35 ms·
>> If Pluto is #9, what numbers are Ceres, Sedna, Eris, Haumea, and Makemake? I don't care about them. This is a cultural issue. There is no fundamental prin
by sandworm101 10y ago
>> If Pluto is #9, what numbers are Ceres, Sedna, Eris, Haumea, and Makemake?
I don't care about them. This is a cultural issue. There is no fundamental principal governing how humans are to name space rocks. This is map making. Exceptions and one-off special rules are made all the time. We accept europe and asia as separate continents. If that can be a thing, then Pluto can remain a planet.
- dalke 10y agoThen it's a good thing I was asking Cozumel, who does care and believes it to be significant, instead of someone who doesn't care.
- sandworm101 10y agoYou put them up to illustrate the consequences of a change to the planet-naming rule. I dismiss those consequences as irrelevant to the issue given how our culture is already so accepting of similar situation ... just in simpler words.
- dalke 10y agoI was certainly not trying to do as you proposed. I put them up there to illustrate that the views stated by Cozumel were contradictory, and to give Cozumel a chance to re-think the validity of the proposed tin foil scenario. If Cozumel believes Pluto is really #9, then why does Cozumel not think that Ceres is a planet, making Pluto #10, which is the foretold doomsday planet X = Nibiru? Or if Cozumel prefers the fringe views of Sitchin's twelfth planet, then why don't Makemake and the other dwarf planets count while Pluto, according to Cozumel, does?
- nkrisc 10y agoOr not remain a planet because it's all arbitrary anyway. The classification is not meant to align to some sort of cosmic ordering, but to classify things in ways that are currently useful to science.