5 ms·
The trouble with explaining the double slit experiment with spread out waves is the electrons hit the screen at points leaving you to explain how that works. Vi
by tim333 10y ago
The trouble with explaining the double slit experiment with spread out waves is the electrons hit the screen at points leaving you to explain how that works. Video of it happening https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ToRdROokUhs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ToRdROokUhs
- maxerickson 10y agoEach probability field ends up interacting with a single point on the screen.
- platz 10y agoThis is just the copenhagen interpretation which says nothing about the physical ontology of the light before it ends up as a point on the screen. Unless you are saying the probability amplitudes are physical things-in-themselves rather than calculational models. (side note - Feynman did not think of a probability amplitude as a physical thing-in-itself)
- srtjstjsj 10y agoBut did Feynman think anything as a physical thing-in-itself? Feynman repeatedly argued that that physics is whatever the instruments measure, generalized by whatever computational models match the measurements, and he was happy to analogize to metaphorize whenever convenient to describe an aspect of a phenomenon ("photons jiggling")
- tim333 10y agoOne good thing about Feynman was he was always clear on what was experimentally observable and is what it is and what is theory where you can make up anything that fits the experiment.
- hasenj 10y agoIf I understand correctly, it interacts with an electron that's more or less locked into a small place around an atom. It doesn't just hit that one point; the blip represents the location of the atom that had the electron that absorbed the photon. Just my two cents
- ars 10y agoBecause charge is quantized, and not splittable. Once it interacts with something all of it gets "sucked in" to one spot, and the entire electron interacts. The exact place it does that is randomized with varying probability at different spots. But once a place is "picked" all of the charge goes there. It's the quantization that is fundamental, and it's the quantization that makes fields look like particles, not the other way around.
- hasenj 10y agoIf I understand correctly, there's currently no explanation of how one electron gets picked out of all the gazillions of electrons available; am I correct? Would that just be considered a fundamental randomness in nature?
- ars 10y agoI don't understand your question, can you rephrase? In the experiment here they fire one electron at a time, so you don't have to pick one electron. Rather the final location of that electron is what's random.
- srtjstjsj 10y agoThat's the question: how is the location picked? You roll a fair die, 1-6. It lands on 4 this time. Why 4, and not 5? How was the 4 chosen? In classical mechanics, it's a horrendously complicated but fundamentally simple computation. In QM, no one knows.
- ThePhysicist 10y ago"Classical" states (a single dot on the screen instead of an interference pattern) are created through the measurement process, which involves entanglement and dephasing: The small quantum system (the electron) first becomes entangled with the macroscopic system (the photo film and everything coupled to it), then the phase coherence between the individual eigenvectors of the electron gets lost due to the coupling with a large number of degrees of freedom in the measurement system.
- fallingfrog 10y agoExactly! But how do you explain that to the public in a way that doesn't sound like a bunch of hocus pocus?
- ThePhysicist 10y agoI know, it's difficult. I wanted to write an article about this for a while, guess I have to get up and just do it.
- atemerev 10y agoCalling an electron "a particle" presumes that it is always localized somewhere, and has a defined travel path. But it doesn't; when measurement happens, it is localized at some specific point, but that's all. Something that can be localized only at interaction points, and not elsewhere, is not a "particle", it's something else. Perhaps "field excitation", like a hot spot in a microwave.
- goldenkey 10y agoBut thats the catch 22. Macroscopic objects are only classical because they have their hand in the river of interaction non stop. Only the smallest butterfly can manage to remain coherent and uncollapsed.