5 ms·
"Any issue that china faces - they seem to figure out how to overcome it." Apart from running a democratic and open society.
by tonyedgecombe 10y ago
"Any issue that china faces - they seem to figure out how to overcome it."
Apart from running a democratic and open society.
- gaius 10y agoYou have it backwards - they see "a democratic and open society" as a problem they have overcome.
- vbezhenar 10y agoUSSR was destroyed by stupid government. I'm not sure about western countries, but democracy might have some tools to prevent stupid presidents to do heavy damage (I'm not sure how exactly, but whatever). So the question is, whether Chinese society was able to build a tools to prevent stupid government to ruin everything. After all, Chinese was terrible poor country not so long ago and for many years. How are they going not to repeat the same mistakes? Western world believes in democracy (at least some people do), but it's not generally accepted truth. I think that democracy is stupid, though I don't have anything better to offer.
- gaius 10y agoI think that democracy is stupid, though I don't have anything better to offer It was Winston Churchill who said that democracy is the worst system of government, apart from every other system that has ever been tried.
- sangnoir 10y agoI think Culture-style benign dictatorship is a better system than democracy, but hadn't been practised yet. As currently practised, democracy tends towards bureaucracy and short-term thinking (projects small enough to fit in a term).
- easuter 10y ago> As currently practised, democracy tends towards bureaucracy and short-term thinking (projects small enough to fit in a term). Not to mention that it can devolve into something that's more of a democracy in name only. Take the upcoming US elections where the choices are, on one hand, a blowhard who wants to build a massive wall to keep out Mexican immigrants, and on the other a corrupt-to-the-core corporate puppet. This isn't much of a real democracy when parties become so big that more competent people have no chance of running for office without the support of said parties.
- tormeh 10y agoThat's just the US's voting system in action. Unfortunately, changing a voting system is almost impossible Because the people with the power to change it are the ones that benefit from the status quo. Britain came really close recently with the Liberals though, but I think that was an exceptional situation and the incumbents managed to convince the populace that a more proportional voting system was a waste of money.
- sangnoir 10y ago> I'm not sure about western countries, but democracy might have some tools to prevent stupid presidents to do heavy damage Democracy also self-contains the tools to undo itself, as long as someone can convince the majority that it's not only a good idea, but prudent to do so. That is why the transition from democracy to fascism and outright dictatorship can happen quickly.
- DasIch 10y agoThat's why militant democracy[1] exists. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Streitbare_Demokratie https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Streitbare_Demokratie
- SolarNet 10y agoThey are working on that too, albeit much slower, but they recently started opening up all the historical archives from previously censored eras.
- nine_k 10y agoIt does not seem like an issue to them. At least, not for their industry. Englandof 1700s was not an open and democratic society either, but it lead the industrial revolution.
- mwfunk 10y agoVery true, but you're overlooking the fact that England of the 1700s was in the 1700s.
- nine_k 10y agoHistory is a pretty local thing. The ideas of democracy and freedom (these are two different, often contradictory things) seem ti be pervasive in Western Europe or North America. This does not mean they are pervasive, or desired, or even understood everywhere in the world, despite the "civilized West"'s attempts at propagating these ideas. Chinese government has a pretty tight grip on the nation's information sources, and has a very significant political and military power. Democracy has no chance to be exported there, as it was exported e.g. to Iraq and Afghanistan (rather unsuccessfully). Chinese government makes a lot of efforts to keep the political system of China under control, without Western-style democracy (and probably any other). It also makes a lot of efforts to keep China producing and selling a lot of stuff, and becoming better and better at it. It's rather successful on both accounts. There are a few examples of countries becoming wild economic successes under quite undemocratic regimes: South Korea and Singapore spring to mind. But both are not Communist (or former Communist, since the Chinese seem to have abolished much of their previous communism). Maybe this is why the didn't look so suspicious to the Western public.
- df41 10y agoA funny thing is when I was talking to a lot of friends in China recently, while they like america in general, they believe the Chinese system is superior to the western "democracy". Do not get me wrong, they blame the Chinese government for many things rather fiercely at the same time. I somehow feel like they are overly optimistic but could not find any proof to refute their point (talking about the current US election clearly did not help...). They are mostly upper middle class who worth more than me. So I guess they may be biased? However the taxi drivers seem to have the same view. An anecdote: none of them want to immigrate (at least to US) and their only major concern seems to be the air quality. Since they can buy everything else from overseas anyway.
- ahartman00 10y agoAnd we have yet to see how they plan to: deal with an aging population(due to the 1 kid rule), deal with the health effects of all the air pollution, and clean up their environment. And as their population becomes more tech savvy, and presumably figures out how to bypass the firewall and thus the censorship and propaganda, they might very well have to figure out a democratic and open society.
- gaius 10y agodeal with an aging population(due to the 1 kid rule) First they gotta deal with the gender imbalance problem - literally 10s of millions of young men for whom there is no possibility of finding a partner, because the one child policy led to many female babies being discarded. Take a bunch of angry young men who see no future for themselves and you get what's happening now in Afghanistan...
- ahartman00 10y agogood point, tongue in cheek response here: easy, that's a propaganda problem. tell them the enemy stole our women or something like that :P