4 ms·
> A surveillance society could eliminate almost all crime, or at least serious crimes. Even just reducing them significantly would have enormous economic and so
by paganel 10y ago
> A surveillance society could eliminate almost all crime, or at least serious crimes. Even just reducing them significantly would have enormous economic and social impact.
I wanted to be on your side, I really did, until I came to this paragraph.
From my point of view "crime" is an intrinsic part of our species, doing bad things is one of the things that make us humans. I'm not condoning rapes nor murders, it's just that, if you look at the history of our species, you'd realize that we are where we are (we've sent people to the Moon and discovered planets from galaxies far, far away) also because we did "bad" stuff.
Take the Bible, a book that has had a profound effect on the "Western" civilization. The story of Cain and Abel is one of the most important from the Old Testament. The New Testament is also a "Chronicle of a Crime Foretold", to paraphrase Garcia Marquez.
Or Homer's The Iliad, the book that defined the Greek-Roman antiquity. It's full of murders and rapes and bad things.
Long story short, we wouldn't have had the "enormous economic and social impact" that we have today as a species if, let's say, an omnipotent God/Spaghetti Flying Monster would have just watched us from the very beginning and would have prevented us from doing any crimes.
- XorNot 10y agoI hardly see the relevance of crime fiction as an argument against an efficient justice and crime prevention system, which is the argument you seem to be making. I'm also fairly sure actual rape and murder are not pre-requisites to writing crime fiction...otherwise the Law & Order series apparently has a much higher production cost then I imagined.
- ceejayoz 10y agoSeems a bit of a stretch from "crime happened in the past and people wrote about it in fiction" to "crime is fundamentally necessary for our societal development"...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- paganel 10y agoFiction represented what people saw around them and considered them as some sort of values. Someone above mentioned "Law&Order" as some sort of dismissal, but that's exactly the point, in a "know it all surveillance society" the societal aspects that made the producers think: "hey, let's make a show about the good guys catching the bad guys, let's call it 'Law&Order'" would not be present. Fiction is always backed up by facts from the real life. I should know, i grew up in a wannabe "know it all surveillance society" (on the Eastern side of the wall), where we did not have TV shows like 'Law&Order' because, technically, the "socialist society" we were part of didn't have any bad guys. There were of course criminals, and rapist, and bad people, but they were just a glitch hidden under the rug. It was sort of supposed that in the brighter future awaiting us all those "bad elements" would have been gone for good. The former socialist government of my country was against the bad guys because in the end we were all supposed "to all be equal", some commenters on HN are against the bad guys because it brings down real estate prices, maybe some other people are against the bad guys because in a book of fiction 2000-years old someone wrote it down that: "You should not steal", the fact remains that no-one, ever, would be able to hide the "bad guys" under the rug, for ever. It's against our very nature as a species.