2 ms·
I think it's a good article, but misses on one of its claims. > Another powerful driver for the uptake of electric vehicles is that they are a vastly superior
by loeg 10y ago
I think it's a good article, but misses on one of its claims.
> Another powerful driver for the uptake of electric vehicles is that they are a vastly superior platform for autonomous driving, infotainment, connected vehicle and transport-as-a-service technologies, ... And it simply makes no sense to have an inherently analogue power unit – vibrating, volatile-liquid-consuming, hot-polluting-exhaust-producing – at the heart of a fully digital, sensor-pervaded, solid-state-electronics-controlled system.
I don't think there's anything true about this statement, basically. There's no reason not to put automated driving, connected vehicle, and transport-as-a-service technologies in petrol cars (as long as it's still economical to make and sell petrol cars).
- derefr 10y agoPerhaps the point the article is aiming for there is: we've started down a path toward cars becoming almost "System-on-a-Chip" designs, like mobile and IoT devices currently are. But the analogue components of a car—places where the motor is connected to analogue sensors, or analogue actuators, using analogue (e.g. hydraulic, or rotating-shaft) signalling paths—resist this vertical integration. You're right that there's no reason to not put these technologies into petrol cars. But there will be two opposing forces from that point forward: the computerized side of the car trying to expand its digital signal-path tentacles through the whole architecture, and the traditional petrol motor and its associated parts resisting change-for-the-sake-of-change in favor of well-known (analogue) engineering solutions. In the end, I suspect the force of computerization will "win", and what we'll end up with is every car essentially being an electric car architecturally, just with some cars containing a petrol-fed electric generator under the hood. Such an architecture likely won't be as fuel-efficient as current hybrid designs are! But it will win anyway: due to the vertical integration possible in electronic systems, it'll likely be much, much cheaper to produce, and more reliable. The "core" of your car—everything that's not sensors or motors—will be a $50 daughterboard, not even worth diagnosing when there's a problem, just popped out and replaced. Just like phones are today.
- loeg 10y agoI don't think we're remotely close to cars being SoCs, or that there's anything about analogue components that magically resists monitoring with sensors.
- derefr 10y agoWe're not close, but like I said, we're headed that way. Maybe in another 20 years, say. The analogue components of a car can, and indeed already do, have out-of-band digital monitoring. That secondary digital supervision feeds both your dashboard, and the pin-outs repair shops connect to. It even feeds things like fuel-efficiency microcontrollers that, in their roundabout way, send commands back to the motor. But the architecture of even current electric cars goes far beyond this: electric cars don't monitor the analogue components with digital sensors, they simply have ADCs connected right to the sensors, and take the now-digital signal from the sensor and feed it to the car's CPU, where that signal—that data, now—can produce many separate outputs. Surprisingly (given the last 30 years of robotics), the key advantage of electric cars over petrol ones is that the petrol architecture is inherently subsumptive—digital "cognitive" actions overriding lower-level, directly-connected analogue "reflex" actions—while the electric architecture can centralize data-flow. You don't have to worry about the driver attempting to move the car with the parking brake enabled; the information of "gas pedal depressed" goes through the "brain" of the device, where it also knows that the "parking brake engaged" line is high, so its desired-torque output should just stay at zero.
- majormajor 10y ago> You don't have to worry about the driver attempting to move the car with the parking brake enabled; the information of "gas pedal depressed" goes through the "brain" of the device, where it also knows that the "parking brake engaged" line is high, so its desired-torque output should just stay at zero. You can do all of this centralization in an ICE car. Electronic throttles and switches aren't new. (Though the design I've seen for this case is "oh, driver pushed the pedal, let's disengage the parking brake since they probably just forgot about it.")
- 10y ago
- Grishnakh 10y agoThere's nothing true about that statement at all, in fact it's profoundly stupid, and really seems to be trying to invent a clever way of convincing people that gasoline-fueled engines are "obsolete" but using a completely nonsensical argument to do so. Your car's infotainment system does NOT care how your car is propelled. And the vibration argument is idiotic. The NVH caused by a modern car's engine is nothing compared to the NVH caused by rolling down a poorly-maintained asphalt street on rubber tires, especially with modern tires which use relatively high pressures to improve efficiency (both in gas cars and EVs). Is this moron going to next try to claim that we need "digital suspensions" too? What about the analog power units in EVs? (Sorry, but motor controllers are inherently analog too. Motors don't work with 1s and 0s.)
- Animats 10y agoYes. "Connected car" is completely independent of the power train. So is automatic driving. As Chris Urmson of Google points out, their self-driving cars have no car-to-car communications. They don't need it, and don't want it. Self-driving cars as transport-as-a-service have many of the problems of Personal Rapid Transit. We have yet to see the first system deployed, despite lots of hype. At least four vendors (Mercedes, Local Motors, Yandex, and a university in France) have shown prototypes of small self-driving buses, but none of them are routinely carrying passengers without a driver. The vehicle technology isn't the problem. It's the riders. Dealing with disabled riders, vandalism, jerks, and people not paying remains a problem.