3 ms·
>> Gustav Rau pulled a pistol from his hip and pointed it directly at the SS officer.“You have no authority here,” he said. “This horse farm is under the jurisd
by sandworm101 10y ago
>> Gustav Rau pulled a pistol from his hip and pointed it directly at the SS officer.“You have no authority here,” he said. “This horse farm is under the jurisdiction of the German Army. [...] Neither man moved until, with a curt nod, the officer stepped back. He agreed to remove his men."
I like this story. It emphasizes the error in the title. These seem to have been German horses, not Nazi horses. I see so many articles and books reference everyone and everything in the German armed forces of the time as "Nazi". The reality was complicated. There was much conflict as many in the armed forces felt they should remain politically neutral. This idea is not uncommon today. Many members of various armies go so far as to not vote while in active service. Others, notably in the US forces, see political detachment unpatriotic. This boils down to an officer within an older, politically detached force pulling a gun on an officer of a new and fanatically active force. There must have been many such stand-offs.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nazism_and_the_Wehrmacht https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nazism_and_the_Wehrmacht
- pvg 10y agoThe reality was complicated. There was much conflict as many in the armed forces felt they should remain politically neutral. This idea is not uncommon today. Most armies today are not involved in genocide so the parallel is not a very good one. The reality was complicated but the Wehrmacht was very much an essential and willing instrument of Nazism. A precedent in Nazi horse-detection - in the mid 80s, it was reported that former UN Secretary General and then- Austrian presidential candidate Kurt Waldheim had been a member of an SA mounted unit. In response to Waldheim's denials, Chancellor Fred Sinowatz quipped that Waldheim 'hadn't been in the SA, only his horse had'.
- Animats 10y agoIt's more like some guy managed to get the German army to fund his pet project. A huge herd of white Lipizzaners would have been militarily Cool, but Ineffective. That's a parade unit, not a fighting force. After the war, the Lipizzaners, both this group and the ones at the Spanish Riding School in Vienna, were rescued by US forces under Patton, who was a cavalryman before his tanker days. A good horse is never the wrong color.
- microtherion 10y agoI'm reminded of another horse breeding scheme that got Nazi funding: Hermann Fegelein's SS-Hauptreitschule München: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hermann_Fegelein https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hermann_Fegelein
- kirrent 10y agoVery much off on this tangent. One of my favourite pieces of trivia in movies concerns the 1969 film Battle of Britain where Kesselring, a German field marshall, almost ironically gives Goring a Nazi salute following their defeat. This detail lead to strong disagreement. From wikipedia: "During filming, Galland, who was acting as a German technical advisor, took exception to a scene where Kesselring is shown giving the Nazi salute, rather than the standard military salute. Journalist Leonard Mosley witnessed Galland spoiling the shooting and having to be escorted off the set. Galland subsequently threatened to withdraw from the production, warning "dire consequences for the film if the scene stayed in."
- enkid 10y agoYou're coming dangerously close to arguing for the clean Wehrmact myth. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clean_Wehrmacht https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clean_Wehrmacht
- sandworm101 10y agoOnly a nut would think that they were clean. That's an answered question. I'm more interested in the internal debates, the clash of culture, within and between the various forces as exemplified by the story above. I'm interested because we see similar divides within western forces in recent years. They aren't pulling guns on each other but there is an old guard with one set of values and a more political generation (post-9/11) with a very different cultural outlook. The fact that a gun was pulled also points to a total breakdown of the standards of decorum armed forces reply upon to prevent internal arguments turning violent. This wasn't mutiny, but only because there was no clear mode to determine seniority between these two men.
- pjc50 10y ago> I'm interested because we see similar divides within western forces in recent years. They aren't pulling guns on each other but there is an old guard with one set of values and a more political generation (post-9/11) with a very different cultural outlook. Could you elaborate on this please? Which direction do you think the modern generation are taking?
- sandworm101 10y agoTake the CIA drone program. During the early days they resisted armed drones. The old guard said they didn't do assassinations, didn't arm spy aircraft else their missions become acts of war (see Gary Powers). A decade later, armed drones are the backbone of the program. Targeted killings are a norm. Or, take the torture program. Despite him being a complete hawk, Senator McCain was against mistreating prisoners. He was a POW himself. But he lost his race for president. The new nominee is pro-torture. The old warriors of the cold war are retiring out and the new batch is moving into senior leadership. The new batch are much less restrained. They don't believe in principals based on reciprocity as they have been brought up fighting asymmetrical enemies. Every fight is now an existential battle to be fought without restraint or compromise, an attitude adopted from politics imho.