3 ms·
Lets go further: nationalize drug companies. Do this to all the drugs.
by JoeAltmaier 10y ago
Lets go further: nationalize drug companies. Do this to all the drugs.
- cheriot 10y agoMaybe someone more familiar with the biotech industry will comment, but it's my impression there have been some market success as well. Keeping that incentive to innovate is important.
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoHa! Like they've been innovating in antibiotics for 40 years? In case folks have not been paying attention, zero innovation occurred there. Currently its all about restless legs and secondary asthma relief and snake-oil mixtures of drugs rebranded under goofy names. The drug companies have largely abdicated their responsibilities. For profit. What remains are money-making shells. Can't we just do without them? They are adding friction at this point.
- cheriot 10y agoAntibiotics do provide a good case for increased public research. I suspect medicine will always have parts that are done better publicly and others better in private hands. For example, a tour guide in one poor country I visited mentioned that he knew guides that were trained doctors. Because good tour guides there make more money than doctors. Coincidentally, they also have a shortage of doctors. Kind of like America having a shortage of teachers when governments set the salary.
- GunboatDiplomat 10y agoI think it would make more sense to simply have a government owned corporation who's sole purpose is to produce generic drugs on which the patent has expired.
- maxerickson 10y agoThe market for drugs like that generally functions quite well. Like a cash price of ~$5 a month well. (The dustup over Martin Shkreli raising the price of Daraprim only happened because there were very few users of the drug)
- cheriot 10y agoSome drugs, like the cure for Hepatitis C, need to be available more widely before the patent runs out. It's a cure and only people that can come up with $84,000 dollars.
- ccvannorman 10y agoHear, hear! One can argue against this saying Capitalism is the panacea of the market, but one only needs to look at ANY OTHER FIRST WORLD NATION (99% of them have nationalized health care and pay less to get better care than us) to see that we're CLEARLY doing it wrong here.
- privateersman 10y agoI would be interested to see how the output of drug companies change after they are nationalised. Like would they focus on simple solutions that solve problems (rather than expensive solutions that hide problems)? And would they struggle at being yet another public service with a huge budget to be cut. Will their best staff move abroad for better salaries? Stuff like that.
- shubb 10y agoI suspect surgery can give us some interesting insights here. My understanding is that surgery research mostly takes place at university hospitals. I think that, outside medical devices, there isn't the same kind of non-practising science industry behind surgery research - it's all done by surgeons at research hospitals. Research hospitals tend to be university hospitals and outside (and even inside) the US, university hospitals tend to be loosely government controlled. So if we want to know what state controlled medical research could look like, I guess we just look to surgery.
- yostrovs 10y agoHow about nationalizing all companies? Start with farmers since food is even more important than drugs. Make sure to throw away history books first.