5 ms·
I wonder why car manufacturers still use direct force transmission with hugely complex (and in case of ignoring the instructions, outright dangerous) like 4WD/A
by mschuster91 10y ago
I wonder why car manufacturers still use direct force transmission with hugely complex (and in case of ignoring the instructions, outright dangerous) like 4WD/AWD instead of diesel-electric or diesel-hydraulic systems like on locomotives.
A computer could instantly shift torque with both of the hybrid solutions, you wouldn't need a clutch or a gearbox any more, not to mention cheap all-wheel-drive including the trailer in trucks. And a fuel-electric drivetrain could easily plug in a battery or supercaps for braking energy recuperation, and the fuel engine could always run at peak efficiency/exhaust gas condition...
- kinofcain 10y agoThe diesel-electric/hydraulic systems are used in situations where the gearing ratio would have to be absurdly high, they're not used because they're efficient or because they have good torque vectoring capabilities. The electric motor can produce nearly 100% of torque at zero RPM, which helps locomotives get several million pounds of train moving. In your car, truck, or even semi, first gear plus some clutch/torque converter slippage is plenty of mechanical advantage to get going, and once you're underway, a lockup torque converter or a fully engaged clutch is more efficient than the combination of an electric generator and a motor. There's also the matter of power distribution, if you have four independent electric motors, you can only ever send 25% of available torque to one wheel, if you have front, rear, and center lockers, you can send 100% of torque to one wheel.
- 4ad 10y ago> a lockup torque converter or a fully engaged clutch is more efficient than the combination of an electric generator and a motor. I doubt it, generators and motors operate at 99% efficiency. Do you have any reference? > if you have four independent electric motors, you can only ever send 25% of available torque to one wheel, if you have front, rear, and center lockers, you can send 100% of torque to one wheel. That assumes that engines are so small that they operate at 100% under normal conditions. This doesn't have to be the case, electric engines are so small, you can have bigger-sized engines where one single engine can use all the power. The nature of electric engine is such that the loss of efficiency by doing this is minimal. Plus you need to do this only fractions of the time, so the engine doesn't have to be designed to operate in high power mode at full duty cycle.
- kinofcain 10y ago> I doubt it, generators and motors operate at 99% efficiency. Do you have any reference? A locked up torque converter or an engaged clutch is basically a solid steel bar. You're the one that is going to need to provide sources that show an electric generator and motor, operating in series, are 99% efficient across a wide operating range. (you won't find that that's true). >That assumes that engines are so small that they operate at 100% under normal conditions. This doesn't have to be the case, electric engines are so small, you can have bigger-sized engines where one single engine can use all the power. The nature of electric engine is such that the loss of efficiency by doing this is minimal. Plus you need to do this only fractions of the time, so the engine doesn't have to be designed to operate in high power mode at full duty cycle. Look up the efficiency of electric motors running outside of their optimum power/rpm ranges. Also, you basically just said that you can get around a percentage problem by increasing the coefficient, which kind of misses the point. Also, if you're going to put four motors, you're probably doing that because you want to put them in the hubs, (if you're putting them inboard, you'd just use one or two motors and put a differential in there, like Tesla does), if you're putting motors in your hubs you want the smallest motors you can get away with, because larger motors increase unsprung weight.
- samwillis 10y agoThe Jaguar C-X75 [1] concept car uses exactly this idea, it uses a tiny and very efficient jet engine that is charging the batteries. Very neat idea. 1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jaguar_C-X75 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jaguar_C-X75
- mschuster91 10y agoWhat the f..k. Thanks for that link, a jet engine?! That's crazy. But it's the "awesome" kind of crazy. And the CO2 values... wow, how is that possible? Burning a defined amount of fuel should always produce the same amount of CO2?
- maxerickson 10y agoI assume the CO2 values factor in the electric only range.
- dredmorbius 10y agoGas turbines operate efficiently at constant output, which a hybrid-drive system with storage can manage. They only need to kick out enough power, on average, to keep the storage system fully charged. Batteries and eletric motors can handle both high-demand accelleration, and regenerative braking. Since the turbines are running at a very constant range, and can be rated to average out power load inclusive of idle times, they can be designed for optimum efficiency within that range. Or that's the theory. There've been other gas-turbine automobiles, including some prototypes built in the 1960s. A friend of mine test drove one, claimed it could lay a patch (spin the tires) at highway speeds. Though my understanding is that in direct-drive applications (such as that), turbine lag is an issue. The exhaust also runs quite hot, and turbines typically emit a lot of NOx (nitrous oxides), what you get when you run atmospheric nitrogen through a high-temperature field. Much anecdata here, apply salt liberally.
- mikeash 10y agoFor anyone interested in turbines and cars, there's a delightful episode of Jay Leno's Garage about a Chrysler turbine car: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b2A5ijU3Ivs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b2A5ijU3Ivs He talks extensively about how it works, what it's like to drive, and the various difficulties that resulted in it never entering mass production.
- mikeash 10y agoMechanical transmissions are still more efficient, at least for cars, than spinning a generator that then powers an electric motor. Even hybrids usually have a way to get the engine power directly to the wheel. In the Prius's system, it uses a planetary gear with a pair of electric motor/generators which allow it to split power between the mechanical and electrical paths. In the Volt, there are clutches which allow the car to transition between parallel and serial hybrid modes.
- 4ad 10y ago> Mechanical transmissions are still more efficient, at least for cars, than spinning a generator that then powers an electric motor. Do you have a reference? Since both electric generators and motors well exceed 99% efficiency at this power level, I don't see how can this be the case.
- mikeash 10y agoDo you? I can't dig up anything particularly good, but what I do find indicates in the mid-90% for practical electric motor efficiencies. This says 85-95% efficiency for the motor in an EV: https://matter2energy.wordpress.com/2013/02/22/wells-to-wheels-electric-car-efficiency/ https://matter2energy.wordpress.com/2013/02/22/wells-to-whee... This says 93% for a brushless DC motor: http://electronics.stackexchange.com/questions/58236/why-does-a-tesla-car-use-an-ac-motor-instead-of-a-dc-one http://electronics.stackexchange.com/questions/58236/why-doe... I found a bunch more of similar quality searching for "ev motor efficiency" and similar. I'm not particularly satisfied with those, so if you have something better, I'd love to see it!
- Gracana 10y agoAnd don't forget, you have generator efficiency to deal with as well. If you're 90% on both sides, the system is only 81% efficient. Ouch!
- ptaipale 10y agoLocomotives are used on railroad tracks. Adding weight does not matter. Cars generally suffer quite a lot if you add significant weight: both performance and fuel economy will be hit. That is why locomotive solutions are not very suitable for cars.