3 ms·
> Enterprises now want to disrupt themselves, because it 1) hurts their existing competitors and 2) creates moats against startups. Do they really want that? O
by wpietri 10y ago
> Enterprises now want to disrupt themselves, because it 1) hurts their existing competitors and 2) creates moats against startups.
Do they really want that? Or just say that want it? As comparison, everybody says that they want to get in better shape. But how many put in the work?
I think there's an enormous amount of money to be made (and probably, being made right now) in going to existing large companies and selling them "innovation" consulting that gives them the feeling of change without doing anything actually hard. It's the equivalent of buying low-fat cookies and calling it a day.
In practice I expect very, very few of these companies to actually do anything meaningfully different. As an example of that, look at how "agile" has changed over the years. 90% of shops I talk to where people are "doing Agile" are actually doing mini-waterfall. It's the same old bullshit with new labels and a slightly faster release cadence.
That's not to say that startups will do any better on average. So many people chased unicorn status without any thought of building actual businesses. But I still expect the startups with a clue to do a fine job going after large companies in the low-fat cookies camp.
- jacques_chester 10y ago> Do they really want that? Or just say that want it? Some. Some not. My argument was against the stereotype of complacency, which itself inspires a different kind of complacency. I've got skin in this game, having been one of the handsomely-billed consultants (for Pivotal Labs) until transferring into Cloud R&D. So I'll tell this joke before someone else tells it. It's adapted, of course, from a joke about therapists. Q: How many agile consultants does it to change a lightbulb? A: One, but the lightbulb has to want to change.
- lgleason 10y agoYou've hit the nail on the head.
- devonkim 10y agoThere seems to be a trend among Fortune 100 management that belief = reality. This attitude makes sense perhaps if you're a personal trainer to help motivate people but management doesn't seem to understand that they need to shape up and convince a fairly low engagement workforce that they're all in it together and that they know what they did in the past isn't how they're going to run things in the future. This can be accomplished by hiring well-known rather than well-connected leadership, firing old managers, and rewarding employees in ways not seen before.
- wpietri 10y ago> There seems to be a trend among Fortune 100 management that belief = reality. That makes total sense to me. The larger a top-down organization is, the more the people on top exist in a reality that is socially mediated. That's especially true given that the theory of the MBA is that it's a universal management degree, meaning that knowledge of the domain is at best secondary. In a social context, confidence is very appealing. Strong belief becomes executives' reality.