5 ms·
This article is alarmist and seems to be very poor analysis on the part of Bloomberg. I don't see car repair shops going away. The only group that may die is J
by dragontamer 10y ago
This article is alarmist and seems to be very poor analysis on the part of Bloomberg.
I don't see car repair shops going away. The only group that may die is Jiffy Lube and good riddance to them. Last time I checked... electric cars need their tires rotated (and all tire maintenance associated with that: Tire Repair, Tire balancing, etc. etc.).
Brakes still need to be replaced: which means the brake fluid industry needs to remain, along with brakes and rotors need to be continuously produced.
Electric cars still need coolant flush every few years. Both for coolant reasons and anti-corrosion reasons. Windshield wipers will crack. Windshields will continue to be replaced. Bodywork needs to repair damage from accidents.
So hell, even the lowest tier, crap repair shop (Jiffy Lube) will still be around 30 years from now. Jiffy Lube's current work is:
https://www.jiffylube.com/ https://www.jiffylube.com/
* Oil Changes -- the only thing that Electric Cars don't need
* Brakes
* Fluids (coolant / brake fluid. I guess transmission fluid might go away)
* Tires
- taf2 10y agoI've driven my model s for 2 1/2 years and not yet had any need for service. Single peddle driving almost completely eliminates the need for brakes. I probably am due to rotate my tires. The AC works great and I don't think I've refilled the windshield wiper fluid yet. Related to the brakes I almost never notice dirty rims on a Tesla do you? If model s is any indicator to the future of EV car reliability than basically that leaves jiffylube maybe handling: * tires * fluids There would be huge drop in need for brake maintenance. I have no idea where their profit center sits, but I can't imagine it's only in tires and fluids?
- joosters 10y agoElectric vehicles require less windscreen wiper fluid? Technology truly is great :)
- dragontamer 10y ago> I've driven my model s for 2 1/2 years and not yet had any need for service. My car (2014 Ford Focus) is 2 and 1/2 years old. Here are the list of things I've done to my car: * Three oil changes and tire rotations. The tires should be rotated every 7500 miles or so, regardless of the vehicle. * New Windshield Wipers -- Rubber degrades when exposed to the sun over long periods of time. I had to replace my windshield wipers recently. * Air Conditioning Filter -- Pollen gets in there. Replaced at 20,000 miles (a few months ago). * Windshield Wiper fluid -- I top it off every month or so. * Three punctured tires -- Why are there so many screws on the road? Uggghhhhh. I check tire-pressure weekly and top it off at a gas-station to 35 PSI. The only thing the Tesla gets rid of, compared to my car, are the three oil changes, which happen whenever I rotate my tires anyway. (I do oil changes / tire rotations myself. Very easy job) The cost of full-synthetic oil + filter is $35, spent every 7500 miles for the oil change. Its basically negligible. My previous car was a Nissan Maxima with 150,000+ miles on it. My family changed its brakes twice in its lifetime (hand-me-down from my father as I left for college). I think people are severely overestimating the amount of times brakes need to be changed.
- loeg 10y agoTangential, but how do you stand to check tire pressure so frequently? Just taking the dust caps off is enough of a burden I don't do it frequently.
- dragontamer 10y agoTire Pressure takes no more than 1-minute to check. What do you do when you're waiting for your gas to fill up? Might as well be productive, right? Plus, air-pump stations are all over gas stations. If you're getting your gas filled up, might as well check tire pressure while you're at it. Leave a pressure gauge in your car.
- fudged71 10y ago>What do you do when you're waiting for your gas to fill up? Many gas stations around me don't allow you to walk away from the pump, they have removed the locking latch on the handle that lets you do that. If there ever is a latch, I use that time to wash the windows.
- loeg 10y agoIf anything, I usually clean the windshield. But that's a good idea, thanks.
- majormajor 10y agoNewer cars have sensors that do it for you. Either the cheap-style "show a light if pressure is too low" ones or the nicer "real time readout of tire pressure available on an info screen somewhere."
- thearn4 10y agoI do wish the TPMS tied into the OBD so that I could actually measure it electronically. It doesn't on Hondas, maybe it does on other makes?
- thearn4 10y ago
- dragontamer 10y ago> If model s is any indicator to the future of EV car reliability than basically that leaves jiffylube maybe handling: If The Model S is any indicator of the future of EV car reliability, then things are awful. http://www.latimes.com/business/autos/la-fi-hy-consumer-reports-tesla-models-20151020-story.html http://www.latimes.com/business/autos/la-fi-hy-consumer-repo... Edmund's had to replace their drive unit 3 times (FOUR drive units in two years!!). Tesla clearly has a lot of kinks they need to work out still.
