4 ms·
It's gotten to the point where the authoritarian feel of US immigrations is actively deterring me from wanting to visit. I wonder if anyone has done any resear
by vidarh 10y ago
It's gotten to the point where the authoritarian feel of US immigrations is actively deterring me from wanting to visit.
I wonder if anyone has done any research on whether/how much this is measurably affecting the US economy.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- gnu8 10y agoIt has zero measurable impact because anyone who counts will make sure their social media profile is either sterile or doesn't exist. Only an idiot would be a member of ISIS or Al Queda on Facebook.
- icebraining 10y agoI wonder if not filling in anything won't be counted against the person, with the justification that they have less info to make an evaluation.
- briandear 10y agoNot really. Basically a social profile can help clear a person but a lack of one wouldn't condemn a person. There's precedent in the Single Scope Background check process for Top Secret clearances: a lack of data just means more weight will be given to other factors. You aren't punished for a lack of data. This is common when people might not yet have a credit history. However, this policy is entirely dumb because social media profiles will be created specifically for travelers to be 'clean.'
- tribby 10y agoI agree this is a likely practical outcome, but the datapoint itself is troubling; I can just as easily imagine a binary interpretation of social/antisocial.
- type0 10y ago> because social media profiles will be created specifically for travelers to be 'clean.' I imagine that in future we will hear about travelers being denied entry because they- "fraudulently stated wrong social media accounts"... or something like that.
- vidarh 10y agoIt likely has zero measurable impact on stopping terrorism. It will have measurable impact on the millions of people who have to give up privacy to enter the US, some proportion of which is likely to be further negatively affected by having something "suspicious" in their profile. Like being idiots who once liked something offensive as a joke, or being friends with some idiot who is connected to ISIS on some social network.
- izacus 10y agoHaving to be careful what kind of jokes you like or articles you link reminds me exactly on how people behaved back in pre-1990 socialist era where liking or retelling a wrong joke got you in trouble with your boss, police or a landlord :/
- vidarh 10y agoAt least in this instance we can avoid this specific persecution by opting to not visit the US.
- zouhair 10y agoSo are you vetting all your friends' friends?
- marme 10y agoif you think this is about terrorism you have not been paying attention. It is to catch money launderers. It has been shown time and time again that people are stupid and post pics of cash, cars, jewelry, etc to social media
- iuguy 10y agoI took a principled stance back in 2001 of not returning to the US until the DHS was disbanded. At the time I felt it was an unnecessary invasion of privacy, and for a country as large as the united states what was needed was better communication and cooperation between local agencies, not federal integration (as I felt this was a states issue, not a federal one). Over time, my views have gradually relaxed, and usually once or twice a year I consider returning to the US. Stuff like this puts me right off, but sadly I know the UK will no doubt follow suit. Also if you think this is ok because it doesn't apply to US citizens, it doesn't apply right now. When it's declared a roaring success, there will no doubt be an attempt to extend it to US citizens.
- briandear 10y agoJust a point of fact, the DHS was created at the end of 2002. As far as the UK, their processes are just as stringent but less public. It is interesting that the UK allows in some radical Islamic clerics but banned an American talk show host who talked about radical Islamic clerics. The U.K. Has some of the strictest immigration in Europe for non Europeans. I am not defending the US or DHS, I am only providing some perspective that the US isn't particularly unique, just more public about it.
- chestnut-tree 10y ago"...the US isn't particularly unique, just more public about it." I agree. I strongly dislike the US proposals discussed here, but the fact is travelling abroad means you've already given up much of your privacy. Those of us in Europe and the US have a somewhat contradictory attitude toward privacy - opposing certain rules or regulations, while happily ignoring others. Take the UK, where the British government has intrusive surveillance laws. A self-serving and apathetic media discourages discussion or opposition to such laws. On the other hand, there was strong opposition against mandatory ID cards when the idea was proposed a few years ago, possibly more to do with the cost of the scheme and little trust in the competency of the government to carry out such a proposal. So, yes we do have a somewhat inconsistent attitude to privacy. Even in Continental Europe (if the country is part of the Schengen area), biometric passports are common. Applying for a passport often means providing your fingerprints - something a lot of people might be uncomfortable doing.
- lars 10y agoI've been going to US tech conferences yearly in the last few years. As of 2016 this has stopped, since the fact that I was snowboarding in Iran in 2011 now means I can't get a visa through ESTA. I now have to take a day off work, fly to Oslo, talk to someone at the US embassy, in order to get a visa. It's just not worth the effort at that point.
- randomsearch 10y agoAnecdote: I know a UK academic who is world-leading in their field and refuses to travel to the US for this reason, has done so for at least a decade.
- codecamper 10y agoGetting into the UK isn't much better. Maybe worse.
- gambiting 10y agoI always wanted to go to US as a kid - now I would actively refuse to.
- Freestyler_3 10y agoI have the same, the US has some pretty places I would want to visit. The way they handle tourists like they are all a threat to the country and are not really welcome, that is what puts me off. Even though the social media question is optional, it raises a flag that you didn't fill it in and you run a higher risk of getting questioned/interrogated at the airport. It saves time for the agents that they don't have to search for someone on social media, but it also makes everyone aware that this is being done. (potentially hurting security because before sending the form a terrorist will now clean up his facebook if he has a dirty profile) This is part of mass surveillance, and at what point will the form say that you have to add agent X to your friends list on social media, so they can snoop around more?? -Where does it stop? For me it stopped a long time ago, I just won't go there. Instead I enjoyed holidays elsewhere around the world. edit- some spelling mistakes.
- blowski 10y agoI have to agree with you. I'm British, my wife is Brazilian and we have a young son with dual nationality. We live in the UK. We were thinking of a family holiday and ruled out the US because of how complicated he visa process is. I'm sure we're not alone.
- Freestyler_3 10y agoYes, at some point the scale tips for a lot of people and the hype of going to the USA is outweighed by the trouble you have trough and the privacy you have to forfeit. For people like you and me, we are aware of this before we get overexcited and commit to the holiday, giving us the freedom to easily choose another destination.
- bemmu 10y agoLast time I visited San Francisco I had border officials twice just suddenly snap at me. While getting my luggage an official just randomly approached me an asked me some random question in an angry tone. Then when in line holding a piece of paper on which I had written my ESTA number, an official came to me and just pulled the paper from my hand, demanding "what's this!?". Additionally they flipped through my entire itinerary. Consider that this is someone's first experience on US soil and it sets the tone for the whole trip. Nothing like this has happened in any of the other countries I've been to, including India, Vietnam, Cambodia etc.