3 ms·
We need to start just de-trusting CAs that do this crap. Yes, websites will break. That will put pressure on site owners to only choose responsible CAs, and tha
by andrewflnr 10y ago
We need to start just de-trusting CAs that do this crap. Yes, websites will break. That will put pressure on site owners to only choose responsible CAs, and that market pressure is the only thing that can solve this problem.
- akerro 10y agohttps://f-droid.org/repository/browse/?fdfilter=cert&fdid=info.guardianproject.cacert https://f-droid.org/repository/browse/?fdfilter=cert&fdid=in... Android 4+ allows you to disable certificates from the system Settings and root isn't required, so try that first if you want to manually mess with the certificates. The app won't work with Android 4+ anyway. An app to manage security certificates on your phone also containing a version of the Android CACert keystore derived from Mozilla. If a certificate has recently become untrusted you can either install an update to this app or you can backup and remove certificates by yourself.
- alcari 10y agoWe can do it without breaking websites: a TLS implementer could reject all certificates issued by a particular CA after a certain date. (For the obvious issue) WoSign's recent certificates are in the CT logs and they're promising to put in all their 2015 certificates as well, so they could be whitelisted.
- 0x0 10y agoOne of the problems here was that they were back-dating certificates...
- alcari 10y agoThat's what I included "for the obvious issue": even in the backdated certificates they still have "reasonable" notAfter dates, and we (will) have a list of every certificate they've issued in the relevant time span. Some people are also calling for every certificate they've ever issued to be added to the CT logs, but I doubt that'll happen.
- mjevans 10y agoIf a CA 'lies' we shouldn't trust anything they've ever said anymore. That's why they should be de-listed.
- andrewflnr 10y agoOf course, that too. I guess most of my point was to handle the pragmatic "but you'll break everything" objection. You can't quite dismiss this out of hand on principle alone, as much as I'd like to.