3 ms·
This may be cynical but every time I read the Princeton Lab's press I am reminded of how different fusion science is from fusion engineering. In the former the
by ChuckMcM 10y ago
This may be cynical but every time I read the Princeton Lab's press I am reminded of how different fusion science is from fusion engineering. In the former the words are like "explore ways of doing x ..." or "Compare different forms of y ...". In the engineer press it is more like, "Once we achieve x which we expect to achieve by p, q, or worst case r, we will move on to y leaving us one step away from fully operational fusion plants."
As an engineer I much prefer the latter, something with a bit of urgency that "we need to develop this as quickly as possible because it unlocks a lot of solutions to problems which are threatening billions of people." Not "Ohh look at all the shiny ways we can turn three two small atoms into one slightly bigger atom!"
- jasonwatkinspdx 10y agoI wonder where that p, q, or r comes from...
- ChuckMcM 10y agoGenerally problem constraints, but your implicit point that without the science the engineering would not be possible is certainly valid. I would be the first person to tell you that I am way further on the D side of the R&D spectrum than the R side.
- sgt101 10y agoYup, Engineers use science, craftsmen use intuition. What does that say for software?
- CWuestefeld 10y agoI think as often as not, engineers hit on something that works, and later on the scientists come along to explain why it works, and figure out a framework of rules around the principle that allows it to be systematized.
- sgt101 10y agoI think that the "it works part" is science ( measure quantify qualify) this is what the software community does really badly.
- bsder 10y ago> Yup, Engineers use science, craftsmen use intuition. Sometimes. The early history of radio was one instance where the engineering ran ahead of the science.
- DennisP 10y agoRecently I watched a presentation[1] by the director of MIT's fusion program, talking about their ARC design. They want to minimize physics risk by using a standard tokamak, but take advantage of new commercially-available superconductors to make a net-positive 200MW reactor that's ten times smaller than ITER. He mostly talks about practical engineering issues: modular reactor construction, easy maintenance, testing current flow through joints in superconducting tapes, 3D printing a reactor chamber with complex cooling channels, immersion in FLiBe for ample cooling and breeding 14% more tritium than the reactor consumes, etc. The reactor would be about the size of JET, which was built in four years. MIT has pretty good experience for this, since their Alcator C-Mod has more powerful magnetic fields than any other tokamak in the world. Of course the startup companies pursuing fusion are also taking an engineering approach. Here's an interesting panel discussion[2] between the MIT guy and people from Tri Alpha, General Fusion, and Lockheed. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KkpqA8yG9T4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KkpqA8yG9T4 [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nWjAJKPLMEo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nWjAJKPLMEo
- deelowe 10y agoIs it just me or does MIT seem to tend towards the more practical end of things when it comes to R&D?