3 ms·
Could everyone just please install Signal and Wire, for open-source, end-to-end encrypted communication?
by FabHK 10y ago
Could everyone just please install Signal and Wire, for open-source, end-to-end encrypted communication?
- Freak_NL 10y agoDoes Signal still require your mobile number as mandatory identifier? If privacy is what matters that is a deal breaker. Last I looked it couldn't be used with third party clients either, and any desktop client requires tethering to an Android or IOS smartphone. Wire looks a bit more sensible, but still works exclusively on their servers.
- edent 10y agoYes and Yes. Signal also doesn't support encrypted backup, so if you change devices you have to export to plaintext.
- themartorana 10y agoI want to. But it took enough time to get the entire family using WhatsApp. We have so much history in those groups and conversations. I'd very much like to be able to change over (and when ads start creeping in, probably will just bite the bullet) but I really hoped it wouldn't come to this. Oh well. Edit: we started using WhatsApp many years ago before the FB purchase, when not only did iMessage suck for groups - oh wait, it still does - and text messaging was expensive, but we needed something stable and cross-platform. WhatsApp delivered on all of that, where iMessage was decidedly iOS only, BBM kept reaching its hand out of the grave but not for long, and Google offerings were impossible for 75 year old relatives to understand. I still like WhatsApp, and the server tech is tops. Too bad it's going this way.
- cJ0th 10y agoGot a wire account a few days ago. While my experience on linux was alright a friend of mine went through a lot of trouble. After the activation he couldn't log in using the browser. It said "no connection" even though that wasn't true. He then installed the Windows desktop app which forced him to upload a photo, which he actually didn't wanted to. Apparently there was a button to skip this step but it didn't work. After some time we were finally chatting for a while. While we both enjoyed the fact that it is secure, open-source and has some great features (like the yt video integration) he found the desktop client "confusing" (don't really know what exactly he meant by that tbh). At this point we were unsure whether or not we wanted to continue using wire in the future. But then his desktop application crashed and he couldn't start it anymore. He tried the web app again but it still wouldn't work. Long story short: Chances are we are not going to use wire again in the future. And this is really unfortunate as I'd prefer to use it! The problem is: convincing people to try it is hard enough. If then their first experience isn't super smooth they a.) won't use it and b.) are probably less open to try a different messenger in the future. And now what? We can't resort to Signal as I still prefer using a dumb phone. And then there is Telegram but I don't trust their security measures. What's more, I really don't see the necessity to tell a messenger my phone number.