5 ms·
> Is there some nuance of the direction that I don't understand? I think the point is that the existing large-scale federalist states are all conceived as top-
by toyg 10y ago
> Is there some nuance of the direction that I don't understand?
I think the point is that the existing large-scale federalist states are all conceived as top-down: a central authority makes (most of) the rules, and lower rings have to suck it up.
The European project is supposed to be a bottom-up, consensus-driven setup where each member-state brings its best contributions and persuades the others to "level up". That's how the best EU directives were born.
In a way, even the Euro was something like that, with Germany persuading others that a "common Deutschmark" was a superior setup for the common currency they had agreed to implement (in exchange for letting them re-annexe East Germany); and overall it was, at the time, when compared to weak inflation-ridden and debt-burdened currencies like the Franc, the Lira and so on. The problem is that circumstances change, and the German model turned out to be very inflexible for economies that significantly differ from the German one. So now a consensus is emerging that the setup needs changing. A similar situation in the US or Australia would be fixed with a few decrees and simple majorities; in the EU that would be unacceptable. Alliances and majorities have to be built from the ground up, and they have to conceive a compromise that will satisfy most member states.