be illegal. They were trying to fit the fact that unpaid internships may be illegal and the fact that they've been growing all into one title, and it didn't work so well. But splitting hairs a) is kind of annoying, and b) doesn't add anything to the conversation about the content of the piece.
- gojomo 17y agoAlways Read Charitably. (Especially, when author is facing formal constraints, as in a headline, tweet, article/op-ed with limited word budget, etc.)
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- Confusion 17y agoComments on (the literal meaning of) titles of articles are hardly ever a valuable contribution to the discussion about the subject of the article. We are all aware that journalists often make up less-than-ideal titles. Let's not reiterate that point ad nauseam.
- jrockway 17y agoNo, it doesn't mean that.
- grellas 17y agoFederal law for unpaid interns in for-profit organizations requires that six criteria be met: (1) the work or training should function as an extension of the intern's educational training; (2) it should be provided primarily for the benefit of the intern; (3) it does not replace the work performed by regular employees; (4) it does not provide the employer with any immediate benefit; (5) it does not entitle the intern to employment at the end of the internship; and (6) there is no expectation by employer or intern that compensation will be paid for the work or training. To have a bona fide intern, all six of the criteria need to be met. State law may also impose additional requirements, as for example in California where the training must be part of an official educational curriculum at an accredited school - California imposes other restrictions as well. All in all, the rules may be well-meaning but they effectively kill opportunities for students to get training in many situations where the employer would otherwise normally be glad to make the opportunities available. In practical terms, it means that an employer wanting to open opportunities to students needs to pay minimum wage at least. Of course, the idea of the regulations is to prevent employers from circumventing minimum wage rules by dressing up what is really a job as an "internship" and in this sense they serve a protective function. Mark Cuban once did a piece entitled "Want an Unpaid Internship So You Can Get Valuable Experience - Screw You" (http://blogmaverick.com/2009/09/05/want-an-unpaid-internship-so-you-can-get-valuable-experience-screw-you/ http://blogmaverick.com/2009/09/05/want-an-unpaid-internship...) in which he recounted his frustrations in dealing with the federal regulations, and this in turn elicited an interesting and lively thread here at HN (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=806563 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=806563).
- _delirium 17y agoIn tech at least, I've always found the "valuable experience" argument to be a bit of a scam. There are plenty of companies that will be happy to pay you a good stipend (not even anywhere near minimum wage) for an internship. If you want something less job-like, you can work informally with lots of smaller companies, visiting their office and doing odd jobs, essentially as an unpaid freelancer (e.g. find something crappy about their site and offer to fix it). But if they want someone coming in to the office 40 hrs/wk, with a boss and deliverables, they should be prepared to pay them in something more than vague promises of "valuable experience".
- ladyada 17y agoThere's a really good ('selfish') reason to properly put interns on payroll. A tech company that has an unpaid intern working on something 'useful' - like writing code - is in a terrible position. If the intern is ignorant, sure no problem. But what if that code makes it into a shipping product, or some other asset that's sold? And suddenly that person feels like they were screwed over because they were not paid? Or what if they get hurt at work, or are harassed and want to bring suit? Its already a risk with proper employees on payroll but at least you have insurances for that. Or perals - they file for unemployment and put your company down as their last employer with $0 pay. (Have any of you had to -really- deal with your local DoL? You'll -wish- it was the IRS!) This is a very bad position to be in. Isn't $10/hr worth it to avoid these problems?
- pw0ncakes 17y agoThe problem is that large, macroscopically psychopathic corporations (including universities) have complete control over access to most of the jobs out there, and so they can dangle "experience" (access) as a carrot that can be offered as a sole reward to the desperate masses.
- axiom 17y agoUgh. What possible good could it do to outlaw unpaid internships? Do people actually think the result will be companies deciding to pay interns rather than just not offering internships? Just put yourself in the position of a manager making the hiring decision - suddenly you get word that you may be sued for offering unpaid positions, is your reaction going to be "wow, we'd better pay them" or "ok, no more interns." Who does this kind of crap benefit, other than self-serving politicians masquerading as defenders of the public good? Something about laws explicitly framed to protect people from themselves (i.e. students from accepting unpaid positions) drive me insane.
- argv_empty 17y agorather than just not offering internships? And then, after a little while, it becomes impractical to insist on prior experience for entry-level positions.