- skybrian 10y agoMostly agreed except for body shops. I expect we will see fewer accidents due to computer-aided driving. Lots of room for improvement. Also, if people decide not to own their own cars, fleet maintenance is a different kind of market.
- joosters 10y agoPlus there are new areas of maintenance: sensors, cameras, batteries and so on. I'm not sure why the article is so confident about battery life. It's not just about total lifetime mileage. As the battery degrades, the capacity drops and so its range decreases, making the car progressively less useful. It's not like the car gets to the claimed 70000 miles and then drops dead.
- vvanders 10y agoSource for battery maintence? Tesla has been out many years now and their battery degradation has been beating expectations so far. The 100k mi taxi that was posted a few weeks ago was only showing ~2% loss and I think he had the car for quite a few years. I think it's been shown that with proper thermal management battery degradation is not a major factor.
- myself248 10y agoIronically enough, the 12v battery seems to work much harder in Teslas, since the electronic systems don't enter deep sleep as aggressively as they do in other cars. https://teslamotorsclub.com/tmc/threads/near-annual-replacement-of-12v-battery-is-typical-according-to-tesla-service-tech.41006/ https://teslamotorsclub.com/tmc/threads/near-annual-replacem... The lithium batteries last a very long time, at least.
- CydeWeys 10y agoThe 70,000 miles figure itself is already wildly pessimistic. Electric vehicles have already been on the roads for enough time for some of them to get well past 70K miles driven, and the potential worries over battery packs degrading simply hasn't come to fruition.
- ebbv 10y agoYour analysis seems reasonable until you actually own an EV and see how little maintenance is required. I've had my LEAF for over two years and all I've needed is tire rotation and tire replacement (due to pothole.) The brakes last way, way longer due to the motor picking up so much of the braking. The oil change places will die out as EVs pick up unless they are smart enough to install L3 charging stations and charge a small fee for their use.
- gwbas1c 10y agoMy Leaf just needs tire rotations. The garage that does my annual safety inspection sticker happily rotates the tires for me. (I fill the washer fluid myself.) That's one trip a year. In contrast, my Subaru requires about 2 oil changes a year, and the garage that does the oil changes doesn't do safety inspections. Thus, my Subaru requires three trips a year. Huge difference. Hopefully my Subaru is the last gas car I need to buy.
- dragontamer 10y ago> The garage that does my annual safety inspection sticker happily rotates the tires for me. Huh, we don't got that in my State. Tire Rotations are typically bundled with the oil change. As far as I'm concerned (in the area that I live in), getting rid of oil changes doesn't do anything really. Still gotta go in for the tire rotation. I mean, I do it myself manually. Because rotating tires is braindead easy to do, and oil changes aren't much harder. Frankly, tires are heavy and are the "harder" part of the job IMO.
- Grishnakh 10y agoYou're overblowing things. Gas cars don't even flush their coolant that often; maybe every 5 years. Brakes on EVs aren't used very much; they can probably last the life of the car. Most people never change their brake fluid; again, that's maybe a 5-10 year thing (it might get done when the car changes owners). Tires are the biggest thing. Jiffy Lube has a lot of competition here, from places like Discount Tire and many other such places. I didn't even know Jiffy Lube did tires, and there's no way I'd go there for that (or anything else for that matter). Yes, windshields will still need replacement, and bodywork will still be needed for crashes. Windshield wipers? If you can't put on your own windshield wipers from Autozone, you need to be committed; everyone does that themselves, or gets a spouse/neighbor/friend to do it for them in 20 seconds. (It'd be better if they still sold the rubber refills instead of making us replace the whole assembly for $20.) But most cars probably never see a bodyshop, and windshields are normally replaced by mobile technicians. Body shops will be needed less too due to automated driving, driver safety aids, etc. Modern cars are already ridiculously reliable, but after 10 or so years they start having some problems because of the gas engine mostly, especially if it hasn't been maintained that well. They're even extending oil-change intervals in them to 10-15k miles (many cars now have sensors and displays that tell you when to change it). EVs will need a little less maintenance (because of the oil), but the biggest difference will be the relative lack of need for major repairs when the car is older.
- mrfusion 10y agoWhat's the coolant for in electric cars?
- dragontamer 10y agoCoolant is for battery cooling and anti corrosion. The anticorrosion chemicals wear out every five years, so you need to replace them.
- maherbeg 10y agoI agree with a lot of the other posters that have replied. A lot of these things are going to go away. A lot of stuff that needs replacing, like windshield wipers and filters will become more commonly replaced at home. I imagine filters will become an easier replacement due to the layout of electric cars.
- woodandsteel 10y agoBut the real big costs, like hundreds or thousands of dollars,are when something in the engine or transmission breaks. Have you ever had to replace a starter motor or alternator? And there EV has ICE totally beaten. Plus brakes last much longer due to regenerative breaking